Leading Together: Teachers and Administrators Improving Student Outcomes

Follow on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · more apps

About Dr. Jonathan Eckert

Dr. Jonathan Eckert is associate professor of education at Wheaton, and previously served as a Teaching Ambassador Fellow at the U.S. Department of Education under the Bush and Obama administrations. He works in teacher education at Wheaton, and with schools across the country to improve policies and teaching practice through the Center for Teaching Quality. He's the author of two books.

Full Transcript

[00:01] SPEAKER_00:

Welcome to Principal Center Radio, bringing you the best in professional practice.

[00:06] Announcer:

Here's your host, Director of the Principal Center and Champion of High Performance Instructional Leadership, Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.

[00:15] SPEAKER_01:

I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to be joined today by Dr. John Eckert. Dr. Eckert is Associate Professor of Education at Wheaton College, and he has previously served as a Teaching Ambassador Fellow through the U.S. Department of Education under both the Bush and Obama administrations.

[00:31]

He currently works in teacher education at Wheaton and with schools across the country to improve policies and teaching practice through his consulting with the Center for Teaching Quality. He's the author of two books, including Leading Together Teachers and Administrators Improving Student Outcomes, which we're here to talk about today.

[00:50] Announcer:

And now, our feature presentation.

[00:52] SPEAKER_01:

Dr. Eckert, welcome to Principal Center Radio.

[00:54] SPEAKER_02:

Thanks, Justin. Good to be with you.

[00:55] SPEAKER_01:

Let's talk about the work that you've done helping schools build capacity for leadership, helping schools develop that shared capacity. I understand this book came out of some research that you did in a number of different schools.

[01:08] SPEAKER_02:

That's correct. So, I taught for 12 years in public schools outside of Chicago and Nashville, so my interest in this really started there. I spent a year at the Youth Department of Ed, and then I've been nine years in higher ed, and working with schools across the country with the Center for Teaching Quality, and one of the main pieces of their work is developing the collective leadership capacity in schools of both administrators and teachers together. So, they had enlisted my help, along with help of another researcher, Mark Smiley, and about three and a half years ago now, where we engaged on how to think about this a little bit differently so that we don't think about developing teachers in one camp and administrators in another camp, but ways we can do that together. And so we've been working on a model for that, and this book was the outcome research of that model that we had developed to go out and look and see how it's actually playing out in a rural, suburban, and urban

[02:01]

setting and then broaden some of those lessons out for all administrators and teachers.

[02:06] SPEAKER_01:

And I know our listeners are probably along a pretty broad spectrum of, uh, degrees of distributed leadership. And personally, my experience was in Seattle Public Schools. I was a teacher and principal in Seattle Public Schools. And we had a pretty strong emphasis on shared leadership, on site-based leadership teams, on teachers being seen as part of that instructional leadership team. Yeah.

[02:46] SPEAKER_02:

That's a great question. To find the three schools that we use. I decided to start with high schools. My background was really in middle schools and elementary schools, so I want to understand high schools because of the complexity of most comprehensive high schools. And the University of Chicago has a great survey that most of the schools in Illinois complete. It's the Five Essentials Survey.

[03:05]

And they look at school climate and culture, and they have a section on effective teaching and effective leadership. And so I use those two frames to find schools that had at least average implementation. I didn't necessarily want super high flyers, but I didn't want places that were toxic, where the environment was so bad that they were just trying to get by. So I wanted average to above average, and I wanted a suburban, rural, and urban high school in order to see What those look like if there were lessons that cut across them, if there were things that were specific to them, because as you know, from your experience, some schools, because they're so small, they have a single teacher teaching chemistry. That's it. So then how do you build capacity there with just one teacher versus large...

[03:50]

urban and suburban schools that'll have six chemistry teachers. And so those dynamics are different, and I always hear about the struggles of both. And so I wanted to see what lessons could be learned across all three contexts. So that's how we ended up with the sample that we did.

[04:06] SPEAKER_01:

So, John, as you began your work with these schools, what vision for leadership, or for shared leadership, or for developing leadership did you have in mind that you were working with these schools on?

