[00:01] Announcer:
Welcome to Principal Center Radio, helping you build capacity for instructional leadership. Here's your host, Director of the Principal Center, Dr. Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.
[00:13] SPEAKER_01:
I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to welcome back to the program Dr. Anthony Muhammad. Anthony Muhammad, PhD, is an internationally known educational consultant, a former middle and high school principal, and the author or editor of 12 books, including Transforming School Culture, How to Overcome Staff Division, Overcoming the Achievement Gap Trap, and Time Change, Four Essential Skills for Transformational School and District Leaders. And he's the editor of two new books on school culture, Culture Champions, Teachers Supporting a Healthy Classroom Culture, and
[00:44] Announcer:
And now, our feature presentation.
[00:54] SPEAKER_01:
Dr. Mohamed, welcome back to Principal Center Radio.
[00:56] SPEAKER_00:
Thank you, Dr. Bader. It is a pleasure to be back and to have an opportunity to share with your listeners on your platform. So, again, I'm honored to be here.
[01:04] SPEAKER_01:
Honored to have you here. Let's get right into it. I'm so excited to talk about the role of the school leader in, as you say, keeping the culture. First of all, you know, what does it mean to be a culture keeper or to keep the culture of the school?
[01:18] SPEAKER_00:
Great question. Some of your listeners may know or have experienced my book, Transforming School Culture. which is the study of 34 schools, 17 schools that were very similar in size, demographic, structure, location, who experienced very different student outcomes. And the premise was, why would two schools who are essentially the same have such different impact on student progress? And it was their culture. And one of the things that all of the healthy cultures had in common was that they had very effective administration, leadership.
[01:53]
And administration didn't necessarily mean just the principal, but leadership as a role. I served as an assistant principal. I served as a principal. Leadership is anyone who has the authority or takes the initiative to lead a school or institution into the future. So it didn't mean that they had these super stand-and-deliver, Jaime Escalante, you know, principals of the year, but it meant that collectively their leadership was leading the train. And in that book, there was a quote that has been quoted quite a bit that a school's culture is shaped by the worst behavior a leader is willing to tolerate.
[02:30]
So leadership set the tone. If the leadership was professional, then the staff tended to be professional. If the leadership had high expectations, then the staff tended to have high expectations. Then I asked leaders to look at teachers the same way we expect teachers to look at students. And if students are not progressing, Then we say, and research has taught, that the teacher needs to do some reflection on his or her practice and to make adequate adjustments. Well, the message is the same for leadership.
[03:01]
If you're seeing in those that you are fortunate enough to lead that they're not making the progress they should, then there has to be something that you can reflect upon in your own practice that hasn't pushed them to that level of engagement, motivation, Effectiveness. And the book isn't just, the Culture Keepers book isn't just for school leadership. It's actually a chapter on district leadership because the same concept exists in a district, but it scales up to the district leadership as it pertains to the cultural health of the entire district.
[03:37] SPEAKER_01:
I feel like school culture is one of those things that we know when we see it, right? We can feel a good culture, we can feel when a culture is unhealthy in some way, and one of the things I've always appreciated about your work is that you help us understand something that otherwise can be fairly nebulous, and you help us take action to improve it. And I feel like we're at a moment in history, like, obviously, you've written a number of books on this that remain classics, and would, of course, still highly recommend those, especially Transforming School Culture. But one of the things that's strange about the time we're in now, a couple years after the pandemic, we've seen things as disparate as, you know, car insurance rates going up, teacher absenteeism being high, low numbers of applicants with traditional certification for open positions, I feel like we're in a very different place as school leaders than we were a few years ago, where it was all about just hiring and retaining the right people and, you know, hiring for a vision.
[04:36]
Sometimes we're hiring out of desperation. Sometimes we're grateful to have anybody at all who, you know, has a pulse to walk in the door. And I work with our students, and I think as a result of that inability to, you know, maybe be more selective, we're finding ourselves having to deal with a wider range of things. And I mentioned car insurance rates just because I feel like that is a quantitative indicator of just a little bit of the chaos that has maybe become more a part of our daily lives in the last couple of years. What's your take on all of that?
