Barbara Blackburn—Rigor In Your School: A Toolkit for Leaders

Follow on Apple Podcasts · Spotify · YouTube · more apps

About Barbara Blackburn, PhD

Barbara Blackburn, PhD is the author of 18 books and a full-time consultant who works with schools around the world to help raise the level of rigor and motivation for professional educators and students alike. Dr. Blackburn has been named to the Top 30 Education Gurus by Global Gurus for 3 years running, and she’s co-author of the book Rigor In Your School: A Toolkit for Leaders

Full Transcript

[00:01] SPEAKER_01:

Welcome to Principal Center Radio, bringing you the best in professional practice.

[00:06] Announcer:

Here's your host, director of the Principal Center, and champion of high-performance instructional leadership, Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.

[00:15] SPEAKER_02:

I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to welcome back to the program my friend, Dr. Barbara Blackburn. Dr. Blackburn is the author of 19 books and is a full-time consultant who works with schools around the world to help them raise the level of rigor and motivation for professional educators and students alike. Dr. Blackburn has been named to the Top 30 Education Gurus by Global Gurus for three years running, and she's the author of Rigor in Your School, a Toolkit for Leaders, which we're here to talk about today.

[00:46] Announcer:

And now, our feature presentation.

[00:48] SPEAKER_02:

Dr. Blackburn, welcome back to Principal Center Radio.

[00:51] SPEAKER_00:

Oh, thank you. You know, it's always a pleasure, Justin, and you have to call me Barbara.

[00:55] SPEAKER_02:

Will do. It's always great to speak with you about rigor and to speak with you about your work with schools, and particularly with leaders. I'm excited that we get to talk today about rigor from a leadership perspective, because as leaders, we get to see the differences from classroom to classroom, and if we've worked in multiple schools, we get to see the differences from school to school, you know. I think as individual classroom teachers, you know, we all think we're being as rigorous as we can be, right? We think we're doing the best that we can. But as leaders, we have a different opportunity to see into different classrooms, to even visit other schools and get a perspective on, you know, kind of the full picture of rigor and the opportunities that we have to raise the level of rigor in our school, both across the board and working with individual teachers.

[01:40]

So, thanks very much for joining me to talk about rigor in your school, a toolkit for leaders. And I wonder if we could start just with some definitions. I know you are our profession's, uh, probably leading expert on what rigor is. So, what is your definition, Barbara, of rigor?

[01:55] SPEAKER_00:

You know, it's real interesting that you ask that, because I'm going to back up a little bit. One of the real issues we have in education is that people, whether it's leaders or teachers, misunderstand rigor. And so, they think it's making it harder or doubling the amount of work. And I actually find that one is very true with parents. If you send home double the homework, they think you're more rigorous. And those really aren't true.

[02:24]

Rigor has a very negative connotation for a lot of people. But if you really boil rigor down, it is about taking a student from where they are And then taking them to a higher level of learning. And the way I think you do that, I have a four-part definition. Rigor is creating an environment, so that's the first part, in which each student is held to high expectations, so that's the second one. They are supported so that each student can learn at high levels, so supported is the second part. And then each student demonstrates learning at a high level, so that's your fourth part.

[03:02]

And that is far broader than the traditional view of rigor, because what it boils down to is we've got to create an environment, and that's where a leader really is just critical. Something that celebrates rigor rather than making it punishment. Having those high expectations, which is critical for teachers to do, but again, it starts at the top. Providing the right support, because the higher the level of rigor, the higher the need for support. And that has to be facilitated in terms of an attitude and actions from the top. Because if we act like, well, students should just get there on their own, then that's not helping.

[03:47]

And then each student demonstrates learning at a high level. And again, from a school-wide perspective, that means providing time for teachers to work together to assess what they're doing and determine if it's rigorous or not, using a protocol to do that, that gives some guidance to teachers, allowing them to do learning walks, observe each other's classrooms, those kinds of things. So, really, if you're going to accomplish rigor in a classroom, It starts with, are we going to encourage rigor in our schools?

