Trauma-Informed Tier I Supports

Follow on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · more apps

About Chris and Courtney Daikos

Chris and Courtney Daikos are the co-founders of Continua Consulting Group, where they help schools and their communities implement trauma-informed multi-tiered systems of support.

Full Transcript

[00:01] SPEAKER_01:

Welcome to Principal Center Radio, bringing you the best in professional practice.

[00:06] Announcer:

Here's your host, director of the Principal Center, and champion of high-performance instructional leadership, Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.

[00:15] SPEAKER_01:

I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to welcome back to the show my good friends Chris and Courtney Dykos. Chris and Courtney are the co-founders of Continua Consulting Group, where they help schools and their communities implement trauma-informed, multi-tiered systems of support.

[00:32] Announcer:

And now, our feature presentation.

[00:34] SPEAKER_01:

Chris and Courtney, welcome back to Principal Center Radio. Thank you.

[00:37] SPEAKER_00:

Thanks, Justin. Great to be with you.

[00:38] SPEAKER_01:

We're here today to talk about Tier 1 and how to assess and teach Tier 1 and how to work with a school district or a community to implement those Tier 1 interventions, especially with regard to the research around student trauma. And I think the state of RTI in our profession is finally getting to the point where we're recognizing that intervention and supporting students' needs is not just about what we do on a pull-out basis, it's not just what we do in self-contained programs, it's not just what we do when kids have exceptional needs that need to be addressed individually, but that at a foundational level, at a Tier 1 level, There are things we need to do as a school, as a system, as a community, to support our students who really can succeed, but need that extra support. What are you doing around Tier 1 in your work with schools and systems and districts?

[01:31] SPEAKER_00:

So we're taking the approach in supporting schools that, first of all, as you described, Tier 1 is what we universally do for all students, and... For everyone who's familiar with the RTI or the MTSS pyramid, when Tier 1 is really strong, it should meet the needs of about 80% of the population. What we often find in going into schools is that there are some strong things happening in Tier 1, and then there are often other things that are not very consistent. And being consistent for kids, especially kids who've experienced trauma, but really for all kids, is really important.

[02:03]

And so a lot of our work often in schools is just identifying Well, let's start with some additional definitions, because we'll be deep in alphabet soup today.

[02:19] SPEAKER_01:

I wonder if you could define for us, what is RTI and MTSS, and how do those two concepts fit together?

[02:24] SPEAKER_02:

So, response to intervention, um, came out of the public health model. Um, it's just a three-tiered system. It's data-based decision-making. The, the public health model is at the Tier 1 level. 80% of all needs are met based off example being such as, um, smoking. I, I would say 100% of us all know that smoking's not good for your health.

[02:43]

Well, how did that happen? How did that information get out? It got through public service announcements. It got through teaching in, in health classes. it got through public information being disseminated. You even see it on billboards now.

[02:55]

And so, with that information, 80% of people's needs were met. Um, if you go to the Tier 2 level, for that example, it would be something like going to this drugstore and getting Nicorette, or getting the patch, or something along those lines. That is the specialized intervention. When we get to the Tier 3 level for smoking, the example would be going to your doctor, going to some sort of practitioner that's going to provide supports for you, potentially going to a mental health practitioner, or even hypnosis works with smoking. So, that would be the individualized intervention at a tier three level. And that's what the public health model was based off, and that's where RTI comes from.

[03:31]

From there, RTI, when you partner up PBIS, or basically common language, common expectations, environmental interventions, such as like PBIS, You add that on there, and that's what we call MTSS.

[03:46] SPEAKER_01:

And PBIS being Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports, is that right?

[03:51] SPEAKER_02:

Correct. So what we've taken further from this is to add on to the bottom of that pyramid cultural responsive pedagogy and trauma-informed practice.

