Creating Purpose and Consistency for Students with Project-Based Learning

Follow on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · more apps

About Amy Baeder

Dr Amy Baeder is an independent education consultant supporting instructional excellence through project-based learning. Dr. Baeder is the Director of the Project-Based Learning Network, which supports teachers across the United States and 43 countries.

Full Transcript

[00:01] Announcer:

Welcome to Principal Center Radio, helping you build capacity for instructional leadership. Here's your host, Director of the Principal Center, Dr. Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.

[00:13] SPEAKER_01:

I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to be joined today by Dr. Amy Bader. Amy is the director of the Project-Based Learning Network and the creator of the PBL Curriculum Developer Certification Program. And we're here today to talk about creating purpose and consistency for students with project-based learning.

[00:33] Announcer:

And now, our feature presentation.

[00:35] SPEAKER_01:

Amy, welcome to Principal Center Radio.

[00:37] SPEAKER_00:

Thanks for having me.

[00:38] SPEAKER_01:

So, we're recording this in the middle of May 2020, when the current school year is wrapping up. It kind of got disrupted in a rather unusual way, and there's still a lot of uncertainty about what school will look like when it resumes in the fall and how the coming year will unfold. What opportunities and what circumstance do you see that we're in with regard to curriculum, Amy?

[01:03] SPEAKER_00:

Yeah, so, when school stopped for us in March, I think teachers were scrambling to get something together. Administrators were scrambling to figure out what school could look like when, in many cases, teachers hadn't had a chance to plan. There were not devices issued to each student. Remote learning and distance learning or online learning, whichever one of those terms you use, that was pretty novel for some of our teachers and for some of our students. So, going into the spring of this year, this was unprecedented and unplanned for. And going into the fall, however, we have a chance to really get this right, to think through what online or distance or remote learning could look like, and really embed some of those principles of project-based learning To start the year off strong, even if that means that we start in an online setting or if we start in person, we have a sense of what that could look like.

[01:55]

And we have a sense of, um, what students could do that could be a little bit more purposeful than what we ended up having this spring in a lot of cases.

[02:03] SPEAKER_01:

Yeah, and it seems like a lot of the learning curve for the first wave of reaction that we did as educators was around figuring out how to continue what we were doing in more or less the same way online, right? We take the same kinds of activities, the same kind of ways of interacting, and put them online. And, you know, that was kind of our best first attempt. What are some of the bigger questions that we might want to be asking ourselves as we kind of re-envision and re-imagine what learning could look like in the new year?

[02:35] SPEAKER_00:

For sure. I think a lot of times teachers were taking technology, uh, like Google Classroom, and they were replicating, like you said, what was happening in the classroom without thinking through how they could really leverage the technology. So, uh, that toe dip into technology used for a lot of teachers, and I'm not saying that that's all teachers. Many teachers have mastered using things like Flipgrid or Google Classroom in ways that...

[02:59]

that do leverage technology, but for the broader teaching core, I think that this was new, and this was a new way of interacting with their students. And so thinking through what we could do to support collaboration, to support ways for students to show their learning in different ways, to support ways for them to be citizen scientists, or to explore primary documents, things like that, that really highlight the use of technology in ways that help students advance their understanding of the content.

[03:32] SPEAKER_01:

Yeah, and I think, you know, one of the big obsessions, I will say, you know, for better or for worse, one of the big obsessions early on in this shift has been around video conferencing. You know, are we allowed to use Zoom? Do we need to use Microsoft Teams? Should we meet every day? Should we have some sort of staggered schedule where we check in every so often on video with...

[03:53]

our students with our classes, and I am hearing a lot of pushback and a lot of kind of people being at their limit when it comes to being in these online meetings with their students all day. And I wonder what opportunities you see coming our way in getting students actively learning and doing work from home without specifically being on technology the entire time. Because certainly, you know, we don't want our own kids on iPads all day. You know, if the opportunity were there for our kids to be in a Zoom meeting, you know, six hours a day, we probably would not be happy with that.

[04:29] SPEAKER_00:

Absolutely, and as someone who's been there and tried to kind of mediate FaceTime calls or Zoom meetings with our kiddos and their classmates or friends, it's exhausting just to be on that mediation side, let alone with a classroom of students. So, props to those of you who are working in that space, but just know that remote learning can look a lot different, and especially with project-based learning, it doesn't mean that students are sitting in front of a device for the duration of the class time that you have with them, ideally they'd be creating something, they could be launched into the work in a digital space, or given their assignment in that way, and demonstrate their learning in that way, but maybe the core of their learning happens with pencil and paper, or with some sort of materials that they're using, manipulatives, things that they could access in ways that aren't always just eyes on a screen 100% of the time.

[05:23]

So, I think that there's definitely some creative thinking that we can do around that so that we're thinking more of PBL in a remote learning setting rather than just digital or online.