[04:24] SPEAKER_02:

Well, Barbara, as we think about putting those kind of conditions in place where students can learn at high levels, um, I'm thinking about the importance of culture and the importance of creating a culture For staff, you know, a professional climate for educators where rigor is really the norm, you know, where it's just part of how we talk. And I'm thinking back to my own experience as a principal, you know, often encountering language or encountering people saying things that really go against A culture of rigor, you know, things about their expectations for students that maybe are not high for all students, things about, you know, kind of the expectations we hold ourselves to, you know, and it's easy to slip into patterns that, uh, you know, that take us away from that culture of rigor. So what's your thinking around how leaders create a culture for rigor?

[05:14]

What is it that we need to be thinking about from that foundational kind of cultural piece?

[05:19] SPEAKER_00:

Well, culture is critical. Uh, the structure of the book, uh, we use a compass, because with leadership, you need a compass to go to true north. And whatever that is, if it's rigor or technology or whatever, a compass can guide you. And so, the aspects of the compass are culture, ownership and shared vision, managing data, professional development, advocacy, shared accountability, and structures to sustain success. And so, the C of that is culture. And when I work with principals, one of the things I find as soon as I start talking about culture, they just roll their eyes sometimes because, you know, culture is this thing that exists that we can impact, but oftentimes we don't, or oftentimes there are other impacts that take over.

[06:10]

For example, if I'm the principal of a middle school, I may be really trying to build a very collaborative environment with teachers working together, and that being a really positive way to impact student learning. But if I've got a third of my teachers who don't want to work with other teachers, they can sabotage those efforts. And so culture becomes more than just what I do, It becomes everything in the school that shapes that environment. And it's almost like jello. If you tried to just pick up some jello with your hand, it would go all over the place through your fingers. Sometimes culture's like that.

[06:52]

You try to get something to happen, and it goes all over the place. And so, one of the things I like in this book, Ron Williamson, who's my co-author, he had found a model... for impacting culture, which is much more concrete. So, rather than just saying, I'm going to get everybody on the same page, it allows you to design a very specific plan.

[07:17]

So, for example, he talks about there's four aspects of culture that you can impact. The first one is rituals and ceremonies. That how we do our rituals and ceremonies make a difference to our culture. Um, so, for example, if the only thing we have is a teacher of the year award, and basically it just gets passed around to different teachers from year to year, we're really not rewarding excellence. It's a ritual that doesn't mean very much. And if, for example, with students, we only have honor roll, which celebrates achievement, there are some students who are never going to make the honor roll.

[08:02]

So, keep that, because parents will get all over you if you don't. So, keep your honor roll, but add a principal's progress roll, which is for any student who makes progress during the grading period. So, it allows you to keep your focus on achievement, but also add in an element of, we're going to celebrate everyone who is making progress, and the goal is that all students are making progress. So, it really is a matter of thinking about what you're doing. And again, going back to teachers, when I was at the university, one of my grad students was at an at-risk school. New principal came in, and, you know, she announces she's going to do the Golden Apple Award.

[08:45]

And, you know, those can be very positive. In this case, it wasn't. She said it was going to celebrate student learning. It was really going to make a difference. She's trying to build a positive climate. So, the first time it was given out, she gave it to the assistant principal, who had totally redone the assessment system that was going to be used throughout the year for diagnosis and remediation.

[09:09]

So, you know, the teachers were sort of okay with that. They were like, yeah, that makes a difference, makes our jobs easier. You know, that's okay. Well, then the second one she gave the next month was to the school secretary for inputting data. So, by that point, the teachers are like, you know what, she really doesn't care about us. Because if she cared about us, we would have been one of the first two.

[09:31]

Does that make sense?

[09:32] SPEAKER_02:

Absolutely. It's like, it's like sending a message about what you value without having to actually say what you value, though, of course, that might help in this particular case.

[09:42] SPEAKER_00:

Right. And so that really leads into the next one, which is heroes and heroines. Who is viewed, you know, as someone who is a role model? And sometimes the ones we want are not the ones that are really the role models for teachers. Another one of my grad students had a situation and the principal had given him a mentor and he was doing really well and he was trying something new and his mentor pulled him aside and said, you need to know that you can't do something new without checking with the department chairperson. And he said, you know, the principal told me just to check with you.

[10:22]

She said, no, you don't understand. Her husband is the superintendent, so nobody does anything in this building without checking with her. And so, the principal had a heroine in the school who would not have been someone that he wanted it to be. And so, you know, you have to watch out because culture is sometimes the unknown stuff that is going on, the hidden part of school. So, one of the strategies we recommend that blends those two together...