[04:00] SPEAKER_00:

Just to be really clear, then, that Chris gave the analogy of the smoking public health interventions that have happened. From that public health model, that pyramid, RTI, response to intervention, has been practiced in schools and school districts for serving students with academic needs. So, response to intervention for reading, response to intervention for math, Setting up what do all students receive in Tier 1, and what are the additional supports for students in both Tiers 2 and 3, depending on need, that practice has been established for a few decades in the education realm. To be really clear, what PBIS has packaged are really strong Tier 1 interventions, and the remainder of their Tier 2 and 3 interventions actually come from special ed and other research. And so, we're always cautious to give credit to PBIS for Tier 2 and 3 interventions that they didn't really invent, if that makes sense.

[04:50] SPEAKER_01:

So we have a number of different concepts that work together, and in your work specifically, you focused on helping school districts build leadership capacity and build staff understanding and build systems for specifically trauma-informed Tier 1 supports. And I know long-time listeners of Principal Center Radio might recall my interviews with Paul Tuff about his books, and you might have heard Paul Tuff on This American Life. He has some great books on the kind of trauma-informed research And the idea of ACE scores, Adverse Childhood Experiences, and knowing that in a lot of our communities, a large number of students have very high ACE scores, have had a number of adverse or traumatic childhood experiences, what are you helping school districts do to provide those Tier 1 supports with that kind of trauma-informed perspective?

[05:42] SPEAKER_00:

So, just to clarify, our current work in several schools is focused on Tier 1, but the trauma-informed MTSS model that we're teaching, um, has Tiers 2 and 3 in it as well. But you gave a great description of the fact that many kids are dealing with adverse childhood experiences, and so what we believe is foundational for the entire MTSS pyramid, um, and especially for the work in Tier 1, is that all staff, and that means all staff, so classified staff, support staff, everyone who interacts with children, has the foundational understanding of what we've learned from the ACEs study, which is that toxic stress for children that are exposed over time to these adverse experiences, especially during their early development, that it has a significant impact on their behavior. So part of what we teach is the neurology of behavior and the neurology of development and how, when children show up with what we call maladaptive behaviors,

[06:37]

that those are actually, they're functional for those kids in those toxic environments, even though they're not functional in school. So when a kid yells or throws something, we look at that behavior often as educators and say that's bad behavior, we need to punish that child. What we're teaching staff is that that behavior actually serves a purpose for that child. It could be to get attention, for example. And helping them understand the plasticity of the brain, yes, that child may currently use this maladaptive behavior, So, what we're looking at, what we're trying to point out is that

[07:28] SPEAKER_02:

What is the function of the behavior? Having educators start to wonder, what is the function of that behavior versus, I can't believe that kid did that, I wonder why that kid did that. And so, in that toxic environment that that child may be experiencing, that function is serving a massive need. All behaviors have a function. All behaviors are either to gain or avoid something. And so, what is that child to try and gain or avoid?

[07:50]

It might be attention, because... Maybe unintentional neglect at home. Mom and dad work two or three jobs, and that child only sees mom and dad one or two hours a day. Well, there's a lot of need for nurturing for that child.

[08:02]

There's a lot of need for attention for that child. And if that child is disruptive in class, the function could be seeking that Maslow need.

[08:09] SPEAKER_01:

Yeah, I think that's a really important perspective, because, you know, for a lot of us, you know, depending on where you grew up, depending on what kinds of schools you've worked in, that may be a very small number of students, and it may be easy to kind of write off those behaviors as just the behaviors of bad kids, but I think it's really important and really critical now that we are starting to recognize the function of those behaviors, as you said, and I know a lot of your specific knowledge and expertise in this comes from from your professional experience working in schools where very large numbers of students have those adverse childhood experiences and, you know, and have those behaviors that they're exhibiting in schools. So, for our listeners, maybe, who are thinking in terms of individual students and not so much patterns, what do you see as some of the common patterns in need? What do we need to do for our students who are in that situation, even if it's not a large number, what do we need to do as a foundation, as a tier one system of supports to meet their needs?

