[00:01] SPEAKER_02:
Welcome to Principal Center Radio, bringing you the best in professional practice.
[00:06] Announcer:
Here's your host, director of the Principal Center, and champion of high-performance instructional leadership, Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.
[00:15] SPEAKER_00:
I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to be joined today by Dr. Richard Cash. Richard is an international consultant, speaker, and expert on gifted education, differentiated instruction, self-regulation, and more, and he's the author of three books, including Self Regulation in the Classroom, Helping Students Learn How to Learn, which we're here to talk about today.
[00:38] Announcer:
And now, our feature presentation.
[00:40] SPEAKER_00:
Richard, welcome to Principal Center Radio.
[00:41] SPEAKER_02:
Thank you. Thanks for having me.
[00:43] SPEAKER_00:
I wonder if we could start by defining specifically what self-regulation is, because it's one of those terms that we hear a lot in education, and we might use it a lot, and we might use it to refer to different things. We might talk about a student who struggles with self-regulation, but let's get really specific about what self-regulation actually is. Could you start us off with the definition?
[01:03] SPEAKER_01:
Sure, sure. Self-regulation is the ability to manage and monitor and adjust three aspects of yourself. Your affect, how you feel, your behaviors, what you do, and your cognition, the line of thinking that you take. That is basically what self-regulation is. It's been popularized recently, most identified with Carol Dweck's mindset, which actually came out of the studies back in the 40s and 50s of what is called self-regulation. Uh, she popularized the term mindset, which is basically part of your self-regulation, how you think about yourself.
[01:49]
Uh, and then recently, Angela Duckworth, in her book Grit, uh, spoke to the same idea. And, and all of these things, you know, Paul Tuff's book on what kids need to succeed, Yeah. All of that stuff is clinically what is called self-regulation. So, you know, when we, in the classroom, talk about a kid's executive functioning, um, that's self-regulation. When we talk about how you socially and emotionally learn, uh, the whole SEL learning movement right now, that's self-regulation. So, it's the term that encompasses all of this stuff, the mindfulness, all that stuff is encompassed under the theories and concept of self-regulation.
[02:33] SPEAKER_00:
And it seems to me that that's a set of concepts that we recognize when students have them or when students lack them. But a lot of your book is not just about understanding what those concepts are, but about how we can actually help students develop those capacities for self-regulation.
[02:49] SPEAKER_01:
Talk to me about that. For anything, any movement in school to be applied with fidelity and actually be worthy of our time, has to have a grounding in good, solid theory. So I give you just enough of the theory, uh, in the first couple of chapters, like I say, just enough to be dangerous. And then after that, then I follow it up with breaking it down by the, the process of learning. Uh, there are four phases in the learning process. Before we can even get a kid into the learning process, they first have to feel confident about themselves.
[03:28]
That whole sense of, Self-belief and self-efficacy.
[03:31] SPEAKER_00:
Right. Otherwise, why bother, right?
[03:34] SPEAKER_01:
Exactly. Because, I mean, the critical aspect here is how a kid feels about themselves and then about the environment determines the focus of their attention. So if they don't feel good about themselves or confident in their abilities to perform, it's like throwing spaghetti at a wall. You know, maybe a strand is gonna stick. But if you want a lot to stick, you've got to get the kid ready for the learning process, which means you have to build their confidence. So the early part of the book is how to build that sense of confidence with kids, and then moving into the next stage of the learning processes, and then how do you start setting a plan for yourself?
[04:15]
How do you start developing goals? You know, we oftentimes as teachers, uh, will tell kids what the goal is. But that may not be good enough for them. That may not be what they truly need. They need to set their own goals. And for little kids, that's a goal for the next 10 minutes.
[04:34]
Uh, for older kids, it's like, what's your goal for the day? What's your goal for the week? Uh, when we set these goals with kids, especially little kids, this bothers me, when we set goals with little kids, uh, that are a year-long goal for a first grader, To me, that's ridiculous, because even as an adult, I can't hold onto a goal for a year, because how many people set, uh, that New Year's resolution? And that's a goal. And I'll tell you, by January 31st, everyone pretty much has forgotten their goal. So, asking a kid to set a year-long goal, it's not a good goal to set.