[05:32] SPEAKER_01:

Now, I know one of the big elements of your Curriculum Developer Certification program is around finding a real-world problem for students to tackle. Like, the authenticity of the problem is a lot of what makes a PBL curriculum motivating to students. And I think as this pandemic has unfolded, we've seen things like making masks or solving scheduling problems or, you know, just solving real problems for people in the community or in the broader world. What opportunities do you see for teachers to engage their students in solving some of those problems through PBL?

[06:10] SPEAKER_00:

For sure. So I think initially, when this all went down, everyone was super excited about sending out links and resources to free, you know, um, maybe there's a Facebook Live at a zoo, or there are online, um, things that kids can do, and so people are sending links around, and links and... There's link overload, right? And so I think that what PBL can do is streamline that so that there is consistency, there is purpose behind the work that students are doing, behind the links that they're accessing, and that the project-based learning arc actually gives a story for why kids are doing what they do.

[06:45]

Another thing that we've noticed is that without having sports, without having the daily work that people are doing, the school that kids are going to, I've seen families and individuals being drawn to creating a family project of some sort. Maybe it's a garden. Maybe it's, um, we just got a bunch of caterpillars in so we could raise butterflies.

[07:06] SPEAKER_01:

So it's been interesting to see families pick up on projects like, as you said, a garden or maybe a baking project, you know. flour and yeast and sugar were sold out for weeks at a time in our area, and as we think about how teachers can apply that same drive to create something, to develop a solution, to build something, what are some of the design constraints that we might be working within that we might feel like make that difficult, or maybe even make it impossible, but if we're creative about it, if we're resourceful, could actually be just the thing that makes a project amazing?

[07:40] SPEAKER_00:

I think that in any community that there are community-wide problems that can be solved. And I think we often underestimate what our students are able to do with a little bit of direction and a little bit of encouragement. Um, it's amazing that kids even, you know, even elementary age kids are able to pull things off if they have the work scaffolded, if they have direction, if they have a reason for doing what they do. So it might be that the first step in any project is to really figure out what real-world problems exist in our community and what can be done for kids of all ages. And then think about how that connects to the standards that you're working within and the learning objectives that you're working within, because there are things that we can do that can benefit our community.

[08:24] SPEAKER_01:

Absolutely. And I think back to, you mentioned just a moment ago, all the links that were circulating, and we've seen the limits of the virtual museum tour, and the YouTube videos, and the, you know, and anything pre-recorded. Like, we've seen the limits of simply being passive as an absorber of information. So I think we've all seen a lot of inspiring examples, maybe on social media or maybe in the news, of kids who took it upon themselves to solve particular problems in their community. Uh, maybe early on with sewing masks and with, uh, birthday parties, you know, celebrating graduations and birthdays and weddings and things like that with, uh, different creative approaches. But when it comes to identifying problems that we can have our students solve as part of a standards-based unit, uh, what should we be looking for in terms of identifying those problems and figuring out how to kind of draw some boundaries around those problems so that they're actually a good fit for teaching the content that we need to teach?

[09:27]

What do you look for when you're designing a curriculum in terms of a problem that students can meaningfully work on?

[09:34] SPEAKER_00:

Well, I think, you know, in school, we often get so far away from the kinds of things that students are actually interested in or that feel purposeful to students that sometimes just coming back to the basics of the kinds of things that we deal with in our daily lives can actually be real-world problems that students are excited about solving. Another piece that I look at is what needs are there in the community and how can students make someone else's life better? Um, I think, in particular, at this time, of people in nursing homes and people who might be even more socially isolated than they were before. and how students might engage in, in that way. Um, often, it's, there's an empathy component, um, and a social and emotional learning component that relate to the problems. Um, as a biology person, I'm always thinking about the natural world, and I'm thinking about what students can observe, and what students can contribute in a citizen science realm.

[10:33]

So, even though we can't be in crowded public places, we can be in nature, and we can... Act as observers and act as scientists and start tracking some things that might solve a real-world problem. So, there are things that can be done even if we're not all together in a classroom.

[10:50] SPEAKER_01:

Well, I know you spend quite a bit of time on that particular topic in the certification program around finding a good problem, a problem that's, you know, within a reasonable scope that students can address and linking that to standards. What are your thoughts on creating consistency Given that we have so much uncertainty about how the coming school year is going to look, you know, right now, and again, we're recording this mid-May, there are a lot of proposals and guidelines on the table right now about, you know, spacing between student desks and reduced numbers of students coming to school at one time, and alternate schedules, and we may have, you know, rolling waves of closures here and there. Given the high likelihood of disruption, what do you see as some of the ways that we can use project-based learning to create a sense of kind of long-term continuity and stability for students, just knowing that we're expecting some disruption?