[09:09] SPEAKER_00:

So, a couple of things. You're absolutely right that in schools where there are high numbers of poverty and other kinds of factors, and for children, we know that our immigrants that are Muslim, that are not members of the dominant culture, there's additional factors of stress that they're facing just by the nature of who they are and how our country often responds to those kids, right? So, definitely, we can see a higher concentration of this need in certain populations, but I think it's also important to emphasize that adverse experiences happen to kids of all socioeconomic groups, and sometimes those kids, they may not have as extreme of behaviors, so it's not as easy to see what we would call, like, externalizing behaviors, so behaviors that are big and loud, but they may be more kids that are internalizers, and so part of what we recommend for schools during their Tier 1 work is actually to screen the entire school and identify who are the externalizers and who are the internalizers, because the internalizers often, especially in more affluent schools, are the ones who are kind of silently crying out for help, but they're the ones who may seem really compliant, but may be struggling with anxiety or depression.

[10:22]

So depending on the school population, The behaviors can look different, but you're absolutely right that understanding behavior in general, and specifically how toxic stress impacts behavior, we believe that's foundational for all staffs.

[10:35] SPEAKER_02:

And I don't know if your listeners know, but the ACE study, the original population set, the data that was used, um, was based off primarily white, middle-class Southern California.

[10:46] SPEAKER_00:

The other thing I would say, though, is that we see two components as being really critical for this Tier 1 work to begin. One is this ACEs foundational understanding, as well as the neurology of behavior, but also thinking through a culturally responsive or culturally relevant lens. We see this as really critical, and we actually... There's a school we're working with right now where, in comparison to other schools, the students may look on the surface like they all are members of the dominant culture.

[11:13]

They're all white kids, right? But in that community, there actually, there's a lot of poverty. And so thinking about culturally responsive practice, we want to encourage schools to really get to know who are their student communities, what's the history of those students and their families within that community, and how in the classroom and in the school are we ensuring that those kids feel that they belong and feel that their identity is valued within that community? So that's also foundational work that we do with schools as we begin this Tier 1 practice. So as we support schools in both assessing and addressing their Tier 1 needs, as we already mentioned, there's two key components that the ACEs understanding and the culturally responsive practice But there are other key pieces we're looking for in Tier 1. So we're looking to see, is there a social-emotional learning curriculum that all students universally have access to?

[12:06] SPEAKER_02:

Is it evidence-based?

[12:07] SPEAKER_00:

Is it an evidence-based curriculum? Is it a curriculum that is taught by teachers? Or is it just a counselor that randomly stops by the classroom? Um, that happens a lot in elementary, as your listeners may know. So we're evaluating and helping the school think about how are social-emotional skills being taught to all kids, including emotional regulation. Because we know that when kids get upset and they get escalated, that's often where behaviors start to become problematic.

[12:34]

And so how, as a school community, are you teaching kids about their bodies and their brains and what it feels like when we get upset and strategies to use to calm ourselves down, including mindfulness strategies? So that's another component we look at is that instruction of mindfulness and really metacognition of how the brain and body work.

[12:54] SPEAKER_02:

As well as increasing distress tolerance. So helping students in those practices, understanding that they can actually sustain a little more time before that emotional outburst. So creating, like, a zone of proximal development of when that student can actually tolerate, you know, the discomfort that they're experiencing.

[13:13] SPEAKER_00:

So, there's the social-emotional piece, the mindfulness piece. Another piece we're looking at are restorative practices. So, when students do make a mistake or have some issue that they need to repair within the community, is the approach to help that student learn from it and repair whatever damage they've done to a relationship or to property. Or is it still a punitive approach where they're just given a timeout or a suspension and there isn't necessarily a lot of learning associated with it? So that's another key component of Tier 1 would be those restorative disciplinary practices. We're also looking for, often this is PBIS, positive behavior intervention supports, but is there a foundational understanding across the building of what behaviors should look like?

[13:56]

Is there common language and common expectations that all adults and students know and use? Are there common ways that kids are recognized and praised for those expected behaviors?

[14:06] SPEAKER_02:

Which is an extrinsic reinforcement. Extrinsic reinforcements don't solely need to be monetary. It can be praise. It can be access to preferred activity.

