The Art of Talking with Children: The Simple Keys to Nurturing Kindness, Creativity, and Confidence in Kids

Follow on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · more apps

About the Authors

Dr. Rebecca Rolland is a lecturer at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and is on the faculty at the Harvard Medical School. She also serves as an oral and written language specialist in the Neurology Department of Boston Children's Hospital and as an advisor in curriculum development for the World Bank. As a nationally certified speech-language pathologist, she has worked clinically with populations ranging from early childhood through high school and has provided teacher professional development. She lives in Boston with her husband and two conversation-loving kids.

Full Transcript

[00:01] Announcer:

Welcome to Principal Center Radio, helping you build capacity for instructional leadership. Here's your host, Director of the Principal Center, Dr. Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.

[00:13] SPEAKER_01:

I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to welcome to the program Dr. Rebecca Rowland. Rebecca is the author of The Art of Talking with Children, The Simple Keys to Nurturing Kindness, Creativity, and Confidence in Kids, which we're here to talk about today. She's also a lecturer at the Harvard Graduate School of Education and is on the faculty of the Harvard Medical School. She also serves as an oral and written language specialist in the neurology department of Boston Children's Hospital and as an advisor in curriculum development for the World Bank. As a nationally certified speech-language pathologist, she has worked clinically with populations ranging from early childhood through high school and has provided teacher professional development.

[00:50]

She lives in Boston with her husband and two conversation-loving kids.

[00:55] Announcer:

And now, our feature presentation.

[00:57] SPEAKER_01:

Rebecca, welcome to Principal Center Radio.

[00:59] SPEAKER_00:

Thanks for having me.

[01:00] SPEAKER_01:

I'm looking forward to the conversation about conversation, because as a parent, as an educator, you know, we always want to hear from kids, and yet sometimes it's difficult to, in the press of life and the reluctance of young people to always share what we might wish they would share, it can be difficult to have good conversations with kids. So, from both your professional and personal backgrounds, what motivated you to write The Art of Talking with Children?

[01:24] SPEAKER_00:

Yes, well, there were a few things. First is I, um, had a really wonderful conversation with my daughter when she was about five years old, and we were sitting in the Museum of Fine Arts in Boston, and she was looking at the mummies, and she actually told me, you know, she loved the mummies, and she asked me, you know, where do you think the mummies went? And I thought she meant the actual mummies, and I said, well, you know, they're right here. And she actually meant, you know, where do they go, sort of their souls. And I said, I didn't know. After a few backs and forths, she actually asked me, you know, where were you before you were born?

[01:54]

And I thought that was just such an interesting question, and I said, I didn't know, where were you? And she said to me, I was an old man, and I got sick of being an old man, and I turned into a baby again. Um, and that was just one example. That was so moving to me, because she was a five-year-old, and she didn't normally talk like that. And it made me realize, sort of, the wisdom that kids have, the insights that kids have, at all ages. If we could take the time to really sit with them and have these kind of more meaningful conversations.

[02:22]

And I started talking with other parents, and I found that they also had had these moments. And I wanted to figure out, well, how can we have more of these moments in schools, as parents, as teachers, and as administrators, and so on?

[02:33] SPEAKER_01:

Well, you know, we certainly can recall those moments, you know, when they occur, but it seems to me that we often want to engineer those moments, right? That we wish we could talk to our, you know, have better conversations with our kids just kind of on a regular basis or, you know, whenever we want to. But kids don't always cooperate with that desire that we might have as adults. They're people, they get tired, they, you know, clam up. So take us into maybe some of the challenges of having these kinds of conversations with kids.

[03:03] SPEAKER_00:

Definitely, yeah. So I really do think it's about finding the right time, getting in sync with children. So I offer what I call the ABCs of rich talk, and I think this is a way, it's sort of a framework that you can use for kids of all ages, whether you have, you know, you're working with younger students, older students, and so on. And it's, the first is A, adaptive. just meaning that actually to go with the flow, to notice a child's temperament, a mood, when do they shut down versus when do they open up, and finding that sweet spot of when actually seems to work best for them and for you as the adult. I think that's one.