[05:11] SPEAKER_00:
Absolutely. I agree with everything that you've said, but I would say that that makes school culture even more important. If you don't have staff who are coming through a traditional teacher education program, we're looking at second career people, people who are accelerated through an alternative program. First of all, I'm glad that those people have chosen to come to the profession. Because without them, I mean, how many classrooms would be empty? And how many students would be underserved?
[05:38]
But the late Dr. Asa Hilliard, who used to be a professor at Georgia State, said that culture is to an institution what water is to fish. It is the environment that shapes whether that person thrives, So if you're bringing in a person who's a second career person, they used to be a salesperson, or they used to be a civil servant working a government job, and they're interested in being an educator. They don't typically have the background and theoretical foundation that a typical, traditionally prepared teacher would have. So that would mean the way that we socialize that person, how that person does their job. creating a collaborative environment where we can accelerate their progress through sharing good practice, helping them reflect on their practice, providing coaching, creating an environment that students center so they learn how to treat students, how to treat parents, how to respect the institution.
[06:37]
In this very tumultuous and unstable period, The schools that are going to continue to thrive are those that have healthy cultures. Because those that were unstable when times were much better, how are they going to respond when things are challenging? We saw that during the pandemic. Schools that were already collaborative just used an online platform to extend their collaborative culture, but those that were dramatic and confrontational and resistant and unprofessional, they just tanked during COVID because COVID didn't really shape their culture. COVID revealed their culture. So, hard times don't really shape your culture.
[07:20]
They really reveal what your culture was to begin with. Anybody can thrive when everything's great, but Wouldn't we say that culture is probably more paramount now than it's ever been? Because how is an organization going to find stability if they don't have a set of very productive and predictable norms of behavior of their professionals? They don't know what wacky policy is going to come up next. They don't know what funding curve, but they can control how they treat one another, their attitudes about students, their professional conduct. their commitment to student learning.
[07:57]
Those are things that outside entities can't disrupt. If you have a healthy culture, you are more prepared and capable to respond to those things that are sometimes outside of our control.
[08:13] SPEAKER_01:
It's interesting, as we welcome new people into the profession, you know, who may be career changers, maybe had a career in a different field, I feel like we have an opportunity to make education professionals out of them, but also a challenge in the sense that they're walking into this more as a job and less as a set of... pre-established professional commitments. In other words, when you go into teaching as an undergraduate and you go through a teacher education program and student teaching and you have all this enculturation that happens from the very beginning, you're entering the workforce in a different position than when you're moving from another industry And I feel like that puts us in a different position as school leaders, where we might have, you know, highly competent adults who have lots of life experience and can learn how to teach, but there's also this sense of professional commitment and the sense of fostering commitment to the school's mission, vision, and values that's so important for hanging on to people.
[09:16]
Because we know this is not the easiest job in the world. we know we have to tap into that and cultivate that and develop that. How do you see that challenge for school leaders today around building that collective commitment to the school's mission, vision, and values?
[09:32] SPEAKER_00:
Great question. A very well-respected sociologist named Dr. Dan Lordy, University of Chicago, wrote a book in 1975 called School, Teacher, or Sociological Study. And Lordy's argument was, is that change is nearly impossible in the current cultural and social construct of American schools. And one of the things that he pointed out, he referred to as the apprenticeship of observation. That education is the only profession where those who are traditionally practicing in the field have been socialized in the field since they've been four or five years old.
[10:11]
So, typically, those who become educators have some level of affinity for the traditional system. They learn the norms, they learn the expectations, they learn the rewards, they learn the penalties, and they went through a socialization process that other professors didn't go through. Doctors don't hang out in emergency rooms at age five and stay there for eight hours a day for 13 straight years. And for most of us who went through the traditional track, when we graduated from high school, a 13-year internship, we went immediately to be inundated in the literature and the research on the profession we just left. And then after leaving college, we went right back to the field that we were socialized in just four or five years earlier. So, Lordy made the case that if you're 50, you haven't been outside of a traditional setting for 45 years.
