[00:01] Announcer:
Welcome to Principal Center Radio, helping you build capacity for instructional leadership. Here's your host, Director of the Principal Center, Dr. Justin Bader. Welcome, everyone, to Principal Center Radio.
[00:13] SPEAKER_01:
I'm your host, Justin Bader, and I'm honored to welcome back to the program my good friend, Dr. Jane Kesey. Jane is the author of 27 books and a widely sought-after expert in leadership development and executive coaching, instructional coaching, and differentiated instruction. And she's the author of the new book, Doable Differentiation, 12 Strategies to Meet the Needs of All Learners.
[00:41]
Jane, welcome back to Principal Center Radio.
[00:44] SPEAKER_00:
Thank you. It is an honor to be here, Justin.
[00:46] SPEAKER_01:
Well, I'm so excited to talk about doable differentiation, because differentiation so often seems like one of those things that we feel like we should be doing, but we never really have time for it. It's intimidating, it's overwhelming, it's too hard for teachers, it's just one more thing. And yet, we know the potential that it has for our students. So, what was it that prompted you to write the book. What did you see happening and what did you see as the opportunity for people to really make differentiation doable?
[01:16] SPEAKER_00:
You know, I wrote my first book on differentiation back in 2006. And it was useful when I was embedded in a school. And we had lots and lots of time for teachers to learn the framework behind it. And I could be in the room doing instructional coaching. And we rolled it out as systems thinking. And we saw real progress.
[01:37]
And I had teachers saying, you know, I can throw out all my undergraduate books because this works. This tells me what I need to know. But it needed some hand-holding. And so, in the years from 2006 through, you know, this book, I was experimenting with, what do teachers really know to make this doable? And I taught a workshop in, I think it was 2017, with...
[01:58]
It was almost all special education or English language learner teachers or others who had very difficult challenges with differentiation, and I boiled down... the workshop to just key strategies using a framework that they could learn in five minutes. And at the end of the day, when I did my typical ask of, what of these strategies are you going to use tomorrow in your classroom? One of the gentlemen said, I'm using them all.
[02:25]
They're all doable. And there was an echo around the room of, yes, this is doable. So that became the title of the book. And I see the opportunity as...
[02:35]
If teachers grasp this two-step process, figure out how, what students the lesson naturally meets the needs of, or how you prefer to teach it, and adjust for the students who just don't learn like that, you've got it. You've got enough going that you're going to get kids to the table ready to learn.
[02:54] SPEAKER_01:
So, Jane, as a starting point, I think it's important to recognize that you've organized the doable differentiation strategies around different cognitive processes, rather than around, you know, kind of the old school multiple intelligences or learning styles that a lot of people are familiar with, why did you make that decision to organize it around cognitive processes instead?
[03:16] SPEAKER_00:
You know, I've been working with this framework of cognitive processes for about 30 years now, and I've done core research. When I show films of students with the different cognitive processes doing math tasks, teachers fall out of their chairs. They can't believe how differently the students approach the same thing. They're evidence-based, they're theory-based, they're research-based, and Just, um, why, you know, they are based on Carl Jung's psychological types, uh, which you've probably heard popularized through the MBTI. No one has to take an instrument to know that these things exist. That some students are more extroverted, some are more introverted, and it does impact how they take in information and learn.
[03:56]
And no one doubts that there are people who are big picture and detail-oriented, which is what, uh, Jung described as being more sensing, as in paying attention to the five senses. or intuitive, as in going with hunches, connections, and analogies. We see this in students. And so you put those together and you've got the four cognitive processes. And what we know from research is school works very well for students with a couple of the cognitive processes. My style takes 82% of the national merit scholarships, even though we're only 20-some percent of the population.
[04:31]
There is a bias. In every school where this research has been done that I know of, alternative schools where students haven't succeeded in our public high schools, about 80 to 90% of the students... are the opposite cognitive process to the ones who are traditionally successful in our schools. So there's a, there's a horrendous bias.
[04:51]
And the students who get left out are the ones who learn by moving, who learn by, uh, solving a problem by touching and picking things up and, and, um, putting things together. They're the kinds of engineers we want on an oil rig when it's in trouble, who can look around and go, oh, there's a ping pong ball, let's tape it down with duct tape and, and put that aside until we can figure out the real solution. You know, they're very hands-on. They don't even know what they're thinking until they start talking about it. We don't necessarily...
