Can Schools Be Fully Accountable for Learning?

In this video, Dr. Justin Baeder discusses why student learning depends on student effort, not just teacher performance or school accountability.

Key Takeaways

  • Students Have Agency - Learning requires student effort, attention, and cognitive participation; it can't simply be done to students.
  • Teaching Isn't the Same as Learning - A teacher can deliver an excellent lesson and still have students who don't learn because they choose not to engage.
  • Accountability Has Limits - Educators should not accept total responsibility for outcomes that depend partly on student choices beyond their control.
  • Practice Matters More Than Scores Alone - Test results don't tell the whole story, so leaders need to examine teacher practice and student behavior together.
  • Education Isn't Manufacturing - Schools teach every student, not just the easiest ones, so accountability systems must reflect that reality.

Full Transcript

Students are not inanimate objects, and whenever we want to take responsibility for student learning or hold schools accountable for student learning, we have to remember that students themselves play a crucial role in their learning. I don't believe that learning can take place without a student applying effort, right? Students have to try. They have to put forth mental effort in order to learn. You can't just sit kids in a chair and hit play...

So, I think we need to push back on this idea that's been around for many years that sounds right. This idea that...

That if the students haven't learned, the teacher hasn't taught it. Have you heard that phrase? If the students haven't learned, the teacher hasn't taught. I actually don't think that's true. I think we can teach a lesson, everything can be perfect, we can do a great job, it can be the best possible lesson...

And if a student does not try, if a student does not pay attention, if a student does not do the work, they will not learn. And of course, there are things we can do to motivate, there are things we can do to create the conditions under which students are most likely to learn.

But students still have agency. They still have free will. They are not inanimate objects that we can do learning to, right? Students are not widgets.

It's not like manufacturing. And if you look at how manufacturing works, like, if you want to produce a quality product as a manufacturer, There are only certain raw materials that will do, right? You can't take bad raw materials and make a good product.

You have to reject the bad raw materials, or else it's going to ruin your product. And in education, we accept all raw materials, right? We don't say, well, those students aren't going to try very hard, so we're not going to teach them at all.

No, like, part of the point of education is that it's for everybody, so we teach things to kids who might not try on purpose. We know going into it that that is going to happen. And I think that means something important for how we think about accountability, how we think about responsibility.

What I don't think we can do is throw that student component out the window and take total responsibility. We cannot take responsibility for things that are beyond our control. I think when we are trying to do the best we can, we should look at what is actually happening, not just results, right?

Like, you can't look at test scores and say, well, I know how good a job the teacher was doing from these test scores. And not look at practice. You have to actually look at teacher practice and look at what the students are doing to see where the disconnect is.

And if you've ever proctored a standardized test, you know exactly what I mean. It's so frustrating to give a test and see a student just click through all the questions and be done in five minutes when you know it would take them an hour

and you know they know a lot of the material. Students have to participate in showing their learning, but they also have to participate cognitively in doing the learning.

Let me know what you think.

instructional leadership grading assessment school improvement walkthroughs evaluation
Want to go deeper?

Want to go deeper?

ILA members get weekly video episodes, on-demand video courses, and the full Ascend career toolkit — including AI coaching to help you build your portfolio and nail your next interview.

Start Your Free Trial →