[10:51]

is something called name it, claim it, and explain it. And what happens is, when you're going to do a faculty meeting, you're going to start your faculty meeting by having something up on the screen when teachers come in. It can be a video, it can be just a, uh, picture, and what has happened is that prior to that, as you have been out in the school, whether for formal observations, walkthroughs, or you just happen to pop in, you take a picture or a video of a teacher who is doing something, uh, positive with rigor. They are trying something new. They are doing something that is more rigorous than it was. So, you snap the picture or the video, you put it up, And what you're going to ask the teacher to do is name it and claim it as hers or his and explain it.

[11:40]

Now, you need to warn the teacher. Because if they just get hit with it, they're not prepared to really talk about it. And, um, particularly some of your teachers aren't real good at sharing in front of everybody. So you definitely want to make sure you warn them ahead of time. But what it does is it creates a ritual that says, our number one focus in our buildings is increasing rigor to impact student achievement. And I'm going to show you people who are doing that well, so I can raise up the teachers.

[12:12]

And it's a very, very effective strategy. Now, I did have one principal, and she said, you know, we just don't do that many meetings, and I want to find a different way to do it. She used email to do it. She would take a picture or video, shoot it out to everybody, and say, this was from...

[12:32]

You know, Justin's classroom. And take a look at it. And Justin, you need to reply to all and tell everybody about it. And then if y'all have any questions, you know, just email Justin. So, you create that ritual that focuses on what you want to achieve and begins to raise up the people who are on board with it.

[12:51] SPEAKER_02:

Well, I'm glad you used that term, raise up, because I feel like in every team, or every grade level, or every department, there's a hierarchy, right? There's the person who's been there the longest, maybe there's the queen bee, or maybe there's the go-getter who is kind of the... You know, the star of the team. And that status can actually keep people from recognizing ways that they're improving or keep people from trying new things.

[13:18]

You know, if I see my role on the team as not being the top dog, it's going to be harder for me to be... willing to take risks and try new things and, you know, and really raise the level of rigor in my classroom. So being held up as an example, like you just said, you know, it might be a little bit uncomfortable for people, but I think if we're going to send a signal about what we value, you know, other than just, you know, who's the highest status person on the team, I think that can really shake things up and really can push people who maybe are in that, you know, highest status position to really up their game as well.

[13:52] SPEAKER_00:

Yeah, and, you know, I've had principals tell me, they've said, you know, I've got one teacher, and I don't care what I say to her, she's not going to share her story. Well, in that case, you share it and say, you know, this is who it belongs to, and it was just so good that I want to share it with everybody. And so, there are ways to get around that. The other piece that I would strongly recommend to principals is be careful who you pick. For the first two to three. And they need to not be your hot shot stars.

[14:24]

Because if you do that, everybody just goes, well, of course he got picked. Because he always gets picked first. So, what you want to do is find your just good middle-of-the-road teachers who are doing something and get the picture there. Because what you want to do is send the message that everybody in the school is making improvement, not just that top 10% that everybody just rolls their eyes with.

[14:45] SPEAKER_02:

I love how many specific tools you have in the book for assessing culture around rigor, for shaping culture around rigor. And it's worth pointing out, I don't know that we've specifically mentioned this yet, other than in the title, but this is a very tool-focused book. Uh, you know, you don't have these long chapters full of paragraph after paragraph of exposition. This really is a very tool-focused book.

[15:05] SPEAKER_00:

It is. I was gonna have to count. There's 10 in the chapter on culture. In the whole book, there's 106. So, everything is chunked around a tool. So, it's very clear to see.

[15:20]

So, some others in the culture chapter, there's one on turnaround stories, using rewards and reinforcements, self-assessment, cultural audit, cultural assessment, which is different, mental adjustments that need to be made. So, it's, like you say, it is very tool-heavy.

[15:38] SPEAKER_02:

Well, and I want to point out the tool on page 56, the Assessing Rigor in Your School's Culture, is definitely one for people to check out. If you're thinking about this issue of culture and, you know, what is our culture around rigor in this school, because that's a more specific question than, you know, just what is the culture like in our school. If you want to specifically assess rigor, well, hey, flip to page 56, ask yourself the questions in that chart, fill in the examples for each of the categories there, and you are well on your way. But, uh, Barbara, I know we wanted to move on into talking a little bit about, uh, how we act on that information as well, and how we kind of create a vision for improvement in regards to rigor. So, talk to me a little bit about how leaders create that vision. If we know we want to move in the direction of increasing rigor, and we've done some assessment, we've taken stock of where we are currently as a school, how do we go about creating a vision and sharing that vision with our staff?

