Deconstructing Depth of Knowledge: A Method and Model for Deeper Teaching and Learning

Follow on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · more apps

About the Authors

Erik Francis an international author and presenter with over 25 years of experience working in education as a classroom teacher, a site administrator, an education program specialist with a state education agency, and a trainer who produces and provides professional development for teachers and school leaders. He is the author of Deconstructing Depth of Knowledge: A Method and Model for Deeper Teaching and Learning published by Solution Tree and Now THAT'S a Good Question! How to Promote Cognitive Rigor Through Classroom Questioning published by ASCD.

Full Transcript

[00:01] Announcer:

Welcome to Principal Center Radio, helping you build capacity for instructional leadership. Here's your host, Director of the Principal Center, Dr. Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.

[00:13] SPEAKER_00:

I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to welcome back to the program my colleague Eric Francis. Eric is an international author and presenter with over 25 years of experience working in education as a teacher, administrator, state program specialist, trainer. You know him from his books, including... Now, that's a good question.

[00:32]

How to Promote Cognitive Rigor Through Classroom Questioning, which we've talked about previously on Principal Center Radio, and his latest book, Deconstructing Depth of Knowledge, a Method and Model for Deeper Teaching and Learning, which we're here to talk about today.

[00:49]

Eric, welcome back to Principal Center Radio.

[00:51] SPEAKER_01:

Thanks, Justin. Thanks for having me. It's great to be back.

[00:54] SPEAKER_00:

Well, I'm excited to talk about depth of knowledge a little bit because it's one of those things that, you know, many schools have been told to use. Many teachers have been given activities to do with depth of knowledge. But there is a lot out there that maybe needs to be deconstructed. What did you see happening that needed to be deconstructed when it comes to depth of knowledge?

[01:14] SPEAKER_01:

The unfortunate thing is we've been doing depth of knowledge. We've been teaching and learning for depth of knowledge. Okay, so, um,

[01:40]

He told me this, actually, in a conversation, that they're not actually levels, they're actually categories. Which makes sense, because what happens is, is that if you think of things as levels, you're thinking, you know, four is better than one, because it's deeper, and it's not. So, that's the original thing about depth of knowledge, is that it was originally designed to be a criterion for alignment studies. And then what Karen Hess did with it, Dr. Karen Hess, is that she superimposed the DOK levels with Bloom's taxonomy, or Bloom's revised taxonomy specifically, to be a measure of cognitive rigor. So that's when we started hearing about how depth of knowledge is based on what comes after the verb.

[02:20]

You look at the initial cognitive action verb of a learning intention, objective, or target... And then you look at where it's categorized and blooms, and then you put it aside, and then you look at all the words and phrases that follow that verb. What I did with it is I turned into a method and model for deeper teaching and learning. I actually turned it into An RTI model, multi-tiered system of support.

[02:42]

And it's all driven by the standards. And when you go to determine depth of knowledge or you go to designate the DLK level, what you're doing is this. It's the next step in unwrapping and unpacking the standards. And it's kind of funny because when I say unwrapping and unpacking the standards of teachers...

[02:59]

Many of them often roll their eyes and make a heavy sigh, which is understandable because, you know, what we do with unpacking and unwrapping standards, it's a great method that Larry Ainsworth came up with, but the teachers only see it as I'm circling the verbs and I'm underlying the nouns. It's not much different than doing matching on a worksheet or doing multiple choice. So, what I say about depth of knowledge is you identify the first verb in the learning intention and then you put it aside. Okay? So you know where it is in Bloom's. Now you're asking yourself, what exactly must students learn or think about?

[03:29]

That's the content. That's the noun or noun phrase that names the specific content you're teaching. Then you have to ask, how deeply does the learning intention demand students to understand and use their knowledge, or understand and use their knowledge in thinking and learning? And that's all the rest of the words and phrases. So, the big thing about depth of knowledge, why we've been doing it inaccurately and inconsistently, is because of that DOK wheel that was distributed as part of the trainings on Common Core Standards as part of the education reform for college and career readiness. It's completely inaccurate.

