TEACH TO WORK: How a Mentor, a Mentee, and a Project Can Close the Skills Gap in America

Follow on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · more apps

About Patty Alper

Patty Alper is president of the Alper Portfolio Group, a marketing and consulting company, and is a board member of both the Network for Teaching Entrepreneurship (NFTE) and US2020, the White House initiative to build mentorship in STEM (science, technology, engineering, and math) careers.

Full Transcript

[00:01] SPEAKER_01:

Welcome to Principal Center Radio, bringing you the best in professional practice.

[00:06] Announcer:

Here's your host, director of the Principal Center, and champion of high-performance instructional leadership, Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.

[00:15] SPEAKER_02:

I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to be joined today by my guest, Patti Alper. Patti is president of the Alper Portfolio Group, a marketing and consulting company, and she's a board member of both the Network for Teaching Entrepreneurship and U.S. 2020, The White House Initiative to Build Mentorship in STEM Careers. And, most importantly, she's the author of Teach to Work. How a mentor, a mentee, and a project can close the skills gap in America.

[00:44] Announcer:

And now, our feature presentation.

[00:47] SPEAKER_02:

Patty, welcome to Principal Center Radio.

[00:48] SPEAKER_00:

Justin, thanks for having me. Uh, I guess we're on other sides of the United States today, huh?

[00:54] SPEAKER_02:

Yeah, we're, uh, in, uh, very different contexts, but I think the common concern that we share is one that I'm very interested in, is how we prepare... Um, so, um, I mean, right, actually...

[01:22]

You know, there's a huge value in connecting students with people who are in some of those careers that students might want to pursue. Um, so tell me a little bit about your work. How did you get involved in mentorship, and what did you learn through that experience of working directly with young people?

[01:38] SPEAKER_00:

Well, I have to say I backed into this. I was an entrepreneur. I had a company for quite a few years, and that is how I came to be on the board of the Network for Teaching Entrepreneurship. And how it began was, uh, nifty teachers from a curriculum. It's a sort of a education on how to start a business. And because I had built a business from the ground up, I thought, geez, I didn't want to just sit on the sideline and talk about raising money.

[02:11]

I wanted to see what these kids are learning, and maybe I would have something to offer. That's how it began. Maybe I could be adjunct to a teacher... And share some of my experience building a company from basically on the street, honestly, learning as I went.

[02:29]

So, I talked to the people at Nifty, and I wrote a proposal, and I actually stepped off the board for a little while. And I became a mentor for a year, like a guinea pig, to carve out a role. Like, what role? could I do that wouldn't interrupt the teacher, that could add value to a student, and lend some of my knowledge and skill sets? And it worked the best, uh, with the Nifty program, because each kid has to write a business plan. That's part of the program.

[03:07]

So there was a project at the center of this intergenerational relationship.

[03:12] SPEAKER_02:

So it's not like you're doing tutoring in the traditional sense, right? There's a particular project, a particular goal that the student has that serves as the foundation of your work together?

[03:21] SPEAKER_00:

Exactly. And that foundation, uh, it's just like project-based learning. This is project-based learning, but adding a mentor to it. So much of my role would be to push back, like, to understand the...

[03:37]

kind of concept behind the business idea that is student-generated. Huge. Student-generated. And sort of add some reality and touch points to how they're thinking about their business concept. But also, we would push them to actually launch. They wrote a plan that was real.

[03:58]

There was profit loss, there was audience, uh, who's your target market, How am I going to reach them? Where am I going to reach them? What are my cost points? And we would push them to actually take a service or a product to market. So we were on the sidelines coaching all the way through the plan development and the execution. And lastly, on presenting what were their findings.

[04:28]

Ultimately, how did they do? I'd have to present their plan in a sort of eight-minute Public oral defense. And so, I've taken this same overview concept in the book and suggested, I believe, because I grew this as a program under the Nifty Auspices, and I have brought in many, countless business people to do the same. I packaged it so that they wouldn't be intimidated by it. They like the idea of working on a specific...

[05:05]

I believe it's super important to have them be trained before they come in and work with kids. And they have to keep it simple. I mean, they have to learn, again, how to kind of be with a kid in this environment. Like, what is it we want from them? But the book takes it from the entrepreneurship mode to a project. Any kind of project.