[16:34] SPEAKER_00:

That is critical, again, and, you know, I hate to use the word critical too much, but honestly, almost everything a leader does is critical. I really think if you are going to do it right, you don't create the vision. You work with your faculty and staff and parents, all your stakeholders... And create that vision.

[16:58]

Now, I would start just by working with your teachers, um, and really get them on board and then sort of go from there. But you want them to have input into that vision so that it's not just another thing they're told to do. Because when I go into schools to do walkthroughs with principals, you know, I'll ask teachers, what's the vision for the school or what's the mission? They don't know. You know, that just becomes this thing that gets posted. But if they've got ownership in it, Then it's much more powerful.

[17:27]

So, two quick strategies that are in the book. One is called the hot air balloon. And what you do, you ask teachers to imagine they are in a hot air balloon above the school. And what do they see, hear, feel that's in the school that makes it rigorous? And then you ask them to imagine that it's five years from now they're above the school. What do they see, hear, feel?

[17:52]

And compare the two. And what it does is, it forces them in a really concrete way to identify what is happening. And then that sets your vision, and you create that using those two. Now, the other one that I found very effective, and honestly, it's my favorite one, is to use vision letters. Um, and what you do is, you ask teachers to write you a letter. They need to imagine it's the last day of school.

[18:23]

And maybe you do this You know, before school starts. It's the last day of school. It was their best year ever. It was the most rigorous year in which they had ever taught. Uh, the level of rigor was high. Students were engaged.

[18:37]

Students were working up to those high levels. You know, they were demonstrating learning at high levels. And it was really their best year. Write me a letter explaining what happened with your students, what that was like, and what did you do to help make that happen. And then, if I'm doing it on a workshop, I have teachers, you know, do a pair share kind of thing. But, ideally, what you do is you meet with teachers, either individually or by grade level or department, you know, whatever you need to do for your organization.

[19:12]

And you ask them to share their letter. And you give them some feedback. You ask them, you know, how can I help you achieve that vision? And then you have the teachers work together...

[19:24]

Well, I love that.

[19:34] SPEAKER_02:

I think that's a great kind of bookend that we've put in place from talking about assessing the culture and kind of figuring out where things are currently, leaping straight to the end and saying, okay, where do we want to be at the end of the year, or where do we want to be five years from now, looking back? And I think often, as leaders, we get bogged down in the process to go from point A to point B, and really the power comes in finding clarity about where we are currently, and then getting clear on that vision of where we want to end up, and then in the middle, as, you know, as we're on that journey, we'll figure it out. If we know where we are, and we know where we're going, we don't have to know, you know, am I going to turn left, you know, in 500 paces three hours from now? You know, we'll...

[20:17]

We'll figure that out as we go down the trail. But let's do talk about, you know, that trail a little bit when, you know, when we're in the midst of implementing that vision and doing the professional development and helping teachers build their own capacity for rigorous instruction. What are some things that we need to think about as leaders in terms of planning and leading that PD?

[20:35] SPEAKER_00:

Well, the first thing you have to do is assess what you're already doing. You just absolutely have to do that because you need to know where you are To get started. And then, uh, refine what you're already doing to help it accomplish your goals. I mean, going back to culture, professional development is a ritual. And if you're not using it to support your goals, then you've got a problem. Because you really need to get that focus on where you're going.

[21:03]

And so, those are the first two tools that we start with. And then we start talking about professional learning. Yeah.

[21:29]

Uh, related to professional learning communities, and you could certainly use that with teachers. So, you really begin to get a feel for, here's what we're already doing, here's where we need to go, here's how we feel about that, so we figure out how to adjust. And then you can use, you know, there's standard stuff. We use book studies. Um, you know, we do learning walks. I really like learning walks with teachers.

[21:52]

I don't think they always have to be their grade level or subject area. I think we learn a lot when we go look at somebody else that's doing something different. Uh, and that also can facilitate scheduling a little bit. It's nice to get to go to another school, but sometimes that's just not practical. So, do it as much as you can where you are. There's so many technology ways to do PD these days.