[04:07]

It credits Dr. Norman Webb. He didn't create it. In fact, he refutes it. If you look at the poster we all have out there at the citation, not only does it credit Dr. Norman Webb, which is inaccurate, but if you go to URL address, it takes you to a dead link.

[04:24]

It's not even the correct link for the web alignment tool. So Webb has refuted it. Karen Hess has refuted it. I refute it. And really, I think it's caused some strong, solid collateral damage in education. You know, we've been really struggling for the last two years, 10 years, excuse me, to have the kids demonstrate their learning, act a cognitive rigor demanded by these more complex, rigorous standards.

[04:49]

And for some reason, we haven't been able to do it successfully or really hit that target at the center that it needs to be. So that's the thing. That's why I wrote this book, is not only to clear up and clarify what exactly it is, but also looking at it as a book that might help us move forward to what education could become as a result of what the pandemic has done to education, not only as a profession, but also as a system.

[05:20] SPEAKER_00:

Well, let's step back just a step and kind of put some of this work around level of cognitive rigor into context. So we're talking about the idea of having objectives for a lesson, learning targets, and so forth that, you know, certainly go beyond the activity. You know, we don't want to just say, you know, what are we going to do today? Well, we're going to do...

[05:40]

You know, we're going to read a book or we're going to work on a lab or whatever. We want to actually get into the task and the cognitive demand of the task and, as you said, the content that students are going to perform that task on. I happen to have learned Bloom's Taxonomy rather than Webb's Depth of Knowledge back in the day. And, of course, we're hearing more about depth of knowledge these days. But you said something interesting, that it's not quite right to see them as levels. And I don't know if you see this in your work.

[06:08]

Frequently, we'll hear people talking about rigor... I wonder if we could clear up some of just kind of the basic misconceptions about thinking about tasks, thinking about cognitive rigor that you encounter in your work, and then get into some of how you apply that in the book.

[06:36] SPEAKER_01:

Well, you hit the nail right on the head, is that what happens is in education, and it's not just DOK, it's not just cognitive rigor. I experienced this with, uh, the questioning and inquiry I do, the good questioning and inquiry I do, is that if it's considered to be a, quote, lower level, it's, quote, bad. And that if it's considered to be a higher, deeper level, it's, quote, good or desirable or better. And that's not the case. That what depth of knowledge does, it describes four different ways students could understand and use their learning. At a DLK1, You could recall information or recall how to use procedures to answer correctly.

[07:20]

At a DOK-2, you could apply knowledge and consciousness skills or use information and basic reasoning to establish and explain with examples. The differences between a DOK-1 and a DOK-2... is that a DLK1, you're just giving the facts and you're just doing it. And that's fine, okay?

[07:37]

That's foundational learning. That's functional understanding. That's foundational knowledge. At a DLK2, what you're doing is you're demonstrating, communicating how you can use that knowledge to answer questions, to address problems, to accomplish tasks, to analyze texts and topics. So, from a math standpoint, it's not what is 2 plus 2. It's how can addition be used to find the sum I'm going to give you an example.

[08:03]

Two plus two. I'm going to give you a worksheet full of ten problems. You pick two today and answer that question. Use those problems as your example. From an English language arts standpoint, it might be, what's the connection between ideas and information? Or, how does the author use craft and structure?

[08:22]

Like, how does the author use literary devices in a text? At a DLK3... What you're asking is, how and why could the knowledge be used? Now you're going from DOK2, which is more procedural, to DOK3, which is more strategic.

[08:38]

And now you have to either think strategically or use complex reasoning to examine and explain with evidence. At a DLK3, you're doing evidentiary thinking and reasoning. That you have to use it to prove it. So, if you want to do a DLK3 every single time, just give the kids an answer and ask them, why is it correct or incorrect? Or ask hypothetical questions. What if?