[11:07]
And he's famous for this line in the book. He said, it is illogical to expect people who have benefited from a system to become the catalyst for changing the system. So his argument is, the traditional pathway of education is one of the reasons change is so difficult to implement in the field of education, because when I was in school, you didn't get second chances. When I was in school, you couldn't have three tardies. When I was in school, We did quizzes every Friday. So what he said was, is that we just historically just reproduced the same blueprint over and over.
[11:46]
We did find a group and who he studied, he called them non-traditional educators. And those were people who were second career educators. He said those folks had an opportunity to witness a professional environment outside of the traditional K-12 schooling structure. Whether it was sales, whether it was management, and they chose to come back to, or come to education out of some desire, not to make a lot of money, but something that was unfulfilling in their other career, that they tend to come with more of a desire to disrupt the system. So, though I agree, they may not have the same amount of teacher education coursework, Go through the traditional student teaching. I would say, in kind of reinforcing Lortie's research, that they present an opportunity.
[12:42]
Because, you know, you and I worked in traditional schools. We witness a very high level of entitlement. You can't tell me to work outside of these hours. You can't make me. I'm independent. I can teach what I want, how I want.
[12:57]
We witnessed that level of privilege as students. Certain teachers who the principal couldn't touch, that we knew were, weren't teaching us to a deep level. And then that cycle has repeated itself over and over. So I hope that it's a wake-up call to those of us who are proud, lifelong, traditional educators. But I think that we, in this hour, should welcome in those who've taken the challenge to help us through a very tough situation, and they may be more prepared to address the issue of change than any traditional educator would have.
[13:36] SPEAKER_01:
I appreciate that framing, because it reminds me of the superintendency of John Stanford in Seattle, who was a United States Army Major General and served as superintendent just before I started, you know, a couple years before I started. And, you know, it had been probably four years since he had passed when I started teaching. But he was remembered as someone who really brought some perspective and really brought some needed changes. So I appreciate your point there that we have the opportunity to get out of the kind of insular thinking of our own profession and learn from the experience of, you know, people from lots of different walks of life. Not that he turned the school district into, you know, an army battalion or anything of the sort. You know, we're still going to be an educational organization.
[14:22]
And of course, we could go too far with that in either direction. I think can only add value. And I've certainly seen that in many of the educators I've worked with who were career changers. Let's talk a little bit about some of the challenges of building that culture that is compatible with, you know, with educating students and with doing the type of work that educators have to do. Because I think the flip side of that is sometimes we see more of a, this is just a job mentality. You know, this is just like any other job.
[14:53]
You know, I could take this or leave it. And, you know, certainly we've come to appreciate that people actually can leave the job if they so choose. But one particular manifestation of that challenge that I've noticed over the past couple of years is around staff attendance. And when I was a teacher in Seattle, we got an incredible amount of sick leave, right? Like, you could get 14, 15, 16 days of sick leave a year.
[15:16]
And I found it very difficult to do the job while being absent more than a handful. I, you know, I think I used hardly any sick leave at all because you just kind of have to be there almost every day to be effective as an educator.
[15:27] SPEAKER_00:
And many states consider kids missing 10 days as truant.
[15:31] SPEAKER_01:
Right. But that's the entitlement we give everybody. And certainly people do get sick and need to stay home when they're sick and, you know, need time to care for family members. But I'm also seeing problems with people essentially treating all of their sick leave As personal days, vacation, you know, I felt like going to movies, whatever. And it's a delicate matter for leaders to say, hey, you know what, this is if you're sick, but at the same time, this is not for you to go to the movies or, you know, relax. Like, your students actually need you to be here pretty much all the time if you're not sick.