[05:29]

This can work in science or engineering or filmmaking or writing an article. Kids need to learn to do projects and spearhead them and see them through to the finish and kind of have the grit to make it through the obstacles and have to stand up and defend them. And I happen to believe that that whole arc... is a cycle that transfers over to the work world in a myriad of reasons.

[06:00] SPEAKER_02:

So the projects, you know, initially you were helping students start businesses, and then in the book you've broadened that beyond just, say, entrepreneurship into, you know, all kinds of other projects, right?

[06:11] SPEAKER_00:

Exactly. Many kinds of projects. So my message to educators, and this is kind of since the book has been published, I have talked, I've been with superintendents, I've been with I've been sort of on a listening tour myself for educators, and my big message to educators is, like, this is wild and new to me, too, is that the business world wants to help. They want a role. More and more corporate social responsibility departments in corporations, and I have interviewed five in my book and more on my website, They want a role. They, it's a benefit to them for so many reasons to come step up and mentor.

[07:03]

The first thing is, is that millennials would prefer to work for a company that's giving back. Second of all, they cannot find the kinds of employees they want. There is a skills gap. And the question is, I mean, that's a whole other conversation. Why is it? Where is it?

[07:21]

And what can we do about it? But many companies are taking these proactive stances and saying, look, we're not finding applicants with the skills we want, so we're gonna go help. We're gonna create that pipeline for ourselves. So they have a built-in motivation, and it's something I happen to believe I've just written an article about this that's going to be coming out maybe in two weeks with this group, uh, Education Reimagined. It's a division of Convergence. This is the second in a series of articles.

[07:59]

But I'm suggesting in this article, actually, that educators might consider doing what I would call a teach-to-work breakfast, like a listening tour, with a host of questions To say to their local business people, we need to hear what your needs are. What is a qualified applicant? What kind of skills do you want? I mean, if there's no dialogue, how are you going to fix this skills gap? So, I'm suggesting a kind of a beginning of a partnership by...

[08:40]

Educators and companies listening to each other and beginning a dialogue. That's the only way we're gonna learn, right?

[08:48] SPEAKER_02:

I wonder if we could talk about maybe a couple of examples, because I'm thinking, especially when it comes to entrepreneurship, one of the challenges for teachers is that students don't necessarily know what's involved in implementing their ideas, and I think one of the big strengths of the approach that you started with is that you really pushed kids to launch, and, you know, not just think about a business, not just develop a plan, but actually execute on it, because you learn so much more from, you know, from actually taking action. Um, but, you know, we'll talk to our students, and they'll say something like, well, I want to be a fashion designer, and I want to have a billion dollar clothing label. And there are a few steps between being in high school with an idea and actually, you know, doing that. How have you...

[09:35]

You know, I'll give you a very nice example. I just wrote a blog about it, and I'm learning...

[10:00] SPEAKER_00:

These creative examples, as I go, I don't have them all. I have to reiterate, I'm not an educator, I'm not a social worker, I'm a business person that has backed into this. And I'm extremely passionate about it because I have done it now for 18 years and have about 1,200 letters from kids. It's just a win-win for everybody. So I'm very passionate about it. Um, but here's a great example.

[10:29]

S.A.P. They are a very high, high-end technology software company, and they started a relationship with a, both a blend of a non-profit who works with schools. The assignment for the kids in maybe a technology class was for each one to design their own app. So, what does that assignment look like?

[10:58]

It could be... A cyberbullying app, because a student has been affected by cyberbullying. And it might be a call to action, or the beginning of a club, or a place to voice anonymously your experiences and get support. So, the subject matter and the need which I would call critical thinking, right?

[11:27]

What is the need that I have and that others have that I'm identifying? That is up to the student. But the SAP, um, employees that come in are going to help them with the technical aspects. Who's the audience that make the student think? Where are we going to reach these people? How are we going to access them?

[11:51]

Just... sort of playing a devil's advocate, but then very much building out the actual app. So, at the end of the day, the student's really done something, and that can go on their resume, and that can go on their, um, college application. You know, I built and designed an app, and it is operational today.

[12:17]

And that's huge. But there could be many ideas. Kids could make films about any number of subjects with their phones. And that's a project. They could go do interviews. There could be many ideas of projects.