[09:00]

Or ask them to make a choice and to defend or justify a choice. And a DOK-4, the real thing that distinguishes a DOK-3 from a DOK-4 is how extensive it is. This is where you're going deep within a subject area. You're going across the curriculum. You're going among texts and topics. You're going beyond the classroom.

[09:19]

It's not project-based per se, but it requires to do more of A focus where you are coming in more so with a deeper level of expertise. You're doing author studies. Instead of just reading Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, you're reading Charlie and the Chocolate Factory and a story by Roald Dahl of the student's choice and doing an author study. You're doing more, uh, deeper mathematical investigations, uh, STEM specifically with engineering design. to address, explain, and respond to a real-world scenario situation. Same with science and that.

[09:55]

In history, you're looking at the impact and influence on history on broader historical context. So, you're looking not only how these events impacted each other, but also impacted the future or how the past influenced those certain events. And that's the problem, though, is that we look at these taxonomies, and DOK is not a taxonomy, okay? You don't have to start at a DOK 1 to get a DOK 4. The DOK level that the teaching and learning experience starts at is at the standard, the DOK level, the standard. I say teaching and testing...

[10:29]

I want everyone to listen to me closely on this. Or I like to say with Hans and Franz, hear me now and listen to me later. Okay? The DOK level of the standard is where teaching and testing starts and stops. Okay? But you need to tier your instruction to the DOK level where the students are.

[10:50]

So instead of looking at it from a deficit perspective or using it as a deficit model, what you're doing is you're addressing the gaps by searching for their strengths. Can you do it at this level? No. Can you do it at this level? No. Can you do it at this level?

[11:03]

Yes. Okay, good. Let's start there. And you start there, and you build upon their strengths so they can rise to reach and go beyond that DOK level. So, that's the thing about DOK. It is not something you should use as a value judgment.

[11:18]

It is definitely something you should not use to evaluate teachers. And I can tell you, there's administrators, I've heard them say, when I come in your room, I want to see more than a DOK1 going on in there. Are, um... You see these initiatives at the beginning of the year.

[11:30]

Everyone in the school should be doing their instruction at a DOK through a DOK4. There's even state departments of education. I can even tell you out here in Arizona, I'll be bold enough to say it, that they're actually evaluating schools and improvement based upon the DOK level they see that day. And that is so inappropriate, and that is so wrong. And I even coach leaders and teachers to say...

[11:53]

If someone says to you, hey, I saw you're only doing a DOK1 today, why? Your response back should be, oh, because today the students are building foundation knowledge and functional understanding, and I'm assessing them for that. And a couple of days from now, they're going to do a DOK2, where they can demonstrate and communicate how they can use what they've learned to answer the questions I give them. And address the problems, or accomplish the tasks, or analyze the text and topics. Next week, we're probably going to get into more of a DOK3, where I'm going to use them, do things strategically, and have them prove it. And at the end of the month, we're going to do a DOK4, where it's more of an extended teaching and learning experience.

[12:28]

Would you like to come back and see the outcome of it? It is so inappropriate to evaluate teachers on DOK levels, and hopefully to your audience here, to everyone's listening, please do not evaluate your teachers on the DOK level they're teaching that day, because that might be the intent and purpose of the DOK teaching and learning experience. But use it as a way to coach teachers. Hey, I see your teaching is mostly to DOK1. That's okay, but what can we do to get it to a DOK3? Or can I guide and support you in figuring out a way where we can get them to move from just answering correctly to DOK1 to establishing and explaining with examples how they got that answer?

[13:07] SPEAKER_00:

One of the most helpful books to me for understanding the importance of what you just said is Natalie Wexler's book, The Knowledge Gap, where she makes an extended argument based on a lot of cognitive science research, especially Daniel Willingham's, that in order to do higher-level work... That kind of, you know, make an argument or analyze the situation, you know, any of those, you know, kind of higher-level tasks, like, you have to have knowledge to act on, you know, trying to skip the knowledge, you know, and certainly there are good critiques of approaches to learning that are too memorization-based, you know, there are a few things we need to memorize, maybe more multiplication facts and, you know, certain things that get used frequently. But we don't want to be spending most of our time on memorization. I think that's why this resonates with people is because we all remember being forced to memorize things that we then never used again and, in the moment, never really did anything higher order with.

