[00:01] Announcer:
Welcome to Principal Center Radio, helping you build capacity for instructional leadership. Here's your host, Director of the Principal Center, Dr. Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.
[00:13] SPEAKER_01:
I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to welcome back to the program for the fourth time, Dr. Anthony Muhammad. Anthony Muhammad, Ph.D., is an internationally known educational consultant, a former middle and high school principal, and the author or editor of 12 books, including Transforming School Culture, Overcoming the Achievement Gap Trap, and Time for Change, all of which we've talked about here on Principal Center Radio. And he is the editor of the new volume, Culture Champions, Teachers Supporting a Healthy Classroom Culture.
[00:43] Announcer:
And now, our feature presentation.
[00:45] SPEAKER_01:
Dr. Muhammad, welcome back to Principal Center Radio.
[00:48] SPEAKER_00:
Thank you, Dr. Bader, and it's a pleasure to be back, and thank you for, you know, considering me worthy enough to be interviewed and to share my insights with your listeners.
[00:58] SPEAKER_01:
An honor to have you. Thank you for making time. I'm excited to talk about classroom culture because we all know how important it is, but often it seems intangible. It's difficult to pin down. It seems difficult to develop. We know when we see it.
[01:13]
We know when we see good classroom culture. We know when we see bad classroom culture. But we're not always sure how to really define it or what to do about it. So take us into your thinking of what healthy classroom culture is and maybe some of the origin story of this book.
[01:28] SPEAKER_00:
Well, classroom culture is a mirror of the school and the organization's culture. And there actually is, there's a companion book to Culture Champions called Culture Keepers. And in my book, Transforming School Culture, I was clear that the healthy cultures that we studied, there was an alliance between those that I call believers. Those are those student-centered, vocal, influential teachers and effective leaders working together. So we created actually two anthologies. One called Culture Champions, which is about the role of the teacher in producing healthy culture, and Culture Keepers, which is about the role of school and district leadership.
[02:08]
Well, even toxic school cultures have a healthy classroom or two. And parents know that when they're shopping for place to place their kid, They hear through the grapevine that Dr. Bader's class is one that I want my child, and they start to lobby. Well, the Culture Champions book is about what is the teacher's role in ensuring that throughout the entire school, the norms, habits, beliefs, behaviors, theories of teachers create this profile of a healthy learning environment that no matter where a child is placed, that's what that child is going to experience. And that starts with informal conversations, how we interact with one another, how we collaborate in collaborative teams, the guaranteed and viable curriculum that we choose.
[03:03]
So this book isn't segmented to say that this is just the individual teacher's kingdom or domain. that healthy classroom culture exists within the context of a healthy school culture. And every teacher and every administrator has a role in making that happen.
[03:20] SPEAKER_01:
Yeah, very well said. And I think the variation between classrooms, you know, is obvious to anyone who gets into those classrooms. And, you know, certainly, as leaders, We like to tell parents, yes, no matter which classroom your child is placed in, you know, it'll be a good learning environment. But we also know that that is a challenge to follow through on and to, you know, as a promise to uphold. It's a difficult promise to uphold. So, I'm fascinated that you've taken the perspective of the individual teacher in some of these chapters.
[03:51]
And in the first chapter... You talk about responding to peers who have lost their way, and I think back to, you know, when I was a middle school science teacher, certainly you have people who are role models, who are positive, who, you know, you strive to emulate as a new teacher, but you also have colleagues that you recognize right away are going to kind of drag you down if you spend too much time with them. They're going to send you...
[04:13]
In an unproductive direction with your career, take us into some of your thinking about people who maybe are not those believers, who are not headed in the right direction, and how we can respond to them.
[04:24] SPEAKER_00:
Well, as you and maybe some of the viewers know, or listeners know, I've been a champion for the professional learning community at work concept for years. I was a student of the late Rick DeFore, the late Rebecca DeFore, and Dr. Robert Aker. And...