[12:33]

They could write articles on any subject and then go get it published or do focus groups around a subject they care about. that are all sort of project-oriented. There's a beginning, middle, and an end with a scope, a vision, an objective, and a result. So it's very, very project-based. And the other thing I will say, um, Justin, is I also take the side of the mentor, right? I want to bridge the gap for, uh, educators and business people to be able to speak.

[13:11]

And the... Business people are more comfortable working within a project. That's how they think. The business world thinks in terms of getting things done and what's my job.

[13:25]

Give me direction. What do you want me to do? I'm there. I'll do it. But don't take my time and let me just flounder. I want direction.

[13:34]

So, if you have a class of 30 and you have... Three mentors that come in from Intel or from Honeywell, you know, each one would get maybe 10 students, and they would come in on a periodic basis, and they would work with students either one or two at a time, and talk about their long-term project, you know, six-month project, and keep them on a track. Where are we on this? So there becomes...

[14:05]

planning and foresight and actions.

[14:09] SPEAKER_02:

And it sounds like the project is really important to give some definition to both parties, right? Like, what are we supposed to be working on? You know, again, this is not tutoring. This is very much about putting something out into the world and defining the mentor-mentee relationship around that product and getting that product or that project out in front of its audience. You know, if it's a film, getting it in front of its audience that, you know, that goes beyond the teacher, that goes beyond the classroom. Very cool.

[14:35] SPEAKER_00:

Exactly. You know, every year, at the end of the year, when I mentor, I kind of bring in breakfast, and I ask the kids to go around the class, and I write a little index card with four questions. And, of course, one of the questions is, what was your highlight? What were your takeaways this year? And last June, a young man who was 15 years old named Moses stands up, and he says...

[15:03]

You know, I want to talk about what I took away. And this is my quote of him. He blew me away with this. He says, you know, an idea without a plan, it's like air. It's nothing. And a plan without an idea is like chaos.

[15:22]

It's effort with no direction behind it.

[15:25] SPEAKER_02:

That's pretty good.

[15:27] SPEAKER_00:

Isn't that amazing? Not a week later in the New York Times, I read about this new book. called Homo Prospectus, which talks about, uh, you know, Homo sapiens, but this book from, uh, I think University of Pennsylvania psychologist talks about that really what separates man from animal is the ability to plan. It takes you from sort of the past to the present and the future. What did I learn? What am I gonna do?

[16:03]

What is my foresight and plan to get there, and how will that impact the future? So, it was sort of taking Moses' little comment, and it all came together for me in a week.

[16:16] SPEAKER_02:

Petty, I wonder if we could talk about the kinds of teachers who you have seen be really successful with setting up these relationships. You know, from the school side, you know, a principal might play... a role in kind of organizing things, but a lot of the groundwork, a lot of the heavy lifting and coordination with students around their projects and finding mentors is going to be done by teachers. What are some of the attributes of teachers that administrators can look for?

[16:42]

You know, who's the right person to make this happen, maybe to be the first one in their school to set up some of these mentoring relationships?

[16:50] SPEAKER_00:

You know, everybody's gonna kind of come at this a little differently. I've just written this article, so you should look for it. This one is going to be called, How Educators Might Partner and Pitch Community Businesses. And I go through, step by step, some suggestions, but there's many avenues. The first thing is, the educator could partner with non-profits who are already in the world of courting donors and professionals. And there's so many nonprofits that are in the education space.

[17:25]

So, that's one avenue, okay? A. B, this is interesting. For the state of Maryland, I've just had some meetings with the Secretary of Education and the Secretary of Labor. The Secretary of Labor will help. At least, that was my knowledge here in Maryland.

[17:44]

That they have relationships with businesses. They know who's moving into town, who has new contracts, who wants to help. And then economic development. There's sources out there for your own community. So, that's one. Two, you need, I think, two things in a school.

[18:02]

You need a liaison. There needs to be one person in the school that will be the kind of community liaison. Who is the quarter who steps in and says, how are things going? Um, who places the, um, mentor within a class? And, of course, before you reach out to your businesses, you would have in mind maybe a business class, maybe a technology class, maybe an art class. Which ones are already kind of project-based?