[05:15]
So, it's, you know, for little kids, it's set a goal for the next 10 minutes. For older kids, it's set a goal for the day. For high school kids, set a goal for the week or set a goal for the next nine weeks. You know, things like that. So that's the second phase is setting the goal. And then the third phase is how do you manage it?
[05:34]
What do you do when you're not reaching your goal? What do you do when you hit an impasse in that goal? This is where perseverance and patience and persistence and grit and all that stuff comes into play is once you've managed to set the goal. And now you've got to see how the goal is working. And then the final phase is the reflection phase. And that's the phase that I think is critically missing in education today.
[06:00]
We don't give kids enough time to really sit and reflect and to think and to analyze actions, behaviors, and cognition, to be able to go back and say, what should I have done better? What did I do really well? You know, things like that. That's a very cyclical process, so it starts all over again once you've gone through that reflection phase. Then you say, okay, now I feel confident enough to take the next challenge on, or I don't feel confident, so what am I going to do to change that quote-unquote mindset to then become ready to learn? Right.
[06:36] SPEAKER_00:
Well, I love the way you've broken that down into, you know, a teachable set of phases. And I think it's so critical that we actually teach students to expect that they're going to fail. They're going to encounter barriers. The first try is not always going to work. Uh, and I think a lot of discouragement sets in when students see their peers succeeding the first time, uh, or just not struggling with the same issues. And I know we have a lot of experience with this type of teaching as educators, especially around behavior.
[07:06]
You know, we see students who struggle to regulate their behavior, and we develop a behavior plan, and we help them set goals and provide reinforcement and reflection, and we have lots of processes for that. But... It's interesting to me, your ABC model, affect, behavior, and cognition, because I think we think of affect and cognition as a little bit less, uh, regulatable, for lack of a better term. You know, we think of them more as characteristics of the student, which, of course, you know, is not a fair destiny.
[07:34]
You know, we need to have a growth mindset, as Carol Dweck would say, about our students, about ourselves. So how do we actually teach students to regulate their emotions, their affect, you know, without making it just kind of a... Stiff upper lip, control yourself, don't show emotion kind of approach.
[07:51] SPEAKER_01:
Funny how that worked for us as kids. It doesn't work for kids nowadays. You know, as I started to study the whole idea of self-regulation and really putting all of the pieces together, realizing that when we only focus on one aspect of the self, the behavioral aspect of the self, we're forgetting two-thirds of ourselves. And so...
[08:13]
What happens is you might change that behavior for the moment, but there's no long-lasting behavioral change. I mean, why do people re-offend? They re-offend because we didn't pay attention to how they feel and what they are thinking and their lines of thinking. So I went back into my own practice and said, okay, what, what could I have done better? Because when I did focus on the behavior, it changed for the moment, but it didn't change for long-term. So I think that what we have to keep in mind and keep considering is that the affect is how we feel.
[08:50]
And I want to clarify the term here between, the difference between affect, how we feel, and emotion. Emotion is a chemical reaction that happens within our midbrain. That is a natural process to us. We don't control it, it controls us. How we react to that response, which is the emotion, how we react to that is called our feelings. So, how we cognitively read that stuff out is called our feelings.
[09:22]
So, I feel mad, I feel sad, I feel... That's a feeling. I can control those, I can manage those. That's that executive functioning stuff.
[09:32]
Now, yes, some of the feelings are natural to us, like the highs and the lows. Those are, those are natural to us. But really, what I call the beauty of the music of what makes us human is on, is right in the middle range of that empathy, compassion, responsibility, organization, desire, drive. All those things are in the middle of the keyboard. And those are all learned. Those are learned behaviors that we learn from our parents, that we learn from others around us, that we learn from our community.
[10:07]
Our culture, our backgrounds, all of that stuff is a learning process. So, in some cases, kids have had poor and inefficient role models for that feeling aspect, especially kids coming from poverty. And believe me, I'm not trying to shame and blame anyone. Poverty has an enormous effect on how we feel about ourselves. And so, if we can get kids to readjust the lens that they look through about themselves and get them to kind of keep the focus on, I control my feelings. No one else controls them.