[04:17] SPEAKER_02:

Yeah, it's a great question. Again, the goal always is improved student outcomes. So at the right side of the model, where we want to end, is with improved student outcomes. And if you work backwards from there, the idea is that you have improved collective leadership practice. So that collective leadership practice will inform Um, so, um, so, um, so, um,

[05:02]

So, if you think of leadership as work, it changes it from being personality-driven

[05:30]

or position-driven to what's the work that needs to be done to get to those improved student outcomes, and then it becomes much clearer who the teachers and administrators are that need to do the work to move it forward, both generally and specifically to the school. So, the model works that way. So, from improved student outcomes back, Going back to the beginning, where you have the principal development and support for it, along with the actual conditions in the school that would facilitate it. Ideally, then, those improved student outcomes and improved leadership practice would filter back into the principal development and the capacity of the teacher, so it's not a linear model. It would loop back to the beginning in order to actually continue the improvement that would hopefully be already going on at the school so that the work would be perpetuated and improved over time.

[06:20] SPEAKER_01:

I wonder if we want to start with the rural school that you studied. Because, you know, coming from kind of an urban background, I worked primarily in urban to kind of suburban-ish schools. And thinking about the work that schools in rural areas do, often everything you just talked about can sound kind of abstract and kind of like a big city issue. So how did some of those issues kind of touch down on the ground in a rural setting? What was the school working on? What were some areas where they wanted to apply leadership or they wanted to develop leadership to solve problems in that particular rural school context?

[06:54] SPEAKER_02:

Okay, so let me give you the quick context of the schools. About 400 to 450 students, uh, is the size of the school. 26 full-time teachers. So, very small, but of those 26, six were nationally board certified, and two had been state teacher of the year finalists. So, a phenomenal school. I actually came across this school in the data set from University of Chicago, but also had been recommended by the state superintendent in Illinois to go check this school out.

[07:20]

So, Went out there. I called the principal first, and we talked for a while, and then we went out there, and the fascinating thing about this place is it's a small district. It's in a community that's economically fairly depressed at this point, and so... the economy has shrunk, so the school population has also shrunk, but the superintendent's office sits in a mobile trailer in the parking lot of the high school, because they're not putting any additional resources into those administrative supports, so the superintendent, very humble guy, uh, really interesting guy, feels like it bridges the communication gap with the school, because he's sitting in the parking lot, and so the principal walked me across the parking lot to meet with the superintendent, got his perspective, and then I went in and started talking to the teachers and teams of teachers, and this is one of those places where you have a lot of singletons, which is what the term they use, and it's used in a lot of schools for, I'm the calculus teacher, I'm the chemistry teacher, I'm the Spanish teacher, that's...

[08:22]

That's all they have capacity for, um, with students, so their teacher staff is small. But what they've done, let me give you one example. They were having a hard time with their freshmen transitioning to high school and moving forward successfully. So they were noticing this with a lot of failures. So, I think it was about eight years ago now, they noticed that the trajectory for their freshmen was not good. So they established a freshman team to bring wraparound supports to the students, and they actually had a, um, dashboard that they shared with each kid and with the team, and they would meet every week as a team of freshman teachers to move those kids forward.

[08:58]

Well, that moved into this open program, that they wanted for sophomores and juniors, where they got to, if they were in the honors track for math and English language arts, they'd do all of the curriculum in the fall semester, and then they would do project-based learning around Common Core content in the spring, and they'd drive that forward in their sophomore and junior years, So that the students had more flexibility around what they were doing. So they'd taken advantage of some of the smallness of their school to be able to wrap around without it being an obstacle that there weren't a lot of teachers in the same subject area. So they focused in on the kids as opposed to the subject. And so I found that pretty compelling in the rural school.

[09:39] SPEAKER_01:

Yeah, where there's not a lot of opportunity for, say, standardization because it's just one teacher per subject, but, yeah, really an opportunity to figure out what is the student need that we need to address and how can we come together as a team to really implement that. And did you see that principal leadership was a pretty important part of that team's work? Was the principal involved or was this more the ninth grade team?

[10:01] SPEAKER_02:

He was fascinating because, again, this is so indicative of leadership as being about the work. Because there, you can't come up with an idea and have somebody else execute it. So, he used this phrase, and he said, I've distilled the practice of leadership by laziness down to a science. So, what he meant by that was, he wanted ideas to bubble up from the classroom, and he did everything he could to try to say yes to support the ideas that came up. But he was vital...

[10:29]

to it, because he had to be able to bridge and bring whatever resources could be brought to bear on those ideas. So I saw that over and over again. The open program, the flexibility to do that was important. His SIPP team, they would meet and included students on the SIPP team. They would do a two-day retreat every spring and lay out what the school wanted to work on based on what was working well, and then they'd develop their supports around that. So he was absolutely integral.