[16:04]
So talk to us about the culture side of that, because I feel like we can handle that as an HR issue. We can handle that as a conversation that we have. But in this volume that you've edited, and I know you bring in the perspectives of a number of different authors and contributors, how do we see issues like that as culture-keeping opportunities?
[16:24] SPEAKER_00:
Great question. Things like absenteeism, high turnover, tardiness, um, I refer to them in my literature as check engine lights. It's not the calls. What you're seeing is the symptom. Anybody can have a cough. But the intelligent, professional physician wants to get down to the root of what causes that cough.
[16:48]
People don't sign up to be educators to be absent. And when those types of check engine lights start going off, it's a manifestation or an indicator that something deeper is happening. Are they not engaged? Are they struggling with the impact of their practice? Are they experiencing kind of a draconian environment. We've made very popular the walkthrough evaluations where we walk through and we have an iPad and we give teachers unfavorable feedback to prove that we're instructional leaders.
[17:22]
They're being asked to stay for an exorbitant amount of hours after school, after they are struggling just to get through the school day. I think that leaders would make a mistake to overreact to the symptom. and not really get down to the cause. And several chapters in the book get into how can leaders be proactive in producing an environment where an educator feels affirmed, they feel effective, they feel like they're part of a team, they feel like they're contributing to something bigger than themselves. When I hear educators say, well, you know, kids don't care. They're not committed.
[18:01]
Well, I disagree with that. People commit to what they value. And when I see a school where the school's labeled a failing school, but I go to do PD, and I see young people out there doing marching band practice at 7 o'clock in the morning in the scorching heat, uh, no, those kids are dedicated. They're just dedicated to what they see value in. So they may skip chemistry, But they'll show up in August at 7 a.m. for marching band practice or those two-a-day football practices.
[18:33]
So anthropology teaches us every human being wants to be successful. Every human being wants to be connected. And if teachers are disconnecting by being absent at a very high rate or tardy or disengaged, I think it's incumbent upon a leader to ask, what is it about our system that somebody doesn't want to attend? What is it about their day-to-day...
[18:56]
professional life that makes it more attractive to sit at home than to actually exercise a vocation that they dedicated years of their life to prepare for, but now they find it more favorable to stay at home. The Culture Keepers book is really for leaders to look in the mirror. The environment that you lead is greatly dictated by your effectiveness as a leader.
[19:22] SPEAKER_01:
Let me ask then, Dr. Muhammad, about starting with ourselves, because I, you know, I can kind of recall the children's book about the person who doesn't want to go to school and, you know, complains to their mother, and then it turns out that that person is the principal of the school. It's not a kid. It's the principal. How do we find that for ourselves? Because I think especially for leaders who are in schools that have a lot of these challenges, that have maybe a lot of new staff who are placing a lot of demands on leadership, who have maybe a higher degree of apathy or a lower degree of commitment than we would prefer, that weighs on us as leaders and makes us feel like maybe we don't have what it takes, or maybe this fight is not winnable.
[20:04]
How do we start with ourselves and... Great question. I like to address that in multiple facets. Number one, leadership is a skill in and of itself.
[20:11]
Just because I was a great math teacher doesn't mean that I'm qualified to lead math teachers.
[20:14] SPEAKER_00:
Just because I was a great ELA teacher doesn't mean I know how to lead
[20:35]
an entire department or an entire school. So I think one of the mistakes we make in assigning leaders is the assumption that because they were really good, uh, as a classroom educator, that that means that they have the skill set to actually lead an entire institution. We don't have a good pipeline or good method of preparing people for the very difficult job. We take good teachers, put them in a seat and say, good luck. So I want to start in kind of addressing the dilemma of leaders, school leaders. One of the chapters in the book was written by Doug Gee, who is a superintendent in Iowa, and he writes about the district office and board's obligation to do for school leaders what we're expecting school leaders to do for teachers.