[13:58]

We never really did anything interesting with a lot of those facts that we had to memorize. So the pendulum has kind of swung the other direction and there's this bias against just learning anything, just being able to explain a concept, being able to understand... Okay, so, um, let me think.

[14:30]

Tasks like make observations and measurements to identify materials, conduct an investigation, support an argument, or use models to describe or develop a model to explain. I'm seeing lots of verbs and tasks like that. What are you seeing out there in the standards as far as this type of task? Because you said, you know, we really do have to begin and end with the standard.

[14:50] SPEAKER_01:

Standards are standards. And what I say about standards is that the standards are the finish line. I want you to think of it like the finish line. I'm gonna give you two analogies, actually. One's gonna be...

[15:00]

One about a race that you have to run or drive or ride a horse with. And the other one I'm going to do with a music analogy. The standard, someone has decided that this is what it means to demonstrate proficiency in this subject area at this given grade level. One of the things the pandemic revealed is that we've been standards-based learning since the 1990s. That's actually when the standards-based learning movement started. It came out of the recommendations from the Nation at Risk report published during the Reagan administration in the 80s.

[15:37]

What's actually interesting is that there were supposed to be national standards as early as 1990s. So when you hear all these arguments about the Common Core and how... I don't mean...

[15:45]

I'll get political. They call it Obama Core and stuff like that. I even got attacked for that in Arizona where basically, like, you know, someone would say to me, who is very anti-Common Core. This is the guy who brought Common Core into Arizona. I'm like, yeah, I'm sitting in my gym shorts and after a workout plotting how to ruin the world, uh, at my kitchen table. You know, standards are standards.

[16:05]

We were supposed to have national standards in the 1990s. It was actually advocated and encouraged by George Bush, and it was actually killed by Bill Clinton, because no one could agree on it. So, the thing is this, is that the standards is basically, it defines what it means to be proficient in a given grade level, a given grade level, in a specific subject area. What the pandemic revealed is that we're not really teaching standards as much as we're teaching, I'm going to put in quotes, stuff. And when I say stuff, stuff is basically what A Nation at Risk defines as curriculum. So, the analogy is this.

[16:43]

How many times do you go to a classroom and you ask the teachers, well, what are you teaching today? What are the kids learning today? Oh, they're learning how to add and subtract fractions. Oh, they're learning theme with Charlie and the Chocolate Factory by Roald Dahl. Okay, what is the standard demand? Uh, it's over there.

[17:00]

Okay? Or we just put these learning targets up because we have to. It's an expectation. It is not something that drives the instruction. It's because when we come in and get... Our administrators come in and observe us, that learning target needs to be there.

[17:14]

The standard identifies not only the level of cognition students must demonstrate, but also the kind of knowledge students must develop, or the content students must study, and also the context in which students must understand user learning. So when you're looking at the Next Generation Science Standards, and I just heard, you know, what you described there, those are the scientific and engineering practices. And there's a whole different part of the standard, especially Next Generation, where The first part is generally a scientific and engineering practice. Analyze, interpret data, develop and use a model. But the second part talks about the core ideas and the enduring understandings that kids learn. So, there's ones that say, uh, develop and use a model of the Earth-Sun-Moon system to describe, uh, patterns and lunar eclipses.

[18:05]

And the seasons, okay? That's what the end result is. That's the finish line. That's where the kids have to reach. That's where you start. The teaching.

[18:16]

Then you need to tear your instruction and say, okay, where are you? All right? Do you know how to develop and use a scientific model? No. Do you know how to use a scientific model? No.

[18:26]

Okay. Do you know what the Earth-Sun-Moon system is? No. Okay. Do you know what the Earth, the Moon, and the Sun is? Yes.