[10:56]

I use the term in the book, he's a catalyst And I'm a former science teacher, so I love the term catalyst, because a catalyst, by definition, is not the focus of the reaction. It just speeds it up and supports it, but it's just in the background accelerating the work, and that's very much what he was. He was very much a catalyst, did not need to be in front getting credit for all of it, but he was very integrally involved in every element of the process, beyond just bringing supports, but saying, yeah, think about this, think about that. Okay, we're gonna have to say no to that part for now, but we'll do this. But very focused on what students and teachers needed.

[11:35] SPEAKER_01:

I love that metaphor. I was also a science teacher and, uh, appreciate the idea that other people need to do the work. And that's not just a matter of time. You know, it's not just that I'm busy and other people I need to delegate. It's more than that. So I wonder, what were some of your insights or what were some of your discoveries about that distributed nature?

[11:57]

Thinking about the different schools that you worked in and the different projects that you looked at, why is that the case? Why does it need to be distributed beyond just a, I'm the principal and I'm busy, so I need help? Like, what was the value that was added by that shared nature?

[12:12] SPEAKER_02:

So I'll take you to the suburban school next. So the suburban school really used PLCs well, and it was seen as a valuable thing. You know, I'm sure you've done enough to know that PLCs can be either a very vital part of a community, or they can be, you know, a bad acronym that teachers hate, because it feels like top-down leadership. And so, in the suburban school, you had a very high-functioning school. with a principal who had taken over three years before, but had been a dean in the school, had been promoted internally, so he'd been there for 20-some years, so he really knew the strengths of his team, and his first staff meeting, which he held, he keeps his staff meetings to 30 minutes, and they're all staff run, uh, because he's like, it's not about me, it's what are the ideas that we're doing here that work. But for his first one, it was before the school year started, he had all of the athletes and band members that were there already practicing,

[13:09]

line the hallways with the drum corps leading the teachers in and all the students cheering for the teachers coming into the meeting. And teachers, this is three years ago, teachers would still be tearing up talking about how much that valuing of them meant to them. And so that permeated everything they did. So, with a principal that values teachers' time, to have Their staff meetings were once a month, and they were 30 minutes long, and they were staff-run, and they held them to 30 minutes. And then PLC times, uh, at the time were an hour and a half every other week. They've now moved to 45 minutes every week.

[13:44]

That time was very tightly managed, but by the departments. So, in a chemistry PLC, there was a second-year chemistry teacher... who was a former bench chemist, he was leading them through on a technical procedure of how to adapt a lab, while a resource teacher was there helping them switch an assessment for kids who needed some accommodation. And all this was going on simultaneously, not driven down by the principal, but space was created by that principal for them to do the good work that they were already doing.

[14:17]

So, it was a very powerful model, especially in contrast to the rural school, because the rural school didn't have the capacity to do PLCs across the board, because they didn't have enough teacher-like subject areas, and so they had to do it a different way. But I just saw that being a nice model of how the work directed the leadership that needed to be done, so that the principal couldn't do all that. And it's not just because he didn't have time, it's he doesn't have the expertise to do all that. But he has the expertise to know how to tap the right people to do that work.

[14:50] SPEAKER_01:

Well, John, I wonder if you could take us into one of the schools that you studied and talk about how you developed the model that you've presented in the book. So, working from the ground up, what was it that came out of that particular setting that you studied?

[15:04] SPEAKER_02:

So, the model, just to clarify, it's an analytic model. It's something you use to look at the school. It's not a, here's how to make this all work, because I'm absolutely not a fan of cookie-cutter Do this here, do this there, and that's why I picked the suburban, rural, and urban setting, because it's not a how-to manual. Anybody that's done leadership in schools knows it's all very contextual. So, I guess maybe I should just take you to the urban school for a moment, because that was a really interesting school as well. They had had a lot of turmoil at the school.

[15:36]

Now, I believe it was nine years ago, the entire administrative team had been... fired in February. So all 13 administrators got fired. And the principal that I talked to that had been there for the, when I was doing the interviews, he'd been there seven years, he actually had a student at the school who was a senior.