[22:15]

So, you know, there's just all kinds of things. Videos you can critique, which actually really help. So you've got all of those kinds of things. One of the most powerful is looking at student work. And what's interesting is, I would tell you there's two parts to that. And the part I actually think is more important is not looking at what the students did, but look at what the task is asking them to do.

[22:39]

You can have a very rigorous task, and students will do it all over the board. Some of them at a rigorous level, some of them not. You can also have a very low-level task, and you'll have some students who will take it to a very high level. So, what you can control as the teacher is, what are you asking them to do? And not just look at the verbs. You know, I all the time have teachers say, oh, create.

[23:02]

As long as my students are creating. No. You know, create is very different if I'm creating a model of an artificial arm and using that for specific medical purposes and analyzing and doing a lot of high-level work there. And...

[23:20]

creating a picture of what I read in the story. Those are very different things, and, you know, a lot of teachers think as long as it's that verb, so you really do need to use a protocol for that. Uh, my bias is Webb's depth of knowledge, because I do think that they go much more into the depth and complexity. Uh, if you're using blooms, that's fine, but you've got to get past that verb. Uh, so...

[23:47]

Having them look at the work means more than looking at what the students did. So, there's just a lot of different ways to do that. And then, as you're moving along, one of the tools that I think you'll find helpful is assessing your PLC. You know, figuring out if you think it's working or not working. It's interesting because that one's actually in the chapter on structures. We definitely have some overlap there.

[24:16]

But, I wanted to mention, we're going to give everybody the website at the end, I know. But, you got a couple places to go on the website. There's over a hundred free resources. And they're all free. You don't have to register, and you have copyright permission to use them. So, you can go to Just for Leaders and find all kinds of things that are specific to leaders, but you can access downloads from all the books...

[24:42]

And you just go to free and book downloads and choose your book. So, I had pulled it up and, for example, the Refining Your Professional Development tool is up on here so you can get that for free. The Assess Your PLC, you can download that for free. The Protocol for Classroom Observations. So, there's all kinds of tools up there that you can get and look at and it really does give you a good feel for the kinds of things that are in the book.

[25:10] SPEAKER_02:

So the book is Rigor in Your School, a Toolkit for Leaders. And, Barbara, if people want to find you online and download all those resources that you just mentioned, could you give your website?

[25:21] SPEAKER_00:

It's very easy. It's barbarablackburnonline.com. Don't go to BarbaraBlackburn.com. That is a lady who writes thrillers about terrorism in Washington, and that is not me.

[25:32]

Uh, you can also just Google Barbara Blackburn and rigor, and you will find me. All kinds of resources. Contact me, so if you need to get a hold of me, you can do it. Uh, you can catch me on Twitter at BarbBlackburn. So, it's pretty easy to get in touch with me.

[25:48] SPEAKER_02:

Well, Barbara, thanks so much for joining me again on Principal Center Radio. It's been a pleasure.

[25:52] SPEAKER_00:

Okay, thank you.

[25:54] SPEAKER_01:

And now, Justin Bader on high-performance instructional leadership.

[25:58] SPEAKER_02:

So, high-performance instructional leaders, what did you take away from my conversation with Dr. Blackburn about leading for rigor? One of the big things that stands out to me is just the ready availability of assessment tools. You know, we think about these big concepts like rigor or things like PLCs, and we think that we have got to figure it out ourselves. We've got to figure out how we're doing, where we are, where to go next. And it only makes sense to not start from scratch, to not make it up ourselves, and to use the tools that are available to us to assess where we are and to figure out our next steps.

[26:34]

So I really do want to encourage you to check out the tools that Dr. Blackburn makes available in her book and on her website. Because this is ongoing work, and you don't have to be doing a new initiative to focus on rigor. You don't have to decide that this is going to be the year of rigor. And it doesn't have to be something new. It can be something that you've been talking about for years.

[26:55]

When you decide, as a leader, to take stock and take action, you can make amazing things happen. So check that out at barbarablackburnonline.com. Download some of those tools, or check out the book Rigor in Your School, a Toolkit for Leaders.

[27:12] Announcer:

Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at principalcenter.com slash radio.

Bring This Expertise to Your School

Interested in professional development, keynotes, or workshops? Send us a message below.

Inquire About Professional Development with Barbara Blackburn

We'll be happy to make an introduction.