[18:33]

Good. Let's start there. See what I mean? So that's how you tear it and you build it up with your instruction...

[18:39]

So what I'm hoping, kind of, for the future is that we really shift how we look at standards. And I'll admit, they're written horribly. It's technical language. And this is the other thing, is that basically, I say standards are the race, the finish line of the race. And when you tell me that I'm teaching kids to and subtract fractions, or I'm teaching Theme with Charlie and the Chocolate Factory by Roald Dahl, or Fall of the House of Usher by Edgar Allan Poe, what you're telling me is that you're teaching kids to run, but you're not telling me if they're running a dash or a marathon. And even though it's running, they still have a different set of skills.

[19:13]

Another analogy I do, and I actually do this in my PDs, is that I show sheet music for Panama by Van Halen. As you can see from the back there, I'm a huge Eddie Van Halen fan, and you know me personally, so you know I'm a huge Eddie Van Halen fan. I got my Funko Pop of Eddie Van Halen just came out, and also my guitar replica of his Frankenstein guitar. So I show the sheet music of Panama by Van Halen, and I tell the teachers...

[19:39]

And I ask the teachers, and I don't tell them, because I ask them, how is this the standards? And the teachers get it. They go, okay, look at all that technical language in there. Look at all the notes they had to learn. Look at the things with tablature. And I tell them, what if I tell you that this is the song that every student needs to play at that grade level, in that subject area, and this is the song we need to teach all the kids?

[20:01]

And then what I show them is Eddie Van Halen's guitars. And I say, how is this the curriculum? Because the curriculum is what you use to teach the standard. Now, the interesting thing about curriculum is that everybody has a different guitar. You know, I may have a Fender Stratocaster, you may have a Gibson, someone else may have a Gretsch, someone else may have a Kramer, someone else may have an Ibanez. We still can play Van Halen with that.

[20:27]

It's just a guitar we're given with. But what also what the curriculum companies do is that they sell it to you to say, if you use this guitar, you will sound like Eddie Van Halen and play Panama perfectly. And to me, it's with curriculum, it's kind of like, I'm going to give you Eddie Van Halen's actual Frankenstein guitar. Or I'm going to give you Eddie Van... A designed version of Eddie Van Halen's Frankenstein guitar.

[20:49]

If I give you that, and I give the students that, then they all should play Panama the way Eddie Van Halen does. No. No. Eddie Van Halen is you as the teacher, and Eddie Van Halen is the students, because you gotta figure out what's the way the students can play Panama, make it sound that, but the students also have to discover and recognize and realize the way that they can play Panama. See, that's the thing about the standards, is that the standards, it sets the tone. It sets the focus.

[21:19]

The curriculum, that's what we've been given to use, but everybody has to play the same song. I mean, Slash from Guns N' Roses plays the Gibson guitar, but he can play Panama, okay? And I believe James Hetfield and Kurt Hammond play, um, I think they play Ibanez's in Metallica, but they can play Panama. All right, you don't need Eddie Van Halen's guitar. You gotta be that guitarist. You gotta help that student discover what kind of guitar you are.

[21:45]

And that's the other thing I say is another music analogy where I say, the minute you teach something to the kids, it's not yours anymore. It's theirs. And teaching's not about, this is how you do it. It's about, what are the different ways we can help students recognize and realize how they do it or how they could do it So I say you're like the red hot chili peppers. You're giving it away, you're giving it away, giving it away, giving it away now. And the kids look at it and go, oh, I understand that way.

[22:09]

And they're like, Frank Sinatra, I did it my way. And also the challenge of teachers is this, is that there might be a way that We don't understand how to teach, because what if I said we teach how we were taught, and a lot of us grew up in that era where we didn't do standards. We learned by learning stuff, and some of our teachers in a standards-based thing still taught stuff, not standards. But also, we teach what we understand. There's five ways to multiply multi-digit numbers. I could teach you four.