[03:36]

B is the back and forth. So I think especially in the classrooms and in general, in parenting as well, we tend to talk at kids. So we think, you know, we're going to make this point, we're going to engineer a conversation, as you suggest, without really paying attention to the balance. How much are kids talking back as well? How are we expanding on what they're already saying? So the B really means finding that balance between the adult talk and the child talk.

[04:01]

And C stands for child-driven. So in my research and my work, I found that it's so much more meaningful if we can start with what is on students' minds, whether it's excited, worried, what they're thinking about, what they're processing. If we actually start from that point, we're much more likely to have more motivating conversations and conversations where students are learning more.

[04:20] SPEAKER_01:

Absolutely. Now, you use the phrase in the book, rich talk. What distinguishes rich talk from, you know, how was your day? Or, you know, what do you want to have for dinner? That, you know, the kind of routine talk that we're used to, maybe transactionally, or, you know, maybe even when we're trying to get kids to open up, but might not do a good job of it. What really makes rich talk stand out from other ways of talking with kids?

[04:45] SPEAKER_00:

Definitely, yeah. So I really think about rich talk as having what I call a double promise. So it means that in the moment, this kind of talk actually is bonding you and the children in your life. So you're actually enjoying yourselves more. You might be more intrigued by what the person's saying. Maybe you're, you know, surprised by it.

[05:03]

You're annoyed by it. You're actually having an emotional experience and processing that with a child. So you're both actually engaged in the conversation. A lot of those times, kind of, when you talk about, you know, we are feeling... One of us is not engaged.

[05:15]

We're asking, how was your day? What happened? You know, one of us, or both of us, are kind of checked out. So this more rich talk is when both people are engaged, or all the people in the conversation. And that second part of the double promise is over the long term. So we don't always see it happening, but actually these conversations, these moments accumulate.

[05:34]

So they actually build to help children become more kind, more confident, more creative, and so on. We don't see that happening, you know, in that exact moment, but over time, as we have more of these conversations, more of those things are happening. So that's what I think is so powerful about Rich Talk.

[05:48] SPEAKER_01:

I wonder if we could talk a little bit about timing, because, you know, often we want to talk to our kids as soon as we see them after school, and presumably they have a lot to share, you know, a lot to update us on, a lot has happened during the school day. But as any parent knows, that can be a dud, right? How was your day? Fine, you know, the kids are exhausted after school. How do we create better opportunities time-wise? Because I just feel like it's so hard to get anything out of kids right after school.

[06:16] SPEAKER_00:

Exactly. I think that's what so many people miss in the sense of we have this idea, we come with all this energy as parents, as administrators, as teachers, that we want to get out of kids everything that happened. But there's a couple of things. If kids are, for example, hungry, if they're tired, if they're overstimulated, if they're sort of over-talked, you know, it's going to be really, really hard for us to get anything out of them. And even for them to feel as if they're connecting with us. So, at that moment, for example, I like to really just suggest that a parent says, you know, hi, how are you?

[06:48]

Or, hi, it's great to see you. Something like that. And even leave a moment or a little bit of silence and see what comes up without that more urgent need to get all of those things answered. And with that in mind, I feel sometimes kids really do better after a time of actions. For example, a lot of kids, you know, can go out and play basketball. They have some time that's kind of decompressing time, time to do something that's nonverbal.

[07:14]

And then after that, or during that, all these stories bubble up. For other kids, it's bedtime, you know, after they've had a chance to settle and they sort of feel like, okay, now I've processed my day. I want to sit there with you. And being open to that and feeling like it's not a failure if kids don't want to talk at the times when we kind of have prescribed as like the right time to talk.

[07:32] SPEAKER_01:

Yeah. Love it. So doing something that's physical or doesn't involve talking, giving them a little bit of a break, a snack, not forcing it to all come out in the 15 minutes right after school.

[07:42] SPEAKER_00:

Exactly. Yeah.