[05:20]
They can be annoying to teachers. I had a teacher of that style tell me she got an award in second grade for asking the most questions, and it wasn't given nicely. And the teacher who's the same style sitting next to her said, I got that same award in third grade. We don't honor them. We leave them out. They get bored.
[05:37]
They're frustrated. They think school's not for them. And, uh, that's not... That's not equitable.
[05:42]
It's... And it's not about always teaching to their style. That's the other thing I want to make clear. It's all students need to learn in all four styles.
[05:51]
And, you know, I have a chart in the book that talks about when do we use each style in school. You know, in order to become a really good scientist, you have to do that hands-on experimenting. And everyone has to, you know, if you go through the basic activity for each one of the four styles, if you're looking at the structure and certainty style, the let me know what to do style. That is our grammar, our spelling, our algorithms, our history facts. We all need that. Uh, then you look at the experience and movement.
[06:22]
Just let me do something style. And that's the, you know, it comes into concert band where you're, listening and performing. It's our science experiments. It's anything that's...
[06:32]
It's our field trips where we learn by immersing ourselves. And then you've got the vision and interpretation, which is also called Let Me Follow My Own Lead, who learn by Reading, creative writing, creating their own projects, independent study. Anything they can do on their own, they prefer over to doing with others. And they, of course, need to learn how to express their ideas, work with others. And then you've got the style that I call question and connect, or let me lead as I learn. And they love debate.
[07:02]
They love role play. They're the bigger-than-life students in your classroom that can entertain everyone or get everyone to want to be in a group together or will take you on in a debate. So, you wonder whether you want them in your classroom, you know, the pippy long stockings of the world. So, you've got these four very different groups who all need to learn in each style. They've got to develop that agility, which is another core piece of this book. So, you know, again, two-step differentiation.
[07:30]
You figure out how you like to teach, and almost everyone can do it by just looking at the information and going, haha, yep, that's me, that's what I wanted in school. And then you figure out, how do I get something for my opposite? And it's not every minute of the day. It's not every day of the week. It might be over the course of a unit. It might be by a simple choice, so they're not left out.
[07:52]
But you don't leave them out in the way we traditionally have.
[07:56] SPEAKER_01:
Let's talk about that kind of bottom line of ensuring that students learn, because I think we've probably all seen differentiation attempts that allowed some students to choose not to really learn what the, you know, the goals of the lesson were. So, with that starting point in mind, what do teachers need to consider to make sure that that the learning targets remain the learning targets, right? So that there's differentiation in ways that work, but that keep everyone moving toward the same set of objectives, right? Because we don't want to differentiate necessarily what students learn. There may be pieces of that, but we want students to ultimately all learn what they're supposed to learn as the result of the lesson, right?
[08:34] SPEAKER_00:
Right. So, you could say that that's the first step of differentiation. And I'm going to say I only have two steps, because while I am clear in the book on how to set learning targets, that's an assumption. That's a universal. And you can't differentiate until you've got that. I like using Shakespeare as an example, just because we all have our own experiences with The Great Bard.
[08:56]
And, you know, there are our Lots of learning standards out there that you can relate to Shakespeare. And if the learning target is simply something around knowing the great story, like the story of Hamlet, then some kids can watch the film if their reading skills are still a little bit below grade level. Some can read the actual text, some can read modern translation. But if the learning target is understanding the craft of a poet or a playwright, and being able to watch the construction of a character, Or how the plot builds over... Well, the plot you could get anyway.
[09:30]
But the actual crafting, then everyone needs to be engaged in the text. And that can include watching and having the text in front of you for those who struggle. But you have to have that clarity first. And so, let's make that clear. But too often, just as you're saying, we assess and then assign a content process or product that we think matches their academic abilities...
[09:54]
Rather than trying to figure out what could I do, what strategies would engage every student at the high level that really is required by this content. And so that's what I'm focused in on. It's a dozen strategies, but I think someone, one of the editors counted, and it's over 70 different ways to use them.
[10:13] SPEAKER_01:
So, Jane, a phrase that I've been hearing a lot and probably using a lot is this idea about scaffolding out the rigor. And there's a concern that as we strive to better meet our students' needs, we will design learning in ways that perhaps are designed to meet students where they are or based on who they are and how they learn, but that might kind of undermine... what we want them to learn. What are some of the, uh, the big dimensions in which, uh, people vary and in which we can differentiate?