[04:39]
The foundational premise of the PLC at Work process, or philosophy, is that we ensure high levels of learning for all students. The key pronoun is we. We've always had great individual classrooms, superstar teachers, but we haven't ensured. And in the process of we, I have an obligation as a colleague to exert peer pressure and support For my colleagues who are not living up to our collective goals, this reminds me of sports. I was a lifelong athlete as a young person, and the best teams that I was a part of, it wasn't the coach that was the only person that had high expectations. Name me a team where it's every man or woman for his or herself, and we go out there as individual talent and hope that we win.
[05:36]
I remember as a new athlete at Michigan State University, some of my senior leaders saying, telling me, here's a lowdown. We stay in shape. We don't get in trouble. We stay at school over the summer, and we work out, and we get ourselves together. If the coach was the only person who upheld a high standard, that's going to be a really poor team. What's been kind of a part of our culture, Dr. Bader and listeners, that we've been taught that as a colleague misbehaves or underperforms or acts unprofessionally, that's not my problem.
[06:14]
But yet, when I ask faculties, what is your strength as a faculty? Well, we all love kids. Well, wait a minute. Your behavior doesn't validate that. If we all love kids, then we'd be courageous enough not just to congratulate and honor people who are doing the right thing, but have the guts to be a critical friend to those that aren't. And it doesn't mean that you have authority or you have to be rude or abrasive or unprofessional.
[06:45]
It could be as simple as, hey, Justin, we really need you to really be a stronger member of this team. In the last three or four meetings, you've been a little bit late, and it's kind of thrown off our agenda. Can we count on you for the next meeting to be here on time? Do we need to send you a reminder? Do we need to come pick you up? Being a critical friend is an important part of developing a healthy culture.
[07:10]
And I don't want us to develop in our field this misconception that when a colleague is unprofessional, that's somebody else's problem. You don't have to have authority to have influence. The best teams... Exhibit high levels of peer pressure and high levels of intrinsic accountability.
[07:34]
And that's what that chapter is dedicated to. Giving teachers the tools to say the things out loud that people are thinking in private.
[07:44] SPEAKER_01:
Yeah.
[08:01]
can thrive throughout that turnover, across that turnover, if it's strong, and if, as you said, that positive peer pressure and accountability are in place.
[08:10] SPEAKER_00:
And just a piece of research to validate, I think Rand Company came out with a study last year, looking at educators who remain in the profession full-term, 30 years or more. At a site, the average tenure of a principal, I believe, was 2.1 years. The average tenure of a teacher who is a lifelong teacher is 11.7 years. So, the average teacher at one school is going to experience about five new principals.
[08:43] SPEAKER_01:
And if we think in terms of just the total amount of leadership in the school, you know, the principal has a certain amount of leadership, the assistant principal or principals might have a certain amount of leadership, but teachers collectively have an amount of leadership that we need to not underestimate. Like, there's power there in shaping culture. Let's talk a little bit about what you talk about in Chapter 2 around empowering believers to speak up because, you know, certainly there is the individual comment, hey, you know, really need you to be part of this team. But there's also that contribution of the people who are leaders, the people who are believers to the whole. What does it mean to speak up in that way?
[09:25] SPEAKER_00:
Great question. That chapter was done by Dr. Alex McNeese, who actually was a teacher under my principalship when I was a principal in the Metro Detroit. So it's been really cool to watch him grow, develop. He's now an associate superintendent in the Metro Detroit area. And probably if not one of my top associates, he's right there.
[09:46]
He knows my work inside and out. And the, the goal of that chapter is to give insight on how to be a critical friend. And how do you influence when you don't have any power and A phrase that Rick DeFore used to use, that it was so powerful, that really places the stress on the person who is acting outside of the norms or the expectations of professionalism, he would ask, can you help me understand? So that chapter that Dr. Van Nistel gives you phrases and insights on ways to frame a dialogue for a hard conversation. So, if I'm late frequently, I'm always speaking in a deficit fashion about our students, about our district, about our school, about our parents, and it's having a negative impact on the energy of our team.