[21:20]
So, if you are my superintendent and you place me in a position and you say, go, good luck. Well, that's pretty bad leadership. The same way a school leader who just assumes that you hired a teacher and said, well, I expect you to do it on your own now, good luck. What is district office's obligation? Because district office is really useless without effective school leaders and effective practice at school. I mean, you're pretty much, you've lost your utility.
[21:51]
Uh, superintendents don't teach lessons. They don't do interventions. They don't provide instruction. They don't coach teachers. They orchestrate. So one of the most important jobs of a district leader is to put their principals in a position to be successful and support them the way they're expecting their principal to support teachers and the way we expect teachers to support students.
[22:13]
So let's start there. Number two. I would encourage a leader, just like a teacher, think about your skill set of leadership. And Dr. Luis Cruz and I wrote a book called Time for Change, and we address four critical leadership behaviors, from communication, which is, we call the meeting of the minds, building trust, which you call the connection of the heart, providing material support and capacity, helping teachers get better at their jobs, and having the courage to have high expectations And hold people to those high expectations. Start there.
[22:51]
Perhaps your suffering as a leader is indicating an area that you may need to grow. Maybe I need to become a better communicator. Maybe I need to be more emotionally intelligent. Maybe I need to pay greater attention to teacher support and teacher development. And maybe I've done all those things that I'm not courageous enough to toe the line and say, We know how to do better, and now the expectation is that we do better. Maybe my courage is the issue.
[23:18]
So Dr. Cruz and I asked leaders to start with those four skills. And if you get better at them, we have evidence that you're going to start to see greater impact of your leadership. So I wanted to frame that question, and anybody that's listening that's from central office, the answer to better school leadership is not to just hire and hope And then preserve the ones, retain the ones that are good and fire the ones that are bad. The same way that there's a teacher shortage, there's an administrative shortage. Central office has an obligation to developing culture through their leadership and leadership teams at every campus.
[23:58]
And a leader has a personal obligation, a principal, an assistant principal, to build their skill set to get better at their job and to seek networks and opportunities like your program. and professional organizations and lean on their colleagues, not as a pity party, but as a professional support system and collaborate the same way we expect teachers to collaborate.
[24:23] SPEAKER_01:
Now, one thing that I think we mentioned briefly earlier is that this book is an edited volume, so you've had contributions from a number of different authors, and I know we can't get into every single chapter and every single author in the brief time that we have available, but do you have any highlights that you want to mention from some of the different contributors that are worth mentioning?
[24:43] SPEAKER_00:
Absolutely. Dr. Luis Cruz has a chapter addressing using our time for change framework. I mentioned Doug Gee and his chapter on central office. Michelle Dillard, who is an associate superintendent in DeKalb County, Georgia, has a chapter where she addresses really honing in on the diversity of your faculty to move your leadership and culture initiative forward. Woodson Plummer, who was a former alternative ed Principal in DeKalb County under Ms. Dillard's leadership addresses leveraging collaborative teams, using your leadership through collaborative teams to push culture.
[25:21]
There's so many that we address as a chapter on addressing attendance, creating a culture where students feel welcomed. There's so many, you know, I don't want to leave anybody out, but those are some ones that come to mind right away. All the chapters are good. One of our contributors addresses engaging parents and creating a culture of literacy. So, the book covers the whole gamut, from student achievement to attendance to addressing collaborative teams and diversity. It's just a very well-written anthology, and I'm really proud of all the authors that contributed.
[25:54]
We even have Mario Acosta, Dr. Acosta, who is one of Marzano's associates, who led a chapter on instructional leadership and its impact on culture.
[26:04] SPEAKER_01:
Definitely worth checking out, as well as the companion volume that has a similar structure, Culture Champions, Teachers Supporting a Healthy Classroom Culture. But this book is Culture Keepers, Leaders Creating a Healthy School Culture. Dr. Anthony Muhammad, thank you so much for your time today. It's been a pleasure.
[26:21] SPEAKER_00:
Thank you, Dr. Bader, and it's always a pleasure to be on your platform.
[26:24] Announcer:
Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at principalcenter.com slash radio.