[22:39]

Please don't ask me to teach that stick method that came out of Asia. It's kind of like with diagramming sentences. I don't know how to diagram sentences, but I could tell you all the different parts of a sentence. But...

[22:50]

What if that's the way the student understands and gets it? And this is a generation, or a multi-century generation. You could show them a video off YouTube, and they go, I totally see that. Do you? Yeah. Okay, good, because I don't.

[23:02]

So, if you're going to use that way, you're going to have to explain to me. That's this generation. My daughter Avery taught me that, my youngest. She's like, Dad, I want guitar lessons. I'm like, cool. I'll teach you.

[23:12]

I know this guy at Monty, Monty's Music, 80 bucks a week. She goes, no, go learn off YouTube. That's how these kids learn. Okay. They can't just have them passively watch it. You gotta have them actively watch it.

[23:22]

And that's sometimes, you know, why things kind of fell apart a little bit when we all went virtual is because we moved our brick and mortar Classroom to the internet online. That's like basically saying, I've been given a Tesla, and I'm going to drive it like a Ford Edsel. So, again, the standard is the center of everything. You don't have to like it, but somebody said, this is what it means to demonstrate proficiency and perform successfully. This is the song you have to play. You can't say, you know what?

[23:55]

I don't like Panama. I like... I'm more of a Sammy Hagar Van Halen fan than a David Lee Roth Van Halen fan. Why don't you just teach them that song?

[24:04]

Because that's not the song that's been decided to say that this is what they have to play when they go on stage or demonstrate proficiency. Center it... deconstruct it, build that pathway to proficiency, that profession of performance, and then go beyond it. Once they play Panama, excellent.

[24:21]

See how they can go in a different, uh, song with it. Like, I've heard Eddie Van Halen, when he plays the Cradle of Rock on stage, he starts playing Smoke on the Water towards the end. Why? Because he played a song, and now he's gonna go beyond it, and everyone's going, yeah, okay, I see the connection between the two. That's a D.O.K.

[24:37]

4.

[24:38] SPEAKER_00:

And just as a side note, everyone should definitely look up The Frankenstrat, and you can read about it on Wikipedia. My friend Mike has a replica of it, so I know the guitar you're talking about really worth taking a look at.

[24:49] SPEAKER_01:

Oh, yeah, that's why I called it Frankenstein, because what he does is he just took bits and pieces and put it all together and made a guitar. You know, I mean, it's bass, and it's so funny, because I just read an interview about, kind of like, you know, he just kind of looks at it as, like, a tool. And I think somebody, like, before he died, somebody gave him One of the Frankensteins that he built, and he tooled around with it, and he just threw it on the couch after he was done, and people were like, oh, what are you doing? I mean, that thing's, like, sacred. It's like, you know, the Ark of the Covenant from Rays of the Lost Ark. And he's like, just threw it inside.

[25:21]

But that's also how we gotta look at curriculum. Look, that's our tool. That's our guitar. That's our paintbrush. That's our hammer. We educators, we are artists.

[25:32]

And the artistry comes from us. You talk about Bloom's taxonomy. A lot of people use that to create questions. But what's interesting is Benjamin Bloom said, this is not about questions. Questions come from the teacher. This is about crafting educational objectives.

[25:46]

You, as a teacher, gotta be the artist. And I'm paraphrasing, of course. You as a teacher have to be an artist to come up with that question, to come up with that activity, that task, that will address that education objective you created using my taxonomy.

[26:01] SPEAKER_00:

Let's talk a little bit, if we could, Eric, about how work with DOK can help us, you know, as we fully re-enter in-person learning, as we, you know, reflect on kind of what didn't go so well with virtual learning and some of the kind of low-level and not very engaging and not very varied learning tasks that students were able to do during virtual learning. What's your vision for how DOK can pave a better path as we move forward?

[26:31] SPEAKER_01:

Well, see, that's interesting you ask that, because that's actually why I wrote the book. You know, the DOK book was more so, if somebody asked me, well, how'd you deal with the pandemic? I wrote the book, uh, Deconstructing Depth of Knowledge. Solution Tree and I have been talking for a long time about working together. I really put off writing another book. You know, when the pandemic hit, I got torpedoed, because everybody wanted PD.