[10:43]
Or it's dragging me down in my morale as a professional. Telling a person, what the heck is wrong with you? Probably wouldn't be the best inroads to create an ally or a partner. So Dr. McNeese provides some strategies and a framework on how to shape those critical conversations so that you're able to, in a constructivist way, help that person come to grips and acknowledge the negative impact of their behavior. Self-reflect, and then as a critical professional friend, help that person make a shift, but save face, maintain their dignity.
[11:24]
I can disagree with everything that you're doing, but you still have the right to your dignity. And I can speak truth, I can be direct, but do it in a way where I don't lose my dignity or lose my professional integrity. Sun Tzu, the great Chinese general, when he wrote the book, The Art of War, talked about if you take on the methodology of your enemy, you've lost the battle. So if you're rude, and my way of addressing is to be even ruder, it's probably not the best way to...
[11:58]
If you're abrasive, and my response is to be more abrasive, The second I take on the methodology that I loathe, I've lost the battle.
[12:07] SPEAKER_01:
I wonder, as you've gone through the process of putting together this book and editing the contributions of different authors, if you have any thoughts on the dilemma that many educators face where they feel like maybe they're alone. They feel like there are so many colleagues who are negative. There are so many colleagues who... feel like maybe they're a lost cause.
[12:27]
You know, I might feel like I personally don't have the power to turn enough people around to turn this ship around. What might be some advice that you have to someone who's in that situation and wondering, do I stay in this school and try to be a force for good because I know I'm doing that? Or do I find a new place to work so that this place doesn't take me down with it? I think that's a real challenge for a lot of people.
[12:51] SPEAKER_00:
The influence of a teacher in a culture that needs support is typically more micro than it is macro. And that's why the Culture Keepers book, which is about the leadership role, is really, really critical. In places that have very, very poor leadership that has really no insight on how to develop culture, typically the best the teacher can hope to do is to find a pocket of health in which to operate. But it becomes very difficult to wield enough influence to influence the entire institution. It's possible, but it's rare and it's very challenging. To that teacher who is feeling a level of despair, he or she is trying to operate in an environment that is just very challenging to influence, I'd like to give you some advice.
[13:44]
Work within what Stephen Covey called your circle of influence, as opposed to being overwhelmed by your circle of concern. Courtney Covey, Your circle of influence are those things that you can directly impact. Your circle of concern is everything that's wrong with your environment that really you dislike, but you don't have any direct power of. Stanford did a big study in 2016 writing about how complaining and negative, deflective behavior actually rewires the brain. Our bodies are full of electricity. And people who complain on a regular basis, they produce neurological defaults to their amygdala.
[14:28]
And the amygdala is the emotional center of the brain. People who are proactive, influential, they operate from their frontal lobe, primarily the prefrontal cortex. So complaining on a regular basis has a negative neurological impact on the professional. Stanford not only found that a default has produced the amygdala, but it also creates an electrical charge that is negative. And we all are aware of electromagnetic fields where unalike attracts. I've actually walked into schools and meetings where I could physically feel the negative energy.
[15:07]
So to the educator who was in a position you talk about, there's a magnetic field that you walk into that is actually pulling on the positive energy in your body. What Stanford published in the study is that positive charge actually has greater voltage than negative. That if you're relentlessly positive, you can overwhelm the charge of the negative field. So, choose a small group of people that you believe aren't just totally negative, And try to influence them with your energy of positivity. Try to create some allies. Stay out of the lounge.
[15:53]
If you're a part of a negative conversation, try to divert the conversation quickly so that it doesn't spiral into this negative force field that you're, this magnetic field that you are operating in. I would also encourage that person, with their external influences like social media, intentionally pick social media groups. on LinkedIn, Facebook, X, who support the types of ideologies that are part of your core values. Stay out of the venting chat rooms and those who are always looking for the hot take about everything that's wrong. If you nurse yourself on positivity, you'll become a magnet to those who are like that, and you can influence others. You probably won't transform your entire school, but you will be able to produce a pocket of positivity and health that will allow you to thrive and operate, even if it's on your grade level or your team or your department.