[11:41] SPEAKER_00:

Yeah, so I think that we're actually in a pretty good place, it being May, and having some time to prepare for the fall, um, because we did not have that for the spring, and I know that teachers were, um, building the plane while flying it, and did not feel great about that, and working very hard to... make sure they were connecting with their students and making sure that they were, um, feeling like they were giving students what they needed. Well, at this point, with summer coming up, I think that whether we are primarily in a digital space or an in-person space, um, we'll have a way to plan for that and to provide students with consistency. And, um, I know that there's one Washington state Um, university that's going to be online for the fall that I know of, and there are some, uh, universities in Arkansas that will be in person in the fall.

[12:32]

And each district I know will face different challenges in figuring out what that looks like. However, what PBL can provide is a sense of consistency. So even if things change, even if I'm in front of my classmates one week and we have to reconsider as, as flu season, you know, comes about and, and illnesses of COVID-19 might come back. Um, we will have our project to work on, and we will have our classmates to work with, and we'll have purposeful work in that project, whether it is online or in person. So that should be the common thread, is that, you know, even if things change in our configurations, in our seating arrangements, things like that, we're still working on our project, and we have a sense of meaningful work ahead of us.

[13:20] SPEAKER_01:

Well, as you said, it was kind of a scramble to figure this out in the spring of the 19-20 school year because we didn't know it was coming, we didn't know what it would require, and just the logistics of taking things online and providing resources to students remotely and figuring out how to best support them, you know, really didn't give us the opportunity to be proactive. But we do have the opportunity to be proactive for the fall, for the new school year. And if people want to learn what the process of developing a high-quality PBL unit looks like, talk to us about the roadmap and what they'll learn from the roadmap.

[13:57] SPEAKER_00:

Well, with the roadmap, I have tried to think about what process I go through when I plan a high-quality High-performance, project-based learning unit. So, I think about where do I start, what steps do I take, and where, um, I end up. And often, I get inspiration from the standards that I need to address, of course, and then things that I might see in the news, current events, um, real-world problems that I will happen upon. And then try to pull those together. So how do the standards address the real-world problems and vice versa? And then once I've done that, I scope out a series of lessons that address that very problem.

[14:39]

And I think through what kind of product I want students to create, um, that would demonstrate their understanding and what kind of real-world audience they might share that with. And again, this might not be a real-world audience that's all, you know, congregated in my classroom, but it might be a digital audience or a way that students could film their work and share that more broadly. So if you go to amybader.com forward slash roadmap, you'll find the roadmap that I'm talking about and the step-by-step process that I go through. Additionally...

[15:13]

I think it's important for school and district leaders who are advocating for project-based learning in their setting for you to take a look at the steps that I like to lead leaders through when they start to talk about PBL with their staff and the kinds of things that they'll need to experience and have others experience if they're going to take this on in their own setting. Of course, you know, not every site will have to go through every single one of these steps, but it is helpful for you to see the kinds of things that you'll need to think through

[15:43] SPEAKER_01:

So, again, people can download that roadmap both for school and district leaders and for teachers that walks through every stage of the process of developing PBL units at amybader.com slash roadmap. And, Amy, can you talk a little bit about what that process looks like for teachers who are developing their own units?

[16:02] SPEAKER_00:

Sure, so, the first thing is, you will not go through this in a step one, step two, step three kind of fashion, even though I have these numbered. Um, you kind of go through them in stages, and they go back and forth. So, it might be that you start with a project or a product idea And then go back to figure out what skills, concepts, and knowledge you need to teach and link those to standards. It may be that you have a real-world audience identified before you even start thinking through steps one, two, and three. Um, so that's the first, the first piece is just, it's not as linear as I make it look, but I didn't want to introduce you to the PBL web for teachers. This is actually a little bit better, a little clearer, so you can see what you need to go through.

[16:42]

The second piece is that I've found that the most successful individuals that go through the PBL CDC, they are going through, in teams or partners, and that is because I think they hold each other accountable, they're able to help each other, and I think that there's just something about being successful in designing a PBL unit when you're not alone. So, I did want to mention that, and of course, if you are an individual, I would be there to help you, but it is so neat to see colleagues going through this process together, because they're in the same context, and it's just, there's something about working with someone else from your school, so...

[17:20] SPEAKER_01:

Absolutely, and really being able to not only share the work, you know, and reduce the workload on each person, but really to collaborate and develop a unit that is better than any one person could. And I'm thinking back to some of the schools that have sent their entire staff through the CDC To develop those units, to work together, to get feedback on their units, and then launch them with their actual students. It's just been amazing to see in the group where people publish those and share their success stories. Just tremendous what teachers can do when they work together and follow that process. So, Amy, if people want to go online and learn more about your work, where's the best place for them to find you?

[18:00] SPEAKER_00:

AmyBader.com.

[18:01] SPEAKER_01:

Well, Amy, thank you so much for joining me on Principal Center Radio.

[18:03] SPEAKER_00:

It's been my pleasure.

[18:05] Announcer:

Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at principalcenter.com slash radio.

Bring This Expertise to Your School

Interested in professional development, keynotes, or workshops? Send us a message below.

Inquire About Professional Development with Amy Baeder

We'll be happy to make an introduction.