[26:54]

They didn't want academic rigor. They didn't want steering space learning. They wanted, how do I turn on the computer, and what's this thing called, the internet? And totally understandable and the teachers were overwhelmed. So what I did was I pitched it to Solution Tree and I wrote it, but what happened was, was that it was, they wanted to come out during the pandemic. And I said, no, because one of the things I could see is that because DOK is so intertwined and so associated with the Common Core State Standards.

[27:23]

with past educational initiatives, that somebody would say, oh, this is so pre-pandemic, or this would have helped me on, uh, March 13th or 14th, 2020, before the world shut down. So what I really want to do, and I really took, like, a future thinking, kind of like a Tony Stark approach to this thing, to say, you know, what could this be? The one of the things that people get incorrect about DOK is that it's not Another way to do Bloom's. It's not a substitute. It's supplemental. It actually strengthens and supports your teaching, your learning, and your assessment.

[27:59]

So that's what I did with the book. Over the years, I've come up with my own perspectives and ideas about what exactly DOK is. You know, I'll actually look at... My wife says, uh, I'm DOK version 3.0.

[28:10]

If Norman Webb is 1.0 for alignment studies... And Karen has this 2.0 with measure for cognitive rigor.

[28:16]

I'm 3.0 where I said I turned into a method model for teaching and learning. And there's a lot of people out there who talk about DOK, and they have great perspectives and differing perspectives. But just as long as we all agree that it's what comes after the verb, that's fine. So, I kind of have the idea, you know, I'm with Solution Tree writing this book. And a lot of times when you write the book, you want to also be respectful and complimentary to the initiatives of your publishing company.

[28:41]

So, as we know with Solution Tree, some of their big initiatives are PLC with the worker DeFores, Rick and Becky DeFore, RTI, um... the inverted RTI model developed by, uh, Mike Matos and Austin Buffram, and also assessment. So, what I did was, is that I have a lot of colleagues and friends who are with Solution Tree, so I reached out to, first of all, the person who really helped me a lot is, uh, an educator named Paula Maker, who is really a dynamic presenter in the Solution Tree organization, and she's gonna come out with a book about literacy eventually, and definitely, she really helped me understand about PLC, especially the four questions from the DeFores, and she really helped me understand and work with RTI, and talking to Tom Herrick, you know, also, you know, as kind of a compliment to your colleagues and your friends in this, what you want to do is you want to say, how can I incorporate your ideas and align it with DOK?

[29:42]

And I do that for two reasons. One is to celebrate their work, and also, hopefully, where we can come together and work together. Like, what I like to always say is, You know, I'm Captain America, you're Iron Man. It's great when they're individual movies, but when they do the Avengers, man, it's epic. You know? So, the way I see it is that I really believe that We really need to make the shift in education right now.

[30:04]

That we say we've been shifting, we've been shifting since the 1990s, but really, what if I said we've just been really scrambling? You know, is this working? No. Is this working? No. Is this working?

[30:15]

No. This is the time to actually say, okay, you know what, we gotta shift the system. And the shift is not gonna come from the federal or state departments of education. They're not even gonna come from the district offices. They might not even come from the principals. It's gonna come from the classroom.

[30:31]

You know, for years we've been doing professional development and doing education initiatives where we've been transplanting trees. Boom, I'm planning to differentiate instruction. That's our initiative this year. Okay, that didn't work. Let's uproot it and let's put in literacy across the curriculum. Okay, that didn't work.

[30:46]

Let's uproot it and let's put in social-emotional learning. Okay, that's not working. Let's uproot it. No. We gotta plant the seed as an acorn. And it starts in the classroom.

[30:55]

And we gotta let it grow. We gotta let it germinate. And we gotta let it give it, you know, and nurture it so it can grow out. And that's what I believe DOK is. DOK can supplement and support different education initiatives. For example, PLC.