[16:56]
But you're going to need the allyship of other teachers and the administration to totally transform the school.
[17:04] SPEAKER_01:
Very well said. Lots of good advice there, and it really strikes me that, you know, we don't really get to choose our colleagues, right? Sometimes we're going to have colleagues that we wouldn't have chosen, but in your advice there, you know, I realize we do get to choose which colleagues we pay attention to, who we spend time with, who we eat lunch with, who we listen to, and who we... Uh, you know, kind of surround ourselves with... We do have some control over that.
[17:27]
And I remember being advised as a new teacher, don't hang out with the negative people. Don't hang out in the staff lounge if, you know, that's a place where complaining is. And I can think of one particular time when I was eating lunch in the staff lounge... And one of the most positive teachers, he was the woodshop teacher, never got involved in any kind of negativity, just always a positive guy.
[17:47]
His job was just as hard as everybody else's, but he always had something positive to say. And I didn't really have a lot, you know, of professional reason to interact with him. We didn't have any, you know, kind of shared business. We weren't on the same team. But I remember he said to me, hey, Justin, you'd be a good principal. And that was the farthest thing from my mind at the time.
[18:05]
But I have to say, of course, it made a difference to me. Of course, that was a nudge in a particular direction to have that kind of positive influence and that kind of comment from him. So yeah, you never know the difference you're making and you definitely have some control over who's in your ear and who you're spending time with.
[18:24] SPEAKER_00:
And to show the power of culture, Could you imagine if the entire school took the disposition, attitude, and posture that the woodshop teacher took? How much more could the school that you were, that you taught at, how much more could you have done for kids if people had made the personal choice to emulate the types of professional behaviors that the woodshop teacher did? And that's the, really, the root of the book, Culture Champions. It's possible, but we have to choose to do that.
[18:55] SPEAKER_01:
Absolutely. So, Mark, I don't know if you'll ever hear this, but if you do, we're talking about you. Thank you, Mark. Let's talk, if we could, Dr. Muhammad, about collaborating for classroom culture, because, you know, certainly one strategy is to shut your door and get left alone and do your own thing, but we can also do some things across classrooms to build culture. What is that chapter about?
[19:16] SPEAKER_00:
Well, the whole concept of collaboration, a lot of it goes back to the work of Peter Senge and the fifth discipline. And Senge's assumption was, or his observation was, the best organizations he studied, they were highly collaborative, and they collaborated around the critical work that people did in an organization. Well, teaching is a very challenging profession. And it's one that Bob Marzano would point out, you get better at the more you do it. But isolation doesn't give you a way to really give you a standard of excellence to measure yourself against. So if I'm working in isolation, I can think I'm the greatest teacher in the world because I have no comparison point.
[20:04]
I have nobody to support me. But if I have a group of educators, So, what is the benefit of collaboration? Number one, it helps you test ideas and theories
[20:31]
In a way that you can have folks who are engaged in the same work test various theories and hypotheses and engage in action research and be able to share with one another, I tried using technology for this learning target, Justin used a constructivist method, and based upon the evidence that we gathered, the constructivist method worked best. Now I just, by virtue, of opening up my door, I just added an effective tool to my toolbox. It also allows you to share the load. So, in the PLC at Work process, teachers answer four critical questions. They align critical learning outcomes. They assess together.
[21:16]
But here's the cool part. Once we gather evidence, we share the load in either supporting kids who need extra help, or extending students who are ready for extension. So not only do I get to learn from Justin, Justin shares with me my responsibility as a teacher, and now they're not my kids and Justin's kids, they're our kids. And I don't have to feel like I have to do everything by myself. My colleague, Mike Mattos, said years ago, it's unfair to expect one teacher to be everything to every student by herself. But I like the chances of four or five people trying to do that, pooling together all their experiences, all their intellect.