[07:43] SPEAKER_01:

Yeah, it's interesting, as a parent, and we can shift gears to talking about students at school in a moment, but thinking as a parent about bedtime, and often, you know, when you have young children, they want to ask you all the big questions about life, right, when you want them to go to sleep, you know?

[08:00] SPEAKER_00:

Exactly, I've been there.

[08:02] SPEAKER_01:

You know, just go to sleep.

[08:03] SPEAKER_00:

Exactly.

[08:04] SPEAKER_01:

You know, as my kids have gotten older, I've noticed that that is really a great time when they're, you know, they're kind of processing the day. They're not quite ready to go to sleep yet. They've got a few minutes where they just kind of need to decompress. And I just hear so much during those times when, you know, they're just kind of sitting in bed or about to go to bed. Just so much can come up, and I just love being available during those times to listen and just kind of see where kids take things. And often they're making connections between different things that they learned, or they might ask what a word means, and that just leads to all kinds of different conversations.

[08:34]

Let's talk about students at school, because as school leaders, We frequently are interested in what students are thinking about, what they're learning, how they're experiencing school, how they're doing with their peers, what they're gaining from the curriculum. You know, we're looking for improvement opportunities as leaders. What are some of our best opportunities to talk with students at school?

[08:56] SPEAKER_00:

Definitely, yes. Well, I think one thing, especially for school administrators to keep in mind is that there's often this push and kind of a fight between social-emotional learning and literacy teaching and saying, well, how do we fit in both? How do we check in with students? How do we think about how they're doing while also supporting teachers to teach reading and writing and literacy skills? And I think my work really finds that you don't have to have that fight between both. So you actually can, through having these kind of conversations, you can actually check in with students emotionally and work on their mental health and so on, while also doing things like literacy teaching and learning about characters and things like that.

[09:32]

And how that works is oftentimes, you know, you can talk about books, you can talk about movies, you can talk about how you would feel if a character, you know, if you were that character, if the character was doing something else. You can talk about how you would like a story to end. So all of these things where you have these back-and-forth discussions involving students' emotions are actually checking with students while also promoting learning. So I think that that is a real key to not think that these two things have to be at odds.

[10:00] SPEAKER_01:

And I'll just say, when getting into classrooms, you know, if you want to find out what students have been up to, you know, you could look at lesson plans, you could, you know, see what's posted on the board, but you could also talk with students and ask them about their work and what they're doing and find the most interesting things that way. I wonder if we should talk a bit about building skills through conversation, because you talk quite a bit about, you know, how we can help our students and our children develop through conversation. What are some of the big opportunities there for parents and educators?

[10:31] SPEAKER_00:

Definitely. Yeah, so there's a few. And in my book, I actually lay out seven different pillars that we can work on conversations to support skills. So these include things like learning, social skills, confidence, empathy and kindness, creativity, and openness to others. And I think that those are really key. And the three that I've found to be kind of the most important, especially for school administrators, are empathy, openness to difference, and then also creativity and play.

[10:58]

Because I think that we often don't see how much kids of all ages need to think creatively and need to think in playful ways. How play is not just about playing with blocks, sort of for younger children, but can be in the way that teachers are teaching science experiments, for example. or in the way that students are approaching history lessons. So really understanding how to think playfully and teach playful thinking in schools, I think is so key. And secondly, I think also in understanding difference. So we have so many classrooms now, which are inclusion classrooms, in which, you know, students of many abilities are in one space.

[11:35]

And supporting students who either have learning differences or who don't have learning differences to appreciate and celebrate differences in thinking and learning, I think is so critical and is not something that we often do in schools.

[11:49] SPEAKER_01:

Well, Rebecca, one thing people will notice immediately when they pick up your book is just how well-researched it is. I think you have well over 100 pages of notes and references, you know, one of those that you get, you know, you get finished with a little quicker than you think because there's that, you know, that bonus section that you don't have to read at the end. Talk to us about how some of the research has informed this deeply researched book.