[10:46]
And how have you designed those into the book?
[10:49] SPEAKER_00:
Let's talk just a little bit about the framework of how you don't end up teaching the kids only who think like you. So, you know, you bring up an interesting point, Justin, about scaffolding out the rigor. And, you know, going back to my work on coaching, I think we all recognize that some of us are more detail-oriented and some of us are more big-picture-oriented. And that relates to the cognitive processes I talk about in this book. We're not really talking about learning styles. We're talking about brain-based ways people perceive the world.
[11:22]
And the detail-oriented teachers tend to structure things. They make very clear step-by-step plans, and that is often a really good thing. But if you take it too far, a kindergartner can do calculus, just filling in the blanks. On the other hand, there are the big picture teachers who, you know, my son actually once got an assignment, do anything you want to tell us, tell me what you learned about World War II. That was the assignment to an eighth grader. There's maybe a few details missing.
[11:49]
And so, you know, those are extreme cases, but we all have one of those tendencies, and we often leave out the students who don't think like us. There's also extroversion and introversion, and the worst mistake we can make is thinking that extroverts don't need to learn to reflect and think, and that introverts don't need to speak up. As a matter of fact, it's not culturally responsive. If you look at the history of African American learning in this country, coming out, the first freed slaves up north, as I understand it, and the references to this are in the book, but when they formed their learning circles, their literacy societies, part of it was a responsibility to help others learn, and so you had to express what you were learning, and so we want introverts learning to speak up and extroverts learning to reflect, big picture people learning to fill in the details, detail-oriented students learning to
[12:43]
leap to the big picture. And as teachers, we want to make sure we aren't stuck in our own style. And so I'm not talking about teaching to learning styles. I'm talking about teaching around the styles. And the strategies are simple ways to do that. So let's, let's take one easy example, and that's what I call curiosity creators.
[13:03]
When you tap into curiosity, you're actually motivating students. There's a part of the brain that pays attention to novelty, and I think it's really useful. Why, as a teacher, do I want to grind away with disinterested students when I can tap into that love of novelty? So one example, a science teacher had called me in to observe her classroom because students just were bored with the readings they had to do. And she handed me one of the readings, and Justin, can I admit, it was on a scale of 1 to 10. It was a 10 on boring.
[13:34]
I used, actually, the research-based strategy of a small glass of wine to spark my creativity to figure out what to do with it. And what I did was a simple thing called key... You've seen them before, an anticipation guide. And you just read the article and find statements or facts that students can agree or disagree with.
[13:54]
The article happened to be on trees. So I said, Minnesota forests have always been just the way they are, was the opening statement. And, you know, more that they could agree or disagree with. And then you have students rate whether they agree or disagree and have what I call, it's a second strategy, a student-centered discussion, where...
[14:13]
the students are in charge of listening, reasoning, justifying, and that's a whole chapter on how you get that going. But they use that strategy to explore what was true and not true in those statements. And whereas the day before, most of the students were looking out the window rather than reading a different article, That day, 100% of the students buckled down and read a very complex and dry text. That's using curiosity to get all kids reading at a higher level. And I want to say, this was a school where about 30% of the students were at grade level. Most were below.
[14:47]
And so, this works. You know, you think they won't be able to read it, but when they're curious, when they want to find out if they're right, they will dig down, realize they can skip a word they don't know, or come back to it, or ask someone, and keep reading. So that's the kind of, you know, you're engaging the students in order to help them want to learn.
[15:08] SPEAKER_01:
Well, Jane, I know one popular way that we might tend to differentiate is to give students choices, right? To give them a choice of what format of response to do, what type of project to do, how to show their learning. How can choice work without creating chaos for both teacher and students? And why is it actually the first strategy you list for doable differentiation?
[15:30] SPEAKER_00:
Well, I listed it first because at its basic level, it's the easiest one to implement. And by that, I mean, we all have a basic need for autonomy that we can also use to motivate students. And so, you know, it can be as simple as, do you want to do the worksheet first, or do you want to talk with your partner about X first? Just that simple choice. You know, we joke about, with toddlers, do you want to put your left shoe on first or your right shoe on first is much better than giving a command. So, there's simple things.