[10:48]
So, when, when a kid says, you made me feel or you did this to me, they're giving away their power. I want kids to take that power back because they're shaming and blaming others and making others responsible for their how they're managing themselves. So I really want kids to talk in the I-frame. I feel this is what I need. Uh, and so really teaching even little kids how to identify, you know, those base, uh, level emotional responses, feelings, and then say, what do I need to do with that? What do I need to do with it?
[11:31]
Not what do you need to do with that, but what do I, as the learner, need to do with that? So that, that's that affect part that we, we can help kids learn how to manage themselves that way. Uh, the cognition part, we tend to think that thinking is somewhat of a natural process for us. Well, yes and no. Yes, there are certain parts to us that are primitive and, you know, we survive and that's a problem-solving situation. However, in today's world, it's a much more evolved level of thinking.
[12:06]
So I broke down thinking into three levels. There's metacognition, which, you know, we were all taught in teacher school that metacognitions are thinking about our thinking. But if you ask a kid, think about your thinking, they're gonna look at you like you've got four heads, because they don't know what that means. So I say metacognition is more of the reflective process. Think about yourself. Think about how you feel, your affect.
[12:35]
Think about what you did, your behaviors. Put those together, that's the ABCs, and now reflect on that. What could you do better? What would you do well? And so forth. That's metacognition.
[12:47]
The next level above that, then, is what I titled infracognition. And infracognition is the structures of thinking, such as creative thinking, critical reasoning, problem solving, decision making. And so forth. Those are all structured. Those are the ones that we need to teach kids how to think critically, how to think creatively, how to reason and decision through, uh, problems. That's a structured way of thinking.
[13:18]
Above that is the thinking beyond the self. And the thinking beyond the self is what I, what is called metaphysical cognition. That thinking beyond yourself. being able to think with empathy, being able to think and compassionately concern yourself with the issues of others, uh, that's what is called metaphysical cognition, oftentimes attributed to philosophers and theologians and stuff, but we can actually teach that to kids as well, to get them to think beyond themselves. So you have metacognition, thinking of the self, infracognition, the structures of thinking, And then metaphysical cognition, thinking beyond the self. And so, behaviorally, we've got a lot that we know.
[14:04]
Like you said, there's a lot that we know about how to manage kids' behaviors. But if we don't link that to feeling and cognition, we're always going to have reoffenders. We're always going to have kids that will fall apart. Uh, and not be able to manage themselves beyond our control.
[14:23] SPEAKER_00:
And it seems to us as adults, as responsible people, as educators, that often when either students or people who've gotten in trouble with the law, uh, are engaging in some of those behaviors that we identify as criminal or destructive or disruptive or just not in their own best interest, we often identify that as short-term thinking. And as you were describing the different types of cognition, uh, it occurred to me that, uh, our brains naturally... Our, our shortcut takers, you know, our brains always want to get to the decision as quickly as possible. You know, I think it's linked to our survival in the, uh, the earlier days of our species.
[14:56]
You know, we've got to, uh, use pattern recognition or heuristics or previous experience to make a decision as quickly as possible. And, and as you described each of those cognition strategies, You know, they really represented for me a slowing down of the process, a stepping back and saying, okay, not just fight or flight right now, but, uh, how am I acting toward other people? You know, what impact am I having on other people? And you're, and you're kind of broadening that perspective by slowing down the thinking and making it more, more reflective.
[15:23] SPEAKER_01:
Well, and especially in today's world, our kids today are more distractible than any other time in human history because there is so much information coming at kids We as adults have kind of learned to deal with it, but it's still overwhelming. You know, I'll go to New York City and stand in the middle of Times Square and actually start to get a rash because there's so much information coming at us. Uh, you know, with the amount of technology that kids have access to, both as in smartphones and iPads and laptops and all that stuff, they're constantly being distracted. I mean, if you go to a website, the intent of a website is to distract you, is to pull your eye in multiple different directions.