[12:10] SPEAKER_00:

Definitely, yeah. So, really, this book involved a ton of research, as you mentioned, from various disciplines. So, part of what I wanted to do is draw from research in linguistics, sort of to think about the role of language in conversation, but also in psychology, to think about students' motivation, their interest, and especially temperament as well. So I thought, for example, there's a whole chapter on temperament, and I really do consider how we need to think about students' and children's temperament not only in a vacuum, but how they interact with others. So there's this idea, for example, of goodness of fit. So how does a teacher and his or her students, how are their temperaments either pushing up against each other, Or are they going smoothly?

[12:52]

That's one thing I think a lot about, is actually how do you notice and respond to differences in temperament? Another aspect I think a lot about is the role of autonomy and feelings of locus of control. So how much do students think is in their control? How much do they have what's known as a mastery climate? So, students feeling as if mistakes are part of a learning journey, feeling as if they're able to make mistakes in a culture that celebrates mistakes as learning. I think that that is one of the real keys in a school, and I actually, in schools I go into, I think there's such a huge difference For example, when a student makes a mistake, in some classrooms, the teacher will say, you know, raise your hand high if you make a mistake.

[13:34]

I really want to know why you got it wrong. I want you to understand why you got it wrong, and I want to help you get it right. And students in those classrooms, especially ones I've talked to, will say, I actually don't feel ashamed to make mistakes. I know everybody's making mistakes, and I know the teacher wants us to understand why we're making those mistakes. That's in a huge contrast to other classrooms where students are rarely asked to note if they're wrong, because the teacher knows, you know, the students will laugh at one another. So I think establishing classroom cultures like that was deeply researched, and it's something I think a lot about, especially in our conversations with students.

[14:10] SPEAKER_01:

Yeah, absolutely. That intellectual climate for taking risks and for putting forth effort, even if it does result in wrong answers, that makes a big difference in how students approach their own effort and their, you know, how they respond to failure and so on. Exactly. Very nice. I wonder if we could talk for a moment about discipline, because as administrators, often, I don't want to say always, but probably more often than we would like, we're talking with students when something goes wrong. You know, there's a problem, there's a conflict, there's a fight.

[14:39]

You know, we want to get into classrooms and talk about learning, but, you know, often, some of our most in-depth conversations with students occur... When they're in trouble, and certainly we have investigation goals, you know, we want to learn what happened, we want to be able to, you know, take the necessary actions, what other goals should we have in mind when we're talking to a student who is in some sort of trouble?

[15:01] SPEAKER_00:

Yes, I think that's a great question. And one thing I'd really emphasize is thinking with the student about, for example, what values they have that they're potentially violating, what values they could work towards. So actually supporting the student to articulate for themselves, not in a punitive way, but in a growth-oriented way, where they have actually potentially crossed a line for themselves. and actually what supports they might need to get improvements there. So I think, you know, that might sound idealistic, but I do think that a lot of students recognize, you know, they don't want to be acting like that, or perhaps it is a failure of themselves to empathize, to take another perspective, something like that. Or, you know, perhaps they do have a bias towards this other student or towards this group of people that, you know, needs to be worked on.

[15:48]

So to actually understand if there were these kind of misconceptions, if there are these values-driven issues that are promoting this kind of misbehavior, and then working with the student on those, even having a contract for the student with him or herself, I think can be really helpful, you know, to say, well, what are my values? How can I work towards those values? And things like that. not to push the student in a punishing way, but to really say, you know, this is a chance for you to think through some of those things. I think that's really important.

[16:17] SPEAKER_01:

Interesting, and you didn't say there, you know, get students to reflect on the school rules. You said their own values, right?

[16:23] SPEAKER_00:

Yes, and I think that, I mean, one thing to keep in mind is, you know, how do your values align with the school rules? I think, though, that we can be so compliance-oriented often in schools, and we focus so much on rules, And not a lot on how students are processing those rules, or even how those rules do fit within their value system. You know, not to say, let's talk about all the ways they don't fit, you know, we're hoping that there is some alignment there. But thinking through, you know, what aspects of these values that the school has, what do most, you know, what most aligns with your own vision for yourself? How do you want to see yourself as a person? Because...