[15:58]
Do you want to do your problem at the whiteboard or at your desk? Do you want to work on this alone or with someone else? So, those are simple... You know, a teacher can have a list of simple choices.
[16:07]
There's also ways you can use choice just with, you know, a simple assignment menu that you've seen before. Problem is, you know, the teachers I've worked with long-term on this... quickly realized that they've always given choices that appeal to students just like them. My husband is a retired teacher, and we used to plan lessons together, and he was in charge of a chess club that had to have an academic component.
[16:29]
And he's my total opposite. I mean, it's truly the English major married to the Phi Ed teacher. So you've got someone in what I call the experience and movement cognitive process, and me in the imagine and, you know, let me, let me, uh, create my own lesson plan, sort of independent study guru English major. And I had suggested that one of the choices be, uh, reading a biography of a great chess player and writing a one-page paper. And he said, no one's going to want to do that. And I said, just put it down so that there's something for each one of the cognitive processes.
[17:01]
And Sure enough, every single quarter, two or three students chose to read a biography and write a paper. A lot of students chose his favorite, which was teach someone at home how to play an easy chess game. You know, and have your parent sign, or parent or guardian sign off on that. Those are, like, the two, as opposite as you can get, ways of demonstrating that you've taken your chess strategies further. But that, that idea of we, do we only, what, what our opposites want almost sound evil to us. Who would want to do that?
[17:29]
Why would I torture a student that way? And so, giving choice within this framework helps you broaden what, uh, what students would want to do, and, and yet you're, you know, going at the same learning targets again. Not, not losing track of that. And does it work? You know, I went from one teacher who only did direct instruction, when she finally got this idea of giving choices, I came into her office for our next coaching meeting, and she had designed a final project with 38 choices, almost 10 for each one of the cognitive processes. And I decided I'd better be in her classroom when she started this for the first time, just to give her a little extra support.
[18:08]
But students were so excited, so motivated, that they were asking if they could do two or three of them. Which doesn't usually happen.
[18:16] SPEAKER_01:
So, Jane, I love the model you have in the book for how we want our students to end up, what kind of traits we want to cultivate, and you have a model that you call STEAM squared. Take us into those additional STEAM characteristics, because we're familiar with science, technology, engineering, art, and mathematics, but you have a separate set of STEAM characteristics that you describe.
[18:39] SPEAKER_00:
You know, obviously, the point of differentiation is academic success. And yet, that is interdependent with all of what we call social and emotional learning. And many of the strategies make sure we don't lose sight of that. That students are all, you know, whether it's because they develop more confidence because they're comfortable in how they're learning, or...
[19:01]
Because we've got a strategy that is very inclusive and builds collaboration in the classroom, or teaches them to persevere, or they aren't panicking anymore because they realize, ha, it's not that I'm dumb, this is just out of my style. And they don't have to know a whole lot about the cognitive processes to realize that. So the strategies include those things. And I developed the acronym STEAM squared to get at that. We all know what STEAM is, you know. Science, technology, engineering, the arts, and mathematics.
[19:33]
And we want, you know, we want success in that. But if you think of the other components, we need students to be successful, and that's the academic component. I want them to thrive. I want them to feel like they're winning in the classroom, which is a little different than just passing standards. I want them engaged. It's far easier for me to teach if students are, whether it's adults or students, if they're engaged.
[19:55]
And that's not entertaining them. That's making sure that they are, you know, working with the content in a productive way. I want them agile so that they don't get stuck when something comes at them in a different way. And I'd like them to mature. I don't know about you, but I don't want to be hold... You know, one of my goals as a parent was, well, number one, never doing calculus again.
[20:15]
I wanted them on their own by the time they were in 12th grade and tackling calculus. And then, um, you know, I wanted them to be successful when they got to university, which means long before that, I couldn't be checking their homework. I couldn't be making sure they were meeting deadlines. I wanted them to mature. And I want to make sure that the strategies we're using have students taking ownership and building that ability to persevere, ability to self-monitor, which is a huge factor in student success. So you think of STEAM squared, successful, thriving, engaged, agile, maturing, pulling strategies that build that as well as the academic success.
[20:52] SPEAKER_01:
So Jane, what are some other strategies that you describe in the book for doable differentiation?
[20:57] SPEAKER_00:
You know, one of my favorites is open questions because it gives everyone access to higher level thinking. And again, it's one of these strategies that a teacher can use in the instant with existing curriculum. Okay, so...