[14:14] SPEAKER_00:

Right. So that's another component we're looking for. And a lot of schools we work with, this is one they have down pretty well if they've been in, you know, doing PBIS work. So with Tier 1, is there a Tier 1 data team that's multidisciplinary and that, at least monthly, is looking at things like, behavioral data, office referral data, and looking at the trends of behavior in the school to lead that Tier 1 work. And all of that is in service of the rigorous and differentiated core instruction. And so, again, within Tier 1, we would say that foundational understanding of ACEs, culturally responsive practice, social-emotional learning, mindfulness, restorative practices, PBIS, or another way that language...

[15:00]

And expectations for behavior are common and consistent. And then all of that in service of, is the curriculum rigorous and differentiated? Can kids access the tasks? Are they meaningful to them? Are they grade-level appropriate? That's obviously a huge piece of Tier 1, and in the academic side, we've often just focused on that.

[15:20]

What we help schools in recognizing is that all of those other sort of affective and emotional pieces are in service of that access to the core instruction, and they have to be in place for kids to feel regulated and safe.

[15:33] SPEAKER_01:

And I'm really struck by the degree to which everything you described seems to operate as a system. You know, the first S in MTSS, you know, a lot of these things fit together, and in a school or a district or a community where it feels like a lot of those things are not in place, It can feel like we have a bunch of separate problems. Like, we have a dropout problem, and we have a drug problem in our community, and we have a graduation rate that's not as high as we want it to be, and we have kids getting suspended, and we have teachers who struggle with classroom management, and we have students who are being referred for special ed, and, like, we have all these related kind of symptoms that are manifesting themselves. But what I'm hearing is that underlying our approach to dealing with all those different factors needs to be a systematic approach to meeting students' needs. So I wonder if we could talk for a moment about the work that you've done over recent months, you know, since we last spoke, uh, with some of your school districts and communities that you're partnering with to help them develop those systems.

[16:34] SPEAKER_00:

So, absolutely, we know for a child in any community that while we may see, you know, their classroom teacher very differently than their PE teacher, and that's completely different than when they go to after school, or when they go to their club soccer team, or when they go meet with their mental health counselor in the community, or they're in a foster care home, and yet for that child... That's all their experience, and they're navigating across those many different settings, and often they're having to, as we would say, code switch or change both their behaviors and also their language and what's expected of them, and that's hard for any child to manage, but that's especially hard for a child who struggles with transitions because that may be a trigger to them with the other kinds of experiences they may have had. And so we had a great opportunity, actually, last week,

[17:25]

Um, we were invited by several agencies in Del Norte County, California, to do a three-day workshop on all of this work, trauma-informed MTSS, but the unique thing was that this was really an effort to integrate how MTSS and Tier 1 can look across agencies. So we had school teachers and administrators with us, but we also had Um, foster care...

[17:49] SPEAKER_02:

Right, we had, we had, uh, tribal members within the community, so tribal support services were there, foster care.

[17:55] SPEAKER_00:

There was a rape crisis prevention team.

[17:57] SPEAKER_02:

Um, domestic violence prevention.

[18:00] SPEAKER_00:

Right, so there were several folks who work directly with children and families in the community, but they're not necessarily school-based people. And this is a community Chris mentioned, the tribes. There are two large native tribes that have a lot of families and kids. They're in the community, very involved in the community. And there's some significant issues that they're facing that we wanted to help them think about through a collaborative lens around Tier 1. Right.

[18:24]

So, for example, again, getting back to a data-driven practice, we looked at data of, essentially, they called it their ACEs data, but some of the data that they're seeing across their community. So, for example, um, drug and alcohol use amongst ninth graders is a significant concern for them as a community. And so, what we did was, We asked, after teaching about Tier 1 and teaching about the importance of common language of Tier 1, it was actually great, um, because the teachers who were in the room, we mentioned PBIS, and we asked, what are your three expectations? And everyone who was from the school district, regardless of their school, knew it was be safe, be respectful, be responsible. And there were even social service providers in the room that weren't school employees, but they knew that language as well. And so it was a great example to build off of.