[16:15]
Books don't do that. Books can't do that. So, when we were learning, we were very linear learners. We learned in a very linear fashion. Kids today are...
[16:28]
what are called randomized learners. They don't learn in a linear fashion. They click on a website and jump all over and are hot-buttoning and, you know, they get bored in a matter of seconds and they move on to the next thing. And it's that, exactly what you said, it's the calming down of the brain to slow it down to allow it a chance to digest information and be able to parse through stuff to try to find good decisions or try to find a good way to solve a problem rather than just race through things.
[17:04] SPEAKER_00:
Well, Richard, I know a lot of your background is in gifted education, and I know a lot of people will be buying this book on self-regulation to help students who are perhaps on the more struggling end of the spectrum, or perhaps even are gifted but have, you know, some difficulty staying focused and things like that. What are some of the biggest implications for school leaders as far as our understanding and our work with teachers to help students develop self-regulation? I know you have First and foremost, I think that what you have to do is you have to make it a systemic concern. That you have to, as a building, understand both conceptually, theoretically, what this thing is, and then be able to apply consistently
[18:01] SPEAKER_01:
across the grade levels, particular strategies or ideas that you think to be the ones you need to focus in on. One of the chapters, the last chapter, actually, in the book is helping people put together a plan, then, of how to make this a program-wide idea. And it really is having consistency, It's having a constant message that not only goes to the students, but it goes to parents, making it a collective agenda. And it's, it's not always just about achievement. Uh, I think that we as educators recently have gotten so bogged down with get those kids to achieve, that we forget that they're still human beings.
[18:52]
They're still little kids. They still need that nurturing, that empathy, that compassion. And they still need to learn how to build that within themselves, but as well as build it within a model of self-regulation. So, uh, what I break down is, you know, how do we get people to be aware of this thing called self-regulation? How do we then help teachers manage it in the classroom? How do we infuse it into instruction?
[19:21]
This is the one that I'm most, most, uh, passionate about, is that For any of these SEL, social and emotional learning aspects, or self-regulated learning, to really be effective, it has to be embedded within everyday instruction, not a pull-out at 10.30, or something that you do on Wednesdays at 10.30. It has to be embedded within instruction. It has to be the common language of instruction. And then the final piece is that the community all has to get around this, has to frame their understanding around it as well, and as much as they can, try to continue it outside of the four walls of the classroom.
[20:06]
Uh, so how do we help community members, church members, uh, libraries, those, those kind of people help us manage this, because in some cases, families may not be able to manage it.
[20:23] SPEAKER_00:
So the book is Self-Regulation in the Classroom, Helping Students Learn How to Learn. And Richard, if people want to get in touch with you, find out more about your work, where can they find you online?
[20:34] SPEAKER_01:
My website is www.nrich.com.
[20:41]
So that's n, as in November, r-i-c-h dot consulting.
[20:47] SPEAKER_00:
Fabulous. Well, Richard, thank you so much for joining us on Principal Center Radio.
[20:50] SPEAKER_02:
Great, thank you very much.
[20:54] SPEAKER_00:
So, high-performance instructional leaders, what did you take away from my conversation with Dr. Richard Cash? I'm really impressed by the clarity of the model that Dr. Cash shared with us. The idea that self-regulation includes affect and behavior and cognition. And I want to encourage you to have this conversation with your staff when it comes to students' social and emotional needs, not just looking at students as either fine or defective and in need of, you know, some sort of fix, but to look at all students and all adults and ourselves As human beings who are constantly needing to self-regulate in terms of affect, behavior, and cognition.
[21:37]
And as Dr. Cash said, I think if we look at this only as an intervention issue, that only certain students need to think about their behavior or need to think about their thinking, then we're missing a lot of opportunities to help all students benefit from that metacognition, from that goal setting, and from the gains that we can see from teaching self-regulation. Stay tuned for more on Principal Center Radio on social and emotional learning, and you might also check out my interview with Paul Tuff on his book on helping children succeed. That's it for now. I'm Justin Bader, and I will see you next time.
[22:09] Announcer:
Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at principalcenter.com slash radio.