[31:09]

Four questions of the fours. What do we want students to learn? That's the DOK level demanded by the standard. How do we know that they're learning it? We assess to and at the level. Not just at the level, but over a range of DOK levels to it.

[31:21]

What if they don't learn it? RTI. We tier it to the level where students are, the DOK level where students are, and we build upon their strength so they can rise to reach and go beyond the DOK bar. That's set by the standard. That's based upon Mike Matos and Austin Buffram's Inverted Pyramid. What do we do once they've learned it?

[31:39]

We extend, always extend learning beyond the DOK level demanded by the standard, by the activity, by the assessment, PLC. And, you know, you can use it with differentiation. Are you at this DOK level? Are you at this DOK level? Are you at this DOK level? How can we get you all to grade level and then go beyond it?

[31:57]

We can use it to strengthen and support and make modifications for ELL and special ed. There's a section in the book where I talk about what's called the e-docs. And I worked with a school out here, Arizona Autism Charter School, where we used applied behavior analysis to create a system of DOK where we can use IEP goals to strengthen and support grade-level learning. Or English language learners saying that an EDOC 1 is about language focus and EDOC 2 is about language features. Gifted education. Use what I call GDocs.

[32:29]

Accelerate the learning. You could do a DOK 2 at third grade. Can you do it at a fifth-grade level, eighth-grade level, high school level, or enrich the learning? How can you make it your own? What's your individual way? That's based upon a Renzulli model.

[32:42]

So, as you see, like, I look at DOK, like, as the missing link. I really look at it as something we can use is that missing thing we've been looking for, like, why isn't this working? Well, maybe if we look at these four levels that are not a taxonomy, but describe four different ways students can understand and use their learning in different contexts and different ways, maybe that's the missing piece of the puzzle. Maybe that's the missing link. Hopefully, I'm going to write a book about that someday. I want to actually call it The Missing Link, DOK as a Supplemental and Supportive Concept and Framework.

[33:20] SPEAKER_00:

So I definitely want to encourage people to check out the book, Deconstructing Depth of Knowledge, A Method and Model for Deeper Teaching and Learning. And Eric, if people want to reach out to you, talk about maybe doing some work together, where's the best place for them to go online and get in touch?

[33:35] SPEAKER_01:

Well, you can go to my website. My website's maverickeducation.com. www.Maverick, M-A-V-E-R-I-K, no C in Maverick, M-A-V-E-R-I-K, education.com.

[33:48]

That's the name of my company. It's named after my daughters, Madison Avery, and my name, Eric, it's how I spell it. I mean, I'm also a child of the 80s, so you can probably guess what my favorite movie is. So, again, www.maverickeducation.com.

[34:01]

Uh, you can go look at the page for Deconstructing Depth of Knowledge on Solution Tree's page at www.solutiontree.com slash true D-O-K. Okay? D-O-K. Or you can contact me on Twitter at maverick, M-A-V-E-R-I-K-E-D-U-1-2.

[34:20]

The one-two is when I started doing this, and I'm proud to say that Despite this pandemic and everything, I just celebrated the 10th year anniversary of doing this. So, the amount of years I was in the classroom, I was in the classroom for about 10 or... Yeah, about 10 years. Yeah, 10 years.

[34:35]

I've been doing this, so this has been really a great opportunity. And thank you so much for having me on your show. This really helps being on these shows and being able, not just even just to promote the work, which is not what it's all about, but to share ideas, to really get out there messages and methods that will help others.

[34:52] SPEAKER_00:

Well, thanks so much for joining me again on Principal Center Radio, Eric. It's been a pleasure to speak with you. Thank you. Thank you for having me back.

[34:58] Announcer:

Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at principalcenter.com slash radio.

Bring This Expertise to Your School

Interested in professional development, keynotes, or workshops? Send us a message below.

Inquire About Professional Development with Erik Francis

We'll be happy to make an introduction.