[19:13]

In terms of, if this is language that children are exposed to, and it's what they're expected to do in the classroom, then how does that connect back to their larger settings?

[19:22] SPEAKER_02:

And then what does that look like in those larger settings? And so, you know, yes, they may be able to parrot, you know, the three words, but what does that mean within the foster care system? What does that mean within the social services system? And so, with that, we provided a project for all agents, so we, um, you know, heterogeneous groups, so you had educators, social services, foster care, all at one table, multiple tables throughout the room, and provide a tier one intervention for drug and alcohol use within the community.

[19:53] SPEAKER_00:

Right, so they were working collaboratively across agencies to talk about a real issue that they face as a community. So, for example, I mentioned drug and alcohol use of ninth graders. And we had taught them about, you know, Tier 1 being really prevention and universal. So if, across agencies, they were going to prevent children from trying alcohol and drugs, for example, what would be some common language they would want to use? What would be some common methods for getting that language out to ensure that every ninth grader learns that? And then what would be common ways across their systems that they would support those kids with Right.

[20:47] SPEAKER_02:

Some discussions I heard were, um, you know, raising the question, why would a ninth grader seek to use drugs and alcohol? Um, what would be a preferred alternative behavior? You know, what do we want to encourage rather than that use? And having that encouragement community-wide, not just in the school. When the bell rings, it's not over. It's all throughout the community.

[21:04] SPEAKER_00:

Right. Right.

[21:20]

They knew, some of the providers that aren't necessarily in the schools, but who work directly with kids, they knew of some curriculum that was being already used in the schools, some social-emotional curriculum, that they thought actually had some great strengths to it. So they identified, for example, what are components of that curriculum and language and lessons that could be used in the other settings. So they were naming that as kind of a foundational set of expectations, that they could do a better job of implementing across the social service agencies and not just in the school. So really reinforcing that message, like Chris said, beyond when the kid is at school.

[21:52] SPEAKER_02:

Another great observation, um, that we saw was that during these discussions, schools and other services were realizing there are additional services that they were unaware of. So just by partnering and just having this discussion, schools are realizing, oh, wow, we can get additional counseling services through this agency.

[22:12] SPEAKER_01:

Yeah, and I think especially for rural schools, for communities that feel like maybe they're geographically isolated from the urban centers where a lot of those resources are more visible, those partnerships and those relationships between, say, you know, foster care, family services, different providers, different agencies with a stake in the success of our children. You know, there are opportunities there, even if there's not a university nearby, even if there's not, you know, a big counseling office nearby. We don't feel like we have a ton of resources in a small town. We do have those opportunities to sit down together at the table and say, how can we get...

[22:48]

As you said, a common language and common goals for helping our students, for setting them up for success and figuring out specifically where do we need to focus? Is it on ninth graders and their drug and alcohol use and preventing and reducing that? Just sitting down and developing that common language. And you have worked with a number of different districts and kind of interagency efforts to help build that capacity since we've spoken last. Is that right?

[23:13] SPEAKER_00:

Yeah, the primary place where we're doing that work here in Washington is we're currently in 10 schools in Snohomish County, and that's actually, um, work that's sponsored by the county mental health, mental and behavioral health services. And so, it gives us a unique opportunity because the county helps the schools get access to additional mental health supports, and so part of what we're working on now as we get deeper into the work with these schools is setting it up so that if students receive counseling from an outside agency, that... that counseling agency actually has the opportunity to sit down and be a part of the problem-solving that the team at the school does on behalf of that child. Because often what we find is, you know, kids may be receiving a Tier 2 intervention at school, for example, and then they are also seeing a mental health counselor, but the counselor doesn't really know what's happening at school, and the teacher doesn't know what's happening with the counseling,

[24:04]

And we're not advocating for private, you know, we're not trying to do anything that is unethical in terms of a child's confidentiality, but we do know that if the child has a specific strategy that they're working on with the counselor that could also be helpful in the classroom setting, that again, the same thing we were just talking about, that child having common language and common expectations from both of those adults that they see regularly, we know that that's best practice to really help the child take on that intervention and make the improvement we're trying to help them with.