[18:39]

Which ones are project-based that are already seeming to work in that direction? And then sit down with that, maybe two or three teachers, and say, let's partner together and think this through. We would like to bring in, um, mentors from, you know, it could be a marketing department that works with art, and it could be within technology, of course, that works with New sciences and technology, and it could be somebody from, I don't know, HR or sales to work in the business department. You could divide people up from one company, depending on the teachers you've selected. And then the book is written to the mentor. It really goes through chronologically, and the educator or teacher can read it

[19:36]

It goes through step by step. Uh, what would your relationship be like with a teacher? Who does what? Respect the teacher's role. Respect it's the teacher's classroom. It's not your classroom.

[19:50]

And by the way, Justin, I never meet students in the class. I come during class, and then we meet in the library, in the cafeteria, in a side office. And the teacher assigns me who I'm meeting with on the days that we've planned that I'm coming. So I'm not interrupting or disrupting their class.

[20:15] SPEAKER_02:

Right, right. So the systems that are in place within the classroom can stay in place. It doesn't take a whole redesign of the curriculum. But even if you have, you know, one mentor and one student who wants to make a film or wants to build an app, or, you know, you've got that one spark to kind of kick things off, the book will take them through how to do that, and I think the great kind of piece of the puzzle that I think your work can solve for people is that often we have the students and we have the people in our community who are interested in helping. They care about kids, they care about the future, they care about the school, they want to help, but we're just kind of busy with a whole bunch of other stuff and we're not really sure what to tell them or how to get started, and this is the guide For them, right? For that mentor who comes in and says, okay, I want to help.

[20:59]

I really want to make a difference in this kid's life. Uh, what can I do? Teach to work. How a mentor, a mentee, and a project can close the skills gap in America is specifically written for that situation.

[21:11] SPEAKER_00:

Exactly. You nailed it. That is it. You know, it's so interesting to me that you have this entire universe of adults and retirees that want to give back And that have all this skills and knowledge. And I think educators can harness that and use it. They want to help.

[21:36]

And you don't have to just put them into sort of contributing to a stadium, you know? How can we learn from their knowledge that's being passed down? And it's very fascinating to learn from somebody who's done it. It's a different experience to learn from a doer and to learn while doing. Can't say that enough, right?

[22:02] SPEAKER_02:

So the book is Teach to Work, How a Mentor, a Mentee, and a Project Can Close the Skills Gap in America. Patti, thank you so much for joining me on Principal Center Radio.

[22:12] SPEAKER_00:

Absolutely, and just FYI, we have a website, www.teachtowork.com. Come check it out.

[22:20] SPEAKER_01:

And now, Justin Bader on high-performance instructional leadership.

[22:25] SPEAKER_02:

So, high-performance instructional leaders, what did you take away from my conversation with Patti Alper about mentoring, and specifically mentoring around projects? I think we're going to see increasing interest in and increasing emphasis on those real-world connections that we as an education system set up for our students. You know, it's not enough for us to say, Well, we just teach 3Rs, and we give students a diploma, and what they do with that, and where they go in life is kind of up to them. You know, there is a much greater need, I think, now than ever before, for schools to take a vested interest in how our students thrive in life after high school. And I think one of the greatest gifts we can give our students is a realistic sense of what's out there. You know, and it's been a while since any of us chose a career, right?

[23:13]

But our students are choosing careers constantly, right? They're going through that process of looking in the mirror and saying, what am I interested in? What problems do I want to solve? And what do I want to do with my life? And I think there's no better experience than connecting them with people who are currently doing the things...

[23:29]

that they may someday want to do, and of actually getting them going on actually doing some of those things, like writing an app, or writing a play, or producing a film. The more experience we can give students in those real-world projects, the better. I also want to let I want to let you know about a new program that we'll be offering at the Principal Center called the Project-Based Learning Network. So if your school would like to do more with project-based learning, we will have an in-depth training series for you on how exactly to go about that. What project-based learning is, what some of the key components of it are, and how to get started. And then if your school is already deep into project-based learning, how to take it to the next level.

[24:10]

So, stay tuned for more information on project-based learning and the project-based learning network at PrincipalCenter.com.

[24:17] Announcer:

Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at PrincipalCenter.com slash radio.

Bring This Expertise to Your School

Interested in professional development, keynotes, or workshops? Send us a message below.

Inquire About Professional Development with Patty Alper

We'll be happy to make an introduction.