[21:30]
You know, after you've asked specific questions about text, you can ask an open-ended question that, like, uh, in Pride and Prejudice, would you have married Mr. Darcy? Why or why not? And, uh, if you're, if you're the, the male, what do you think you did wrong, you know, that would have kept Elizabeth from marrying you, or whatever? That's a completely open-ended question that...
[21:51]
has to have students thinking about what he did and didn't do that might be misconstrued by the poor, uh, gal who had to suffer through all those yearnings, turnings of his... his moral dilemmas. So, you know, that's, that's simple. You can take an example, you could take a math problem and just leave out the, everything that the book says and say, what do you need to know to solve this problem?
[22:13]
That's Dan Meyer's technique out on, on the internet. So there's all kinds of simple ways to do it, but you can also take it all the way to project-based learning or, you know, a post-hole problem. Post-hole problems, you know, have no Correct answer, it could be something like, how can we reduce waste in this school? You know, food waste. And you don't give a whole lot more information, and you have students, you know, perhaps work in groups to figure that out. But you're playing right into the hands of two of the learning, the cognitive processes who love coming up with their own ways of doing things.
[22:45]
And with just a little structure, you can make sure the other side knows how to proceed with it. And so, once again, you've got a doable process that gets everybody at the table.
[22:56] SPEAKER_01:
Love it. Reminds me of the classic essential question for a unit.
[22:59] SPEAKER_00:
Yes. And then we want to make sure we don't scaffold the meat out of it, which it's only 20% of rigorous tasks are actually implemented at a rigorous level for various reasons. You know, it can be as simple as we can accidentally implement without the rigor as simply as giving too long for a task where students get bored and don't really know where to go with it. Or another classic one that comes out of the research is We don't give them long enough. We're so tied to the bells in the classroom that we take over and do the summary and the justification and the learning notes without giving them the time to process it, and they never actually make the leap that they need to make. Which comes back to open inquiry is not something that I recommend.
[23:42]
Guided inquiry, which takes more time to plan. You know, you have to figure out on these open questions, how do I make sure it still is going to go toward the learning target? That's another whole subject that I do, do cover. I try really hard to give the, each, each of the strategies has, like, the big ideas you need for success, and the concerns people have about using them, and I address those, trying to make sure you've got as many connecting points for success as possible. You know, the other one that sometimes people find sort of strange in this era of technology is what I call big notes. And big notes are just that.
[24:19]
It's, perhaps it's writing on a whiteboard so everyone can see. Or students, if students are looking at one iPad, they can't all possibly be engaged in the same way. Nor can I walk up as the instructor and see what's going on. So, you know, I advocate using chart paper, or whiteboards, or movable manipulatives that are big enough that everyone can see what's going on, or strips of paper, or anything, so that every student has to be involved, that there's a common workspace, and that I, as the facilitator, or the teacher, can immediately see whether a group's on task or not, and I can start organizing in my mind who's, which group's going to report out first, or I might have a card that I can slip them quickly to prompt their thinking, or You know, I can walk up and ask a question, which, by the way, I've already got prepped because...
[25:06]
We want to be prepared for students heading just a little off track that will put them on the right path. So this, you know, open questions, make sure everyone, you know, the introverts are actually engaged, the extroverts are on target with how they're sharing their thoughts, provides a structure for those who need it, lets people add that want more freedom in things. And once again, you're meeting everyone's needs, getting more students engaged, helping them be agile, and you've got an easier job as the teacher.
[25:35] SPEAKER_01:
So the book is Doable Differentiation, 12 Strategies to Meet the Needs of All Learners. And, uh, Jane, if people want to learn more about the book or your many other books or get in touch with you about working together, uh, where's the best place for them to go online?
[25:49] SPEAKER_00:
janekeesey.com. You can contact me through there, and there's some information on all of my books, and a little TEDx talk from a while ago that does talk about the research with the cognitive styles I use in the book.
[26:01] SPEAKER_01:
Well, Jane, it has been a pleasure, as always. Thank you so much for joining me again on Principal Center Radio.
[26:05] SPEAKER_00:
Thank you so much. I hope to see you in person in the future.
[26:09] Announcer:
Thanks for listening to Principal Center Radio. For more great episodes, subscribe on our website at principalcenter.com slash radio.