[24:33] SPEAKER_02:

The counseling approach to address maladaptive behaviors, the gold standard for that would be something along the lines of cognitive behavioral therapy. And within cognitive behavioral therapy, there's often what's called homework at the end of each session. And that homework is, say, at the end, what goal do you want to work on this week? And so, the counselor may encourage a child, how about identifying your triggers this week? Now, that's not revealing the nitty-gritty discussion that occurred prior to that. It's not revealing personal information.

[25:03]

Of course, I would argue that schools should seek a release of information within this partnership. But at the same time, if a child is simply looking for triggers or practicing a self-soothing strategy, that student's school and teachers should be aware that that student is practicing a self-soothing strategy so that teachers in the system does not get in the way of that child trying to seek that goal or complete that homework assignment of identifying their triggers. And so... If we're all on the same page on that, then that's how it's going to be that much more successful.

[25:34]

And, of course, the alignment of the school and additional services is... We can't encourage that enough.

[25:39] SPEAKER_01:

Well, Chris and Courtney, it has been great to talk in more depth about some of these issues and how we can support our students better. If someone would like to get in contact with you and learn more about the work that you do, where's the best place for them to connect with you online?

[25:54] SPEAKER_02:

Our website is continuaconsulting.com.

[25:59] SPEAKER_00:

C-O-N-T-I-N-U-A C-O-N-S-U-L-T-I-N-G dot com.

[26:07] SPEAKER_01:

Chris and Courtney, thanks again for joining me on Principal Center Radio. Thanks so much, Justin.

[26:10] SPEAKER_00:

Thank you, Justin. It was great.

[26:11] SPEAKER_01:

Good to talk to you. And now, Justin Bader on high-performance instructional leadership. So, high-performance instructional leaders, what did you take away from my conversation with Chris and Courtney about trauma-informed, multi-tiered systems of support, and especially that Tier 1 level as a community partnership? One of the things that really strikes me is the opportunity that we have to build relationships across agencies and across different professional categories, where we tend not to really talk. You know, educators don't talk to mental health practitioners all that often. And I think especially in communities where the resources are thin, where there are not a lot of agencies, where there are not a lot of supports available, you know, we might feel that, as a school system, we're the only ones pulling for our kids.

[27:01]

But as Chris and Courtney highlighted in our interview, there may be Native American tribal organizations, there may be the foster care system, there may be a variety of other agencies across sectors that share our goals of supporting our students. And I think especially when it comes to what seem to be our most challenging and most intractable problems, whether it's with drug and alcohol abuse or... Graduation rates or simply students who are having a very hard time succeeding in life because of the circumstances that they find themselves in, those partnerships are more critical than ever, and they allow us to do things that might have been inconceivable not too long ago. But as the research comes in, as best practice in this part of our profession really develops, I think new opportunities are emerging.

[27:49]

And that puts on us a new obligation to take this research seriously, to really look at what our students need from us and what can be done. So if you're interested in speaking with Chris and Courtney, you can go to ContinuaGroup.com and find out more about their work and the training that they provide. for school districts and other agencies to implement those multi-tiered systems of support. Uh, and if you're interested in learning more about ACE scores and about childhood trauma and adverse childhood events that impact students and how they show up at school, I want to encourage you to check out our previous interviews with Paul Tuff. T-O-U-G-H. Paul Tuff has written several books on helping students succeed, no matter the adverse backgrounds that they may come from.

[28:34]

So look up in our Principal Center Radio archives Paul Tuff's previous interviews at PrincipalCenter.com slash radio.

[28:41] Announcer:

Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at PrincipalCenter.com slash radio.

Bring This Expertise to Your School

Interested in professional development, keynotes, or workshops? Send us a message below.

Inquire About Professional Development with Chris and Courtney Daikos

We'll be happy to make an introduction.