[22:03]
You accelerate the development of each teacher by their proximity to one another. And in this environment, with high teacher turnover, long-term subs, and teachers who are alternatively certified, I believe it's almost malpractice to not develop a collaborative culture in schools, Because we have to shorten that learning curve and help accelerate teachers who may be novice, who may not have gone through the traditional preparation program. I thought I was a great teacher until I started collaborating with other teachers and I realized how much I didn't know. And my progress as a professional accelerated because of it.
[22:46] SPEAKER_01:
It reminds me of the old saying, you know, you can either get 20 years of experience in 20 years, or you can get one year of experience 20 times. And I think a lot of the difference is if you're working with other people or just, you know, shutting your door and doing your own thing for 20 years, that's probably going to be one year of experience 20 times over. So much power there.
[23:04] SPEAKER_00:
And I hear that a lot in small schools where I'm the only woodshop teacher, where I'm the only cosmetology teacher. Well, that's good. But you're not the only cosmetology teacher in the state of Washington or in the state of Michigan. Wouldn't you grow in learning cutting edge cosmetology techniques? or auto-mechanic techniques, testing different tools and resources, if you periodically collaborated with other people who did that job, you're both going to bless each other with what you bring to the table. Working alone is more convenient because there's no drama, there's no conflict, there's no disagreement.
[23:44]
I'm always right when I'm by myself, but I have to become vulnerable enough to want to grow, and that happened through creating a relationship with others who are engaged in the same endeavor that I am.
[23:58] SPEAKER_01:
I wish we had more time to talk about every chapter in the book, but Dr. Muhammad, if you could have one hope fulfilled from this book, what would be your wish as to the impact of this book on the profession?
[24:09] SPEAKER_00:
Is that teachers would take back their power of positive influence. As I've witnessed teachers since COVID, and it started before COVID, I see many who've lost their efficacy, who've lost a lot of hope. The data's showing it. I believe, at last count, there were 57,000 unfilled teaching vacancies. About 170,000 vacancies filled with those who are either not certified or certified in a topic other than what they're teaching. Our profession, I fear, is losing its soul.
[24:44]
And if we're waiting for an outside source to bring back our inspiration, whether in Washington, D.C., or our state capitol, or the board of education, or the community at large, you're going to be waiting a long time. The only savior we have is us. And self-efficacy is our only way back to the nobility of our profession. I'll be very honest with you, Justin.
[25:17]
I continue to write. I continue to try to provide solutions. But I think we have to recognize we're in a pretty dark period in our profession. You see it in the expression and the posture and the energy of educators. There's a very observable level of fear of saying the wrong thing or doing the wrong thing. We've moved to being more exclusive than inclusive.
[25:45]
And people don't know where our core values or morality sets anymore. And as a thought leader, I have an obligation to speak those quiet parts out loud and to try to be a voice of reason and inspiration. But the only saviors we have would be us. And when we cease our own self-efficacy, I don't know what's next.
[26:12] SPEAKER_01:
So the book is Culture Champions, Teachers Supporting a Healthy Classroom Culture. Dr. Muhammad, if people would like to get in touch with you or follow you online, where are some of the best places for them to go?
[26:21] SPEAKER_00:
All right, my website is www.newfrontier21.com. I am on LinkedIn under Dr. Anthony Muhammad. I'm on Facebook.
[26:35]
I have a Facebook page, Dr. Anthony Muhammad. You can get all my resources at solutiontree.com. Those are books, videos, streaming videos, etc. And all the books are also available on Amazon.
[26:50]
So there's many different ways. If you just Google me, all of that will come up. But those are the best technology tools to connect with me.
[26:58] SPEAKER_01:
Thank you again for your time. Thank you. My pleasure.
[27:01] Announcer:
Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at principalcenter.com slash radio.