[16:00]

And when he heard that they'd been fired, he thought to himself, well, maybe that needed to happen. And I feel really bad for the person who has to take over after this has taken place. So, after he heard about this, that weekend, he gets a call from the superintendent who says, hey, we'd like you to do this. And I think he'd been maybe a year, year and a half, he'd been at a middle school as a principal. Before that, he'd been an elementary principal. And he very much ran the school like an elementary principal.

[16:30]

When he walked the hallways, he kind of knew everybody. He was always picking trash up. He was always just serving. And so he's this really humble guy that is doing really tough work in a place that was toxic because, you know, you fire administrators in February and they have to work out their contract. That's not exactly the greatest environment for developing leadership or capacity. And so he came in the following year and his job was huge.

[16:57]

And the school still had issues to overcome, but in seven years, it was remarkable how much progress they'd made. Not because they followed some model or they did some, you know... PLCs were working sporadically in the school. So there wasn't a, here's how we did it.

[17:14]

It was much more about who he was and who his leaders were and what the teachers were doing and the way he elevated their work in meaningful ways. So... I think that is the big takeaway that I found, that it really is about the work, and it's about the way that people are doing the work, and as to how successful it's going to be. Which, again, I don't think that's a breakthrough finding for people that have actually done the work in schools, but I was happy to be able to take a lot of research, bring it to bear, look at it in an analytical way, and say, here's why this is working.

[17:52]

So, it wasn't a... Here's how you should do it theoretically, and I think this should work. It's, here's how this is working, and it's working in all these different contexts. And when we tested it out with teacher leaders from around the country, this came through.

[18:07]

And so I'll give you this last bit on this. One of my favorite questions we asked in all 81 interviews was, is leadership more about the person or the work? And the teacher leaders and administrators who found that it was more about the work We're typically more likely to step into places that they weren't comfortable than if they thought it was about the person. And so that was really profound to me, because it makes sense. If you think leadership is about the person, then you see all your deficits that keep you from being able to do it. If you think it's about the work, then you see, okay, this has to be done, this has to be done, this has to be done.

[18:46]

I can do that. I can do that. And Justin over there, he can do that. And so then, it becomes less about you, and so it's not as much of a constraint on you stepping up and taking a risk.

[18:58] SPEAKER_01:

And that focus on the work, that focus on, you know, what are we here to accomplish for students, what do students need for us, you know, I think that gives us Permission, in our own eyes, to be flexible and to do things, as you said, that maybe are outside of our comfort zone, that are stretching us in some way to try something that's a challenge, to try something that's new. And I think in a lot of schools, you know, you've talked about three different schools that you studied. I think in a lot of schools, just the idea... Of the principle not having all the answers and not being able to single-handedly make all the decisions.

[19:35]

That is new in a lot of places, or, you know, we have a lot of leaders who come into a school and they have that mindset that leadership is a shared function, that it is distributed in their school, and they find that that's a strange idea. in a job that they step into. So, thinking about that focus on the work, uh, do you have any advice for new leaders who maybe are experienced in other contexts but have stepped into a new context where everyone expects them to be it on everything? You know, you're the decider, we brought this to you so that you can tell us what to do. What are some steps based on your research, that administrators can take to start to bring other people along in that mindset that leadership is shared and that they do have, you know, that other staff do have the ability to contribute as leaders.

[20:22] SPEAKER_02:

Well, the toughest challenge that you described there is if you're new to the context is that you're new to the context. And so you have to get to know the people with whom you're working so you know the good work that's occurring and how they're getting it done. What I found from the teacher leaders we talked to that were speaking about their administrators and from the administrators that we spoke to that were doing this work, some of which were very new, I mean, I just described the urban principal who had to step in in a very tough situation. He spent a lot of his time listening. And he, there was an urgency to get work done. So it was not a passive listening.

[20:59]

It was, you know, where are there places, where are there pockets that we can build on? And then taking that and then elevating those people's voices, and more importantly, their work. Because the work with students, when you start seeing students doing amazing things that somebody down the hall didn't think was possible, but somebody's working with those same kids three doors down that they didn't know about, when you start elevating that through staff-led meetings where they're sharing the good ideas that they're doing and you're highlighting that work, not in a way that you're the purveyor of all that's good and true, but you just elevate what students are doing, then... I think people are naturally curious as to how that's getting done.

[21:40]

So, it's just like when you're working with students who are struggling or being super successful. You highlight the work that you want to see, and then you fan it. And that success then breeds more success. Because I don't think most teachers want to work in a school where the principal is it, as you described it. Where they, like, you need to make all the decisions. Most teachers...