[16:57]

It's a rare child that I've seen that does not want to be seen as proud, you know, seen as a role model to others, you know, seen as somebody that other people can look up to. And so I think even if a student is misbehaving and doesn't see themselves as a role model, you know, there's opportunity to support them to see themselves more in that light. And I think taking that kind of strengths-based approach, especially at the beginning when something starts to happen, can really go a long way towards not starting that spiral. I've seen students so often get labeled early on, you know, you're the troublemaker, you're the discipline problem, and they really do play into those labels a lot, I've found. So I think actually trying to start from a different perspective can be really useful.

[17:37] SPEAKER_01:

Well, Rebecca, I know your book is written with regard to students in general, children in general, but you also have deep expertise working with students with disabilities, especially around speech and language. What are some things that we should know or keep in mind, just to understand what can be going on with students who do struggle with language or speech?

[17:57] SPEAKER_00:

Yeah, so there's a couple of things, and I think one is just to recognize how much stigma there is nationally among parents, but even among teachers and administrators about learning disabilities. So there's really interesting research that came out, for example, showing that there's a large minority of teachers that attribute learning disabilities to a student's being lazy. There's many students, for example, who think of learning disabilities as a sign that you're not smart, or even that you're not trying hard enough. So there's so many misperceptions and misunderstandings about learning disabilities that lead to all of the stigma from students themselves, from teachers, from administrators, and parents. And so I think what we need to do first is to really establish a culture where we have some more accurate information about some of these learning disabilities available to students and parents and teachers so that it doesn't feel as if, you know, we're facing all of these misperceptions.

[18:50]

But then I also think it's so important to talk with all students, but especially those with disabilities, about their strengths and challenges in learning, to actually emphasize that, for example, even if you have dyslexia, there are many other strengths that you have as a learner, other than, you know, if we don't focus on reading, for example, and to support students in taking kind of a more holistic view of themselves. So rather than saying, oh, I'm just a dyslexic student, you know, to say, oh, I'm a student. I have dyslexia, but I also play soccer. You know, I also am really good at math, or I'm really creative. To really help students see sort of the whole spectrum of themselves is so important, but especially for students with disabilities, because they often do struggle social-emotionally.

[19:31] SPEAKER_01:

Absolutely, and I think that, that person-first language where we don't start with the label, we start with, you know, this is a, you know, person with or a person who, not a, a blank person. I think, you know, I thought the message was out about that, but I, I still hear all the time just the, the labeling and the, the not using the person-first language. So, an easy change that we can, can model and really uphold in our schools. Well, Rebecca, thinking about the ultimate impact of this book, what are some of your hopes for what will change in the world as educators read your book, as parents read your book, and use it to have better conversations with students?

[20:05] SPEAKER_00:

Yes, well, I'm really hopeful, especially now, at this precise moment in our history, because I do think, even as I read articles every day, that students and teachers and administrators are waking up to the idea that we really do need mental health supports for students, not just for counselors or psychologists in schools, which we obviously do need more of, but we need this to be an everyday thing for administrators, working with students, for teachers. We need this to be woven within the school day. We need it to be a part of learning. We need to recognize how much emotions do impact learning. Well, Rebecca, I know you speak and consult with schools and other types of organizations. If people want to get in touch with you, where's the best place for them to go online?

[21:03]

Uh, yeah, so they can go to my website. It's just RebeccaRoland.com. It's two C's in Rebecca and two L's in Roland. I have a weekly newsletter there, and they can also find me on Twitter, LinkedIn, other social media places.

[21:14] SPEAKER_01:

So the book is The Art of Talking with Children, The Simple Keys to Nurturing Kindness, Creativity, and Confidence in Kids. Rebecca, thank you so much for joining me on Principal Center Radio.

[21:24] SPEAKER_00:

Thank you. Thanks for having me.

[21:25] Announcer:

Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at PrincipalCenter.com slash radio.

Bring This Expertise to Your School

Interested in professional development, keynotes, or workshops? Send us a message below.

Inquire About Professional Development with Rebecca Rolland

We'll be happy to make an introduction.