[22:04]

want some autonomy, they want some ability to influence those things, they just need to know how to do it well, and understand that the principal brings a body of knowledge of the way the budget works, of the way legal constraints are, of the way the district is operating, that they also need. Because sometimes, as teachers, we can be a little bit myopic in what we see, and that's not a deficit. As long as all of those perspectives are brought to bear together, and that really takes the principle of being willing to step back as well as step up into that by elevating the people around him or her. So, that would be it. I mean, it's kind of a, just a general approach to doing the work that's context-driven.

[22:48] SPEAKER_01:

Well, John, if you could wave a magic wand when it comes to the topic of your book, if you could wave a magic wand I love it when I see administrators who don't want to leave the classroom and they miss it when they go back and teach again.

[23:17] SPEAKER_02:

and they actually spend time in the classroom remembering what that's like. Not just observing and evaluating, which is a key role for principals and department chairs, but actually getting back in and going back to that first love, if that's really what it is. If that's not a first love and they actually are really great administrators and that's what gets them going, getting back in to observing carefully, not for evaluation, But learning from those amazing teacher leaders in their school, because when you start to see things kids do with those great teachers, which is always my hope for the system, the more great teachers we can have working with students that are well supported by policy and everything else in the system, the better off we're going to be, the more inspiring it is to be doing what you're doing. So if you can get back in and get that experience where you're in either co-teaching with a teacher or doing some...

[24:09]

or just getting in around it with a real heart of what we do in education is happening, I think then that makes that idea of leadership as the work that's being done to improve outcomes so much more real, and it lets you... Forget about all of the negativity that kind of pervades the system right now, because when you see that, other stuff matters, but the great teaching that you're seeing or that you're doing transcends that. So, that would be my...

[24:38]

If I could weigh my... And just have them do one thing, it would be either get in and teach themselves or get in and really work with someone who is...

[24:49] SPEAKER_01:

Absolutely, and one of the big things that we encourage administrators to do at the Principal Center is just make a habit of getting into classrooms every single day, because it's easy to get stuck in the office, it's easy to get glued to your chair answering email and filling out paperwork, but, you know, to put the work first, to put students first, we've got to be in classrooms. every day, so, thanks very much for that. The book is Leading Together, Teachers and Administrators Improving Student Outcomes, and John, if people want to connect with you online or find your website, where's the best place for them to go?

[25:18] SPEAKER_02:

Yeah, so the website is just Jonathan, J-O-N-A-T-H-A-N-M Eckert, so M is middle name, and Eckert.com, and then Twitter is EckertJohn, E-C-K-E-R-T-J-O-N, and you can always reach out to me at Wheaton. My email's easy to find there, too. It's just john.eckert at wheaton.edu.

[25:37]

So, uh, no, I'd love to connect. I love working with great administrators, so thanks for the time to be able to talk to your audience, Justin.

[25:43] SPEAKER_01:

Likewise. Thanks so much for joining me on Principal Center Radio.

[25:46] SPEAKER_02:

Thank you.

[25:48] SPEAKER_00:

And now, Justin Bader on high-performance instructional leadership.

[25:52] SPEAKER_01:

So, high-performance instructional leaders, what did you take away from my conversation with John Eckert about leading together? It was interesting to talk about high schools in different contexts, urban, suburban, and rural, and about the different factors that come into play depending on the size of your school and the number of people in each department. But I think one thing that cuts across Every kind of school, whether we're talking about the setting, whether we're talking about elementary, middle, or high school, is the importance of leaders getting into classrooms. So, one of the things that John said toward the end of our conversation about just getting into classrooms, maybe teaching, maybe co-teaching, maybe collaborating, and if not that, just...

[26:32]

Visiting classrooms to understand the work that teachers and students are doing every day. I think that is one of the most important things, bar none, that we can do as instructional leaders. And I want to let you know about an all-new program that we have for you online, 100% free, the Instructional Leadership Challenge. This is...

[26:53]

So, this is something that's been in the works for a long time. We've had over 10,000 people in more than 50 countries go through the earlier

[27:13]

So sign up at instructionalleadershipchallenge.com.

[27:37] Announcer:

Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at principalcenter.com slash radio.

Bring This Expertise to Your School

Interested in professional development, keynotes, or workshops? Send us a message below.

Inquire About Professional Development with Jonathan Eckert

We'